Recruitment of family caregivers of persons with dementia: Lessons learned from a pilot randomized controlled trial

Sama Joshi, Taeyoung Park, Lilla Brody, Kiana Cruz, Priya Mukhi, M. Carrington Reid, Keela Herr, Karl Pillemer, Catherine RiffinFrontiers in Pain Research 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Family caregivers play an essential role in supporting the health and well-being of older adults with dementia, a population projected to increase rapidly over the coming decades. Enrolling caregivers of people with dementia (PWD) in research studies is vital to generating the evidence necessary to support broader implementation of efficacious intervention programs in real-world care delivery, but a range of challenges impede recruitment and enrollment of sufficiently large and representative sample sizes. In this article, we characterize the challenges and lessons learned from recruiting caregivers of PWD to participate in a pilot randomized control trial. We utilize Bronfenbrenner's ecological model to categorize the challenges into three levels: individual, community and institutional. We found that establishing rapport and maintaining flexibility with participants was crucial for motivating individuals to enroll in our study. Building trust with local communities by collaborating with support group leaders, appointing a co-investigator who is already embedded within a given community, and establishing equitable partnerships with organizations increased recruitment rates. At the institutional level, engaging experts in regulatory affairs and geriatrics may help overcome barriers in obtaining approval from institutional review boards. We also recommend using research registries of individuals who offer their contact information to researchers. The lessons learned from our research—including the challenges and potential solutions to overcome them—may promote more effective and efficient recruitment in future research.

Addressing the Recruitment Crisis in Dementia Research

As the global population of older adults with dementia grows, the reliance on family caregivers has become a cornerstone of public health. While developing interventions to support these caregivers is critical, clinical trials in this field frequently struggle with recruitment, often resulting in small, racially and ethnically homogeneous sample sizes. This "recruitment crisis" limits the statistical power and real-world applicability of research findings, particularly for underrepresented populations.

This paper addresses these challenges by identifying specific barriers and offering actionable solutions based on a pilot randomized controlled trial (RCT). By applying a strategic roadmap, researchers can engage diverse participants even under difficult circumstances, such as the global COVID-19 pandemic.

Methodology and the Ecological Model

The researchers conducted a pilot RCT evaluating the Pain Identification and Communication Toolkit (PICT), a manualized intervention designed to help caregivers recognize and manage pain in persons with dementia (PWD).

To analyze their recruitment process, they applied Bronfenbrenner’s ecological model, which provides a holistic framework for understanding human development within various environmental systems. Challenges and solutions were categorized into three levels:

  • Individual (Microsystem): Caregiver-specific factors such as extreme time constraints, high stress levels, and personal motivation.
  • Community (Mesosystem/Exosystem): Reaching underrepresented groups and navigating complex caregiver support networks.
  • Institutional (Macrosystem): Regulatory hurdles, including Institutional Review Board (IRB) approvals and the effective use of research registries.

Recruitment strategies were multi-modal, involving presentations to support groups, direct outreach at clinics, community flyers, and online research registries. Notably, the study period (March 2019 – August 2021) required a mid-trial transition from in-person to fully virtual recruitment due to COVID-19.

Strategic Barriers and Solutions

The core of the study's success lay in its ability to adapt to the specific needs of the caregiving population. The following table summarizes the key barriers identified and the corresponding solutions implemented across the three ecological levels.

Summary of recruitment barriers and solutions across individual, community, and institutional levels.

Key Insights for Future Research

The "lessons learned" from the PICT pilot RCT offer several high-impact strategies for future studies:

  1. Prioritize Rapport and Flexibility: Caregivers often live in "crisis mode." The research team found that flexibility in scheduling and using concise, "low-mental-load" communication was vital. Adapting the research process to the participants' lives, rather than vice versa, is essential for retention.
  2. Leverage Embedded "Insiders": For community-level recruitment, passive methods like flyers are often insufficient. Appointing a co-investigator already embedded in the target community and collaborating with established support group leaders significantly boosted trust and enrollment.
  3. Streamline Regulatory Processes: One of the most practical insights was the transition to oral consent. Traditional, lengthy written consent forms can be a major deterrent for stressed caregivers. Moving to a verbal process (with IRB approval) reduced participant burden and streamlined the enrollment pipeline.
  4. Utilize Specialized Registries: While broad national registries are available, the authors found higher success with institution- or county-specific registries. These localized databases often carry an inherent layer of trust and familiarity that encourages participation.

Results and Discussion

Despite the unprecedented challenges of the pandemic, the study achieved a remarkably high response rate. Of the 155 individuals approached, only 33 (approximately 21%) declined to participate. This suggests that the strategies used to frame the study’s value and reduce participant burden were highly effective.

The transition to virtual recruitment actually expanded the study's reach. While 17 participants were enrolled in the first year (in-person), an additional 17 were enrolled after the shift to virtual methods, despite the added stressors of the pandemic. Furthermore, the final sample of 34 participants achieved a higher degree of racial and ethnic diversity (27% non-White) than is typical for many dementia caregiving pilot studies.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While this pilot study provides a valuable framework, the authors acknowledge limitations, including the small sample size ($N=34$) and the persistent issue of "internet inequity" among rural and lower-socioeconomic populations.

Future research should focus on:

  • Investing in multi-lingual recruitment materials and diverse staff to better reach non-English speaking populations.
  • Advocating for the legitimization of oral consent and other low-burden regulatory processes within IRBs.
  • Developing long-term, equitable partnerships with community organizations to move beyond "transactional" recruitment models.

Summary updated

Abstract

Family caregivers play an essential role in supporting the health and well-being of older adults with dementia, a population projected to increase rapidly over the coming decades. Enrolling caregivers of people with dementia (PWD) in research studies is vital to generating the evidence necessary to support broader implementation of efficacious intervention programs in real-world care delivery, but a range of challenges impede recruitment and enrollment of sufficiently large and representative sample sizes. In this article, we characterize the challenges and lessons learned from recruiting caregivers of PWD to participate in a pilot randomized control trial. We utilize Bronfenbrenner's ecological model to categorize the challenges into three levels: <i>individual</i> (i.e., understanding caregivers' time constraints and motivations), <i>community</i> (i.e., reaching underrepresented populations and accessing caregiver support groups) and <i>institutional</i> (i.e., obtaining informed consent and navigating research registries). We found that establishing rapport and maintaining flexibility with participants was crucial for motivating individuals to enroll in our study. Building trust with local communities by collaborating with support group leaders, appointing a co-investigator who is already embedded within a given community, and establishing equitable partnerships with organizations increased recruitment rates. At the institutional level, engaging experts in regulatory affairs and geriatrics may help overcome barriers in obtaining approval from institutional review boards. We also recommend using research registries of individuals who offer their contact information to researchers. The lessons learned from our research-including the challenges and potential solutions to overcome them-may promote more effective and efficient recruitment in future research.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{joshi2023recruitment,
  author = {Sama Joshi and Taeyoung Park and Lilla Brody and Kiana Cruz and Priya Mukhi and M. Carrington Reid and Keela Herr and Karl Pillemer and Catherine Riffin},
  title = {{Recruitment of family caregivers of persons with dementia: Lessons learned from a pilot randomized controlled trial}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Pain Research},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpain.2023.1125914},
}
Figure