Rectification properties of conically shaped nanopores: consequences of miniaturization

Jan‐Frederik Pietschmann, Marie-Thérèse Wolfram, Martin Burger, C. Trautmann, Giang D. Nguyen, Matthew Pevarnik, V. Bayer, Zuzanna S. Siwy

Abstract

Nanopores have attracted significant scientific interest as templates for biological sensors and model systems for understanding transport phenomena at the nanoscale. While previous research has focused on the effect of pore opening diameter on ionic transport, this article presents systematic studies on the dependence of ion transport properties on pore length. Specifically, we examine ion current rectification in conically shaped nanopores with homogeneous surface charges. We find that reducing the length of these nanopores significantly lowers their ability to rectify ion current. However, rectification in short pores can be enhanced by tailoring surface charge and the shape of the narrow opening. Simulations were performed using MsSimPore, a software package based on a 1D reduction of the Poisson-Nernst-Planck (PNP) equations that includes bulk electrolyte reservoirs, a feature critical for modeling short pores.

Introduction

Nanopores are nanoscale channels capable of regulating ion flow. When these pores possess asymmetric geometries, such as a conical shape, and charged walls, they exhibit ion current rectification. This phenomenon allows ions to flow more easily in one direction than the other, effectively acting as an ionic diode. This property is fundamental for applications in biosensing, DNA sequencing, and ionic logic circuits.

As the field moves toward integrated "lab-on-a-chip" devices, membranes are becoming thinner, necessitating a deeper understanding of how pore length affects performance. Standard 1D mathematical models often fail for short pores because they neglect "access resistance"—the variation in ion concentration and electric potential just outside the pore entrances.

Methodology

To address these challenges, the authors developed MsSimPore, a software package designed to solve the Poisson-Nernst-Planck (PNP) equations efficiently.

Schematic representation of a conically shaped nanopore in a PET membrane, showing the small opening ($r_s$), large opening ($r_L$), and the surrounding electrolyte baths.

MsSimPore utilizes a 1D reduction of the PNP model but incorporates explicit bulk electrolyte reservoirs at both ends of the pore. This allows the model to capture complex variations at the pore entrances, a feature typically requiring computationally expensive 3D simulations. The tool employs a stable hybrid discontinuous Galerkin finite element solver, capable of handling high surface charge densities up to -2 e/nm². The model was validated against experimental data from 12-µm long conical nanopores etched in polyethylene terephthalate (PET) foils.

Results and Discussion

The study reveals several critical insights into the physics of miniaturized nanopores:

The Miniaturization Penalty

A primary finding is that rectification decays sharply as pore length decreases. For instance, a 6-nm wide opening that exhibits strong rectification in a 12-µm membrane becomes nearly ohmic (behaving like a simple resistor) when the membrane thickness is reduced to approximately 90 nm.

Optimal Surface Charge

Counterintuitively, increasing surface charge does not indefinitely improve rectification. The simulations identified an optimal surface charge density—approximately -0.4 to -0.5 e/nm² for the studied geometry—that maximizes the rectification factor. Increasing the charge beyond this point leads to a decrease in rectification.

Quantitative analysis of (a) rectification and (b) ion selectivity as a function of surface charge density.

Selectivity vs. Rectification

High ion selectivity does not inherently guarantee high rectification. In short pores, the "depletion zone"—an area of low ion concentration that restricts flow in one direction—is less effective, even if the pore remains highly selective to specific ions.

Geometric Recovery

For applications constrained to short pores, rectification can be partially recovered by modifying the pore's geometry. Increasing the cone's opening angle or adopting a "curved" (cigar-like) profile rather than a strictly linear cone can enhance the diode-like behavior.

Conclusion

This research highlights the significant impact of pore length on the transport properties of conically shaped nanopores. While miniaturization poses challenges for ionic rectification, these effects can be mitigated through precise control of surface chemistry and pore geometry. The MsSimPore software provides a robust and efficient framework for exploring these parameters, offering a valuable tool for the design of next-generation nanofluidic devices.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nanopores attracted a great deal of scientific interest as templates for biological sensors as well as model systems to understand transport phenomena at the nanoscale. The experimental and theoretical analysis of nanopores has been so far focused on understanding the effect of the pore opening diameter on ionic transport. In this article we present systematic studies on the dependence of ion transport properties on the pore length. Particular attention was given to the effect of ion current rectification exhibited in conically shaped nanopores with homogeneous surface charges. We found that reducing the length of conically shaped nanopores significantly lowered their ability to rectify ion current. However, rectification properties of short pores can be enhanced by tailoring the surface charge and the shape of the narrow opening. Furthermore we analyzed the relationship of the rectification behavior and ion selectivity for different pore lengths. All simulations were performed using MsSimPore, a software package for solving the Poisson-Nernst-Planck (PNP) equations. It is based on a novel finite element solver and allows for simulations up to surface charge densities of -2 e per nm(2). MsSimPore is based on 1D reduction of the PNP model, but allows for a direct treatment of the pore with bulk electrolyte reservoirs, a feature which was previously used in higher dimensional models only. MsSimPore includes these reservoirs in the calculations, a property especially important for short pores, where the ionic concentrations and the electric potential vary strongly inside the pore as well as in the regions next to the pore entrance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pietschmann2013rectification,
  author = {Jan‐Frederik Pietschmann and Marie-Thérèse Wolfram and Martin Burger and C. Trautmann and Giang D. Nguyen and Matthew Pevarnik and V. Bayer and Zuzanna S. Siwy},
  title = {{Rectification properties of conically shaped nanopores: consequences of miniaturization}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1039/c3cp53105h},
}

Loading related content...

Figure