Redesigning Stochastic Environments for Maximized Utility

Sarah Keren, Avigdor Gal, Erez Karpas, Luis Enrique Pineda, Shlomo Zilberstein

Abstract

Traditional AI research focuses on increasing agent intelligence to handle environmental uncertainty. This paper introduces the Utility Maximizing Design (UMD) framework, which instead optimizes the environment itself to maximize agent performance. By treating environment modification as a planning problem, the authors demonstrate how targeted changes—such as reducing the probability of action failure—can significantly improve expected utility within a fixed budget.

Introduction: Flipping the Script on Agent Performance

Most AI research aims to make agents "smarter" so they can navigate complex, uncertain worlds. However, in many real-world scenarios—such as hospitals, warehouses, or automated homes—the environment is controllable. The Utility Maximizing Design (UMD) framework addresses a critical question: How can we make the world "better" for the agent?

In stochastic environments, agents face unpredictability; a vacuum robot might slip on a rug, or a human worker might take a sub-optimal path. While redesigning these spaces can improve efficiency, it incurs costs. UMD provides a formal method for finding the optimal set of modifications that maximize system utility while staying within a specific budget.

The Utility Maximizing Design (UMD) Framework

The UMD model consists of four primary components: the environment (modeled as a Markov Decision Process or MDP), the agents operating within it, the system utility criteria, and the initial state.

Redesign as Planning

A key technical contribution is a novel "compilation" technique that transforms the environment redesign problem into a standard planning problem. This allows researchers to leverage existing, off-the-shelf AI solvers to identify the most effective modifications without building custom optimization engines from scratch.

The authors propose using informed search to find optimal modifications efficiently. They developed an admissible heuristic for the "Equi-Reward" (ER-UMD) case, where the agent and the system designer share identical goals, such as ensuring a floor is cleaned with minimal energy expenditure.

Key Insights: The Power of Subtle Changes

A major takeaway from this research is that effective redesign is not limited to removing physical obstacles or adding walls. Improving the reliability of an action—essentially changing the probability distribution of an outcome—is a powerful tool for maximizing utility.

Example of environment redesign: adding a rug (yellow) to a living room to reduce robot slippage and improve navigation reliability.

As shown in the figure above, a "subtle" modification like placing a non-slip surface in a high-traffic area can drastically reduce the stochasticity of a robot's movement. This leads to higher overall performance and more predictable behavior without requiring a more complex or expensive agent.

Experimental Evaluation and Results

The researchers evaluated UMD using benchmarks from the International Planning Competition (IPPC), including Box World, Blocks World, and Triangle Tire. These domains represent stochastic shortest-path MDPs, providing a rigorous testing ground.

  • Budget vs. Performance: In nearly all tested domains, increasing the redesign budget led to a measurable reduction in the expected cost for the agent to complete its task.
  • Search Efficiency: Informed heuristic search consistently outperformed exhaustive search methods, proving that redesigning complex environments is computationally feasible for real-world applications.
  • Domain Sensitivity: The effectiveness of specific heuristics varied by domain, suggesting that while the UMD framework is general, search strategies should be tailored to the specific structure of the environment.

Limitations and Future Directions

While successful in most domains, the framework struggled with "Exploding Blocks World," where high-entropy or destructive stochasticity is present. This suggests that certain types of extreme uncertainty may require different modeling approaches. Future work will explore more diverse heuristic techniques to improve scalability and handle higher-dimensional, high-fidelity environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

​We present the Utility Maximizing Design (UMD) model​ for optimally redesigning stochastic environments to achieve maximized performance. This model suits well contemporary ​​applications that involve the design of environments where robots and humans co-exist an co-operate, e.g., vacuum cleaning robot. We discuss two special cases of the UMD model. The first is the equi-reward UMD (ER-UMD)​ ​in which the agents and the system share a utility function, such as for the vacuum cleaning robot. The second is the goal​ ​recognition design (GRD) setting, discussed in the literature, in which system and agent utilities are independent. To find the set of optimal​​ modifications to apply to a UMD model, we propose the use of heuristic search, extending previous methods used for GRD settings. After specifying the conditions for optimality in the​ general case, we present an admissible heuristic for the ER-UMD case. We also present a novel compilation that embeds​ the redesign process into a planning problem, allowing use of any off-the-shelf solver to find the best way to modify an environment when a design budget is specified. Our evaluation shows the feasibility of the approach using standard bench​​marks from the probabilistic planning competition.​
BibTeX
@inproceedings{keren2017redesigning,
  author = {Sarah Keren and Avigdor Gal and Erez Karpas and Luis Enrique Pineda and Shlomo Zilberstein},
  title = {{Redesigning Stochastic Environments for Maximized Utility}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1609/aaai.v31i1.11095},
}
Figure