Reference Array and Design Consideration for the next-generation Event Horizon Telescope

Sheperd S. Doeleman, John Barrett, Lindy Blackburn, Katherine L. Bouman, Avery E. Broderick, Ryan Chaves, Vincent L. Fish, Garret Fitzpatrick, Antonio Fuentes, Mark Freeman, José L. Gómez, Kari Haworth, Janice Houston, Sara Issaoun, Michael D. Johnson, Mark Kettenis, Laurent Loinard, Neil M. Nagar, Gopal Narayanan, Aaron Oppenheimer, Daniel C. M. Palumbo, Nimesh Patel, Dominic W. Pesce, Alexander W. Raymond, Freek Roelofs, Ranjani Srinivasan, Paul Tiede, Jonathan Weintroub, Maciek Wielgus

The images of M87 and Sgr A were scientific milestones, but they were essentially "still" photos captured over a few days. To truly understand the physics of accretion and jet launching, we need to see these monsters in motion. This paper outlines the roadmap for the next-generation Event Horizon Telescope (ngEHT), a transformative upgrade designed to turn the EHT into a high-fidelity movie camera for supermassive black holes.

TL;DR

The ngEHT project aims to upgrade the existing global array by adding ~10 new dishes and implementing simultaneous multi-frequency observing (86, 230, and 345 GHz). This will increase image dynamic range by orders of magnitude, enabling real-time "movies" of black hole environments and the first direct measurements of black hole spin and jet formation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The current EHT is limited by "sparse baseline coverage"—there are massive geographic gaps between telescopes. This results in a low image dynamic range (~10:1), meaning we can see the bright ring but struggle to see the faint, complex structures like the base of a relativistic jet or the "photon ring" predicted by General Relativity.

Furthermore, the atmosphere is incredibly turbulent at the high frequencies (230–345 GHz) needed to see through the plasma surrounding a black hole. Current observations are limited to short "campaigns" because they require perfect weather across the entire globe simultaneously. The ngEHT seeks to solve these issues through better geography, wider bandwidth, and smarter calibration.

Methods

The authors employ a rigorous design process involving:

  • Synthetic Observation Pipeline: Using the ngehtsim library, they simulate how different array configurations would "see" black holes based on theoretical models.
  • Optimization Metrics: They use two key metrics to evaluate potential sites: the Filling Fraction (FF), which measures how well the array samples spatial frequencies (the $u,v$ plane), and Point Source Sensitivity (PSS), which quantifies the array's overall sensitivity.
  • Frequency Phase Transfer (FPT): A novel technique where lower-frequency data (86 GHz) is used to calibrate the phase of higher-frequency data (345 GHz). This effectively "undoes" atmospheric blurring, allowing for longer integration times and higher sensitivity.
  • Phased Site Selection: A two-stage optimization to select the best locations for new 6–9 meter dishes from a pool of 44 candidate sites.

Datasets

The paper relies on:

  • GRMHD Simulations: High-fidelity General Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamic simulations of M87 and Sgr A serve as the "ground truth" for testing array performance.
  • MERRA-2 Weather Database: A decade of historical atmospheric data was used to model the "opacity" (transparency) of the sky at potential telescope sites, ensuring the selected locations are dry enough for sub-millimeter radio astronomy.
  • ETHER Sample: A newly compiled database of the most promising individual black hole targets for future observations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Anchor" Strategy: You don't need a massive dish at every site. By pairing a small, new ngEHT dish (6–9m) with a massive "anchor" site like ALMA, you can achieve the sensitivity needed to detect faint signals across intercontinental distances.
  • Simultaneous Multi-Frequency is Essential: Observing at 86, 230, and 345 GHz at the same time isn't just for "color" images; it's a calibration necessity. The 86 GHz band acts as a guide star to stabilize the more difficult 345 GHz observations.
  • New Operating Modes: The ngEHT moves away from once-a-year campaigns toward Long Term Monitoring (observing for months to track jet evolution) and Target of Opportunity (reacting to flares or gravitational wave events).

Key Results

  • Dynamic Range Boost: The ngEHT is expected to achieve an image dynamic range exceeding 1000:1, a 100-fold improvement over the first EHT results.
  • Bandwidth Expansion: The system will digitize up to 32 GHz of aggregate bandwidth, providing a 4x improvement in net sensitivity.
  • Fiducial Phase 1 Array: The authors identified three high-priority sites for immediate expansion: La Palma (CNI), Coquimbo, Chile (LCO), and Baja California, Mexico (SPM).
  • Cinema Mode: Simulations show that with the ngEHT's improved coverage, researchers can reconstruct movies of Sgr A* with 5-minute time resolution, sufficient to track plasma orbiting near the event horizon.

Limitations and Future Work

  • The Data Deluge: Recording at 128 Gbps generates Petabytes of data. While cloud processing is an option for correlation, the physical shipment of hard drives (or SSDs) remains the only viable way to move this much data from remote sites like the South Pole or the Andes.
  • Atmospheric Constraints: Even with FPT, 345 GHz observing is extremely sensitive to water vapor. The array's performance will always be somewhat at the mercy of global weather patterns.
  • Computational Cost: Correlating and imaging data from a 20+ station array with high bandwidth requires massive scaling of current software (like the DiFX correlator).

Reference: Doeleman, S. S., et al. (2023). Reference Array and Design Consideration for the next-generation Event Horizon Telescope. Draft version August 21, 2023. arXiv:2306.08787v3.

Summary updated

Abstract

We describe the process to design, architect, and implement a transformative enhancement of the Event Horizon Telescope (ngEHT). This program - the next-generation Event Horizon Telescope (ngEHT) - will form a networked global array of radio dishes capable of making high-fidelity real-time movies of supermassive black holes (SMBH) and their emanating jets. This builds upon the EHT principally by deploying additional modest-diameter dishes to optimized geographic locations to enhance the current global mm/submm wavelength Very Long Baseline Interferometric (VLBI) array, which has, to date, utilized mostly pre-existing radio telescopes. The ngEHT program further focuses on observing at three frequencies simultaneously for increased sensitivity and Fourier spatial frequency coverage. Here, the concept, science goals, design considerations, station siting and instrument prototyping are discussed, and a preliminary reference array to be implemented in phases is described.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{doeleman2023reference,
  author = {Sheperd S. Doeleman and John Barrett and Lindy Blackburn and Katherine L. Bouman and Avery E. Broderick and Ryan Chaves and Vincent L. Fish and Garret Fitzpatrick and Antonio Fuentes and Mark Freeman and José L. Gómez and Kari Haworth and Janice Houston and Sara Issaoun and Michael D. Johnson and Mark Kettenis and Laurent Loinard and Neil M. Nagar and Gopal Narayanan and Aaron Oppenheimer and Daniel C. M. Palumbo and Nimesh Patel and Dominic W. Pesce and Alexander W. Raymond and Freek Roelofs and Ranjani Srinivasan and Paul Tiede and Jonathan Weintroub and Maciek Wielgus},
  title = {{Reference Array and Design Consideration for the next-generation Event Horizon Telescope}},
  booktitle = {Galaxies},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/galaxies11050107},
}
Figure