Reducing curtailment of wind electricity in China by employing electric boilers for heat and pumped hydro for energy storage

Ning Zhang, Xi Lu, Michael B. McElroy, Chris Nielsen, Xinyu Chen, Yu Deng, Chongqing KangApplied Energy 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of integrating massive amounts of wind power into China's electricity grid, which is heavily reliant on combined heat and power (CHP) plants. By simulating the West Inner Mongolia (WIM) power system, the authors demonstrate that a combination of pumped hydro storage (PHS) and electric boilers (EBs) can significantly reduce wind curtailment and CO2 emissions, offering a cost-effective solution for a cleaner energy future.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China has rapidly expanded its wind power capacity, becoming a global leader. However, a significant portion of this potential energy is wasted due to "curtailment," meaning it's not used when generated. This problem is particularly acute in northern China, where the electricity grid is dominated by Combined Heat and Power (CHP) plants. These plants are essential for providing heat during winter but are inflexible; they must generate electricity whenever they produce heat, often leading to an oversupply of electricity when wind power is also abundant. This forces grid operators to shut down wind turbines, wasting clean energy and increasing reliance on fossil fuels. The paper aims to quantify the benefits of two proposed solutions – pumped hydro storage (PHS) and electric boilers (EBs) – in mitigating this curtailment in a representative region, West Inner Mongolia (WIM).

Methods

The core of the study is an improved unit-commitment (UC) based power system chronological simulation. This sophisticated model allows for a detailed, hour-by-hour analysis of the entire power system's operation, considering various constraints. What makes this approach novel is its ability to:

  • Simulate both power and heating systems simultaneously: This is crucial for understanding the interplay between CHP plants, which serve both needs, and the impact of wind power on this balance.
  • Incorporate practical operational details: The model accounts for the specific characteristics of CHP, PHS, and EB operations, as well as wind power variability.
  • Evaluate year-round operation: Unlike simpler models, this approach captures the seasonal variations in demand and generation, particularly the critical heating season.

The simulation was used to compare a "business-as-usual" (BAU) scenario with various alternative scenarios that incorporate different levels of wind power, PHS, and EBs.

Datasets

  • NASA-assimilated meteorological database (GEOS-5): Used to derive hourly wind speed data with a spatial resolution of 1/3 degree longitude by 1/4 degree latitude.
  • Regional data for West Inner Mongolia (WIM): This includes historical and projected data on electricity demand, heat demand, CHP capacity, and wind power capacity.
  • GE 2.5 MW wind turbine power curve: Used to calculate hourly wind power output based on wind speed.
  • Regional building codes and temperature data: Used to model heating demand.

The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather utilizes existing meteorological and regional energy data to create a realistic simulation environment for the WIM power system.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CHP inflexibility is the root cause: The paper clearly illustrates how the mandatory heat production from CHP plants during winter creates an inflexible base load that directly conflicts with abundant wind power, leading to curtailment.
  • EBs are surprisingly effective and cost-efficient: While PHS is a known storage solution, the study highlights electric boilers (EBs) as a particularly cost-effective way to absorb excess wind power. By using wind electricity to generate heat, EBs not only reduce curtailment but also decrease the demand on CHP plants, freeing them up for more flexible operation.
  • Synergy is key: The combination of PHS and EBs offers the greatest benefits. PHS can handle short-term fluctuations, while EBs are excellent for absorbing prolonged periods of wind surplus, especially when PHS capacity is limited.
  • Policy reform is essential: The authors emphasize that current pricing mechanisms in China, which often use flat, 24-hour electricity rates, do not incentivize the deployment or operation of PHS and EBs. Without appropriate price signals, these crucial technologies may not be economically viable.

Key Results

  • Without PHS or EBs: Increasing wind capacity to 40 GW in WIM would lead to a significant curtailment of 20.4% of wind electricity, with a CO2 reduction cost of $25.3/ton compared to the BAU scenario.
  • With PHS: Adding 3.6 GW of PHS to 40 GW of wind capacity reduces curtailment to 15.7% and lowers the CO2 reduction cost to $20.2/ton.
  • With EBs: Introducing EBs with a capacity of 30% of the peak heat demand (approximately 6.2 GW) alongside 40 GW of wind power (and no PHS) reduces curtailment and achieves a CO2 reduction cost of $19.4/ton.
  • Optimal combination: The most cost-effective scenario identified is a combination of 40 GW wind power, 3.6 GW PHS, and 6.2 GW EBs. This scenario reduces CO2 emissions by 43.5 million tons (compared to BAU) at a cost of only $16.0/ton.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified EB model: The study uses a simplified model for EBs, assuming they operate only when wind power is in surplus and that their heat output directly replaces CHP heat. Future work could explore more complex operational strategies for EBs.
  • Price-incentive policy: The paper strongly advocates for policy reforms, particularly real-time pricing mechanisms, to ensure the profitability of PHS and EB facilities. This suggests that future research could focus on designing and evaluating such policies.
  • Broader system integration: While the study focuses on WIM, the authors suggest that similar analyses could be conducted for other regions in China and globally to understand the broader applicability of these solutions.
  • Technological advancements: The paper implicitly assumes current technologies. Future research could consider the impact of advancements in PHS and EB technologies on cost-effectiveness and integration capabilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Accommodating variable wind power poses a critical challenge for electric power systems that are heavily dependent on combined-heat-and-power (CHP) plants, as is the case for north China. Pumped hydro storage (PHS) and electric boilers (EBs) are two of the strongest technological options under discussion in China to address this challenge, but rigorous quantitative analyses of their effectiveness rooted in actual system data are lacking. An improved unit-commitment based power system chronological simulation is applied to evaluate potential benefits from PHS and EBs in West Inner Mongolia (WIM), where CHP capacity is projected to increase to 33.8 GW by 2020. A business-as-usual (BAU) reference model assumes deployment of 20 GW of wind capacity. Compared to BAU, expanding wind capacity to 40 GW would allow for a reduction in CO2 emissions of 33.9 million tons, but at a relatively high cost of US$25.3/ton, reflecting primarily high associated curtailment of wind electricity (20.4%). A number of scenarios adding PHS and/or EBs combined with higher levels of wind capacity are evaluated. The best case indicates that a combination of PHS (3.6 GW) and EBs (6.2 GW) together with 40 GW of wind capacity would reduce CO2 emissions by 43.5 million tons compared to BAU and at a lower cost of US$16.0/ton. Achieving this outcome will require a price-incentive policy designed to ensure the profitability of both PHS and EB facilities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2015reducing,
  author = {Ning Zhang and Xi Lu and Michael B. McElroy and Chris Nielsen and Xinyu Chen and Yu Deng and Chongqing Kang},
  title = {{Reducing curtailment of wind electricity in China by employing electric boilers for heat and pumped hydro for energy storage}},
  booktitle = {Applied Energy},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1016/j.apenergy.2015.10.147},
}
Figure