Reconfigurable Intelligent Surface assisted Multi-user Communications: How Many Reflective Elements Do We Need?

Hongliang Zhang, Boya Di, Zhu Han, H. Vincent Poor, Lingyang Song

Abstract

Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (RIS) are a promising technology for 6G, but their deployment requires understanding the physical limits of their performance. This paper investigates the fundamental limits of RIS in multi-user communications by deriving the asymptotic system capacity as the number of reflective elements ($N$) approaches infinity. The authors provide a practical framework to determine the exact number of elements required to achieve a target percentage of maximum capacity, helping engineers avoid over-designing these surfaces.

Introduction

Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (RISs) act as "smart mirrors" for radio waves, capable of shaping the wireless environment to improve signal quality. While previous research established that the received Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) can increase with the square of the number of elements ($N^2$), a critical question remained: How many elements are actually enough?

In a multi-user scenario, adding more elements doesn't increase capacity indefinitely. Physical constraints, such as path loss and the geometry of the RIS, eventually lead to diminishing returns. This paper tackles the challenge of quantifying the relationship between the number of elements and the system sum-rate.

Methodology

The authors model a downlink multi-user MISO (Multiple-Input Single-Output) system where a Base Station (BS) with multiple antennas serves several single-antenna users via an RIS. Key technical components include:

  • Zero-Forcing (ZF) Precoding: A standard, low-complexity method used at the Base Station to cancel out interference between users.
  • Asymptotic Analysis: Using the Central Limit Theorem and Random Matrix Theory, the authors derive the system's capacity as $N$ becomes very large.
  • Path Loss Modeling: A detailed model accounts for incident angles and the physical size of the reflective elements, moving beyond simplified distance-based models.
  • Capacity Ratio ($\epsilon$): A metric representing the ratio of the current sum-rate to the theoretical maximum capacity (with an infinitely large RIS) to determine the "efficiency" of a specific RIS size.

The theoretical derivations were validated using Monte Carlo simulations based on 3GPP standards for 5G/6G channel modeling.

Key Insights

  • Capacity Saturation: Contrary to the idea that "bigger is always better," the system capacity eventually hits a ceiling. As the RIS grows, the average distance from the elements to the users increases, and the "effective" gain per element decreases.
  • Phase Shift Independence: A surprising finding is that when $N$ is sufficiently large, the specific phase shifts of the RIS elements don't influence the distribution of the SNR. This suggests that for massive surfaces, random phase shifts might perform similarly to optimized ones in terms of average behavior.
  • The Antenna-Element Trade-off: There is a direct trade-off between the number of antennas at the Base Station ($M$) and the number of elements on the RIS ($N$). Increasing BS antennas allows for a significantly smaller (and cheaper) RIS to achieve the same target sum-rate.

Results and Discussion

Numerical results show that the derived theoretical results provide a very tight approximation of the simulated system capacity. As shown in Figure 4, the system capacity saturates as the number of elements $N$ increases, reaching approximately 71.5 bit/s/Hz in a setup with 5 users and 10 BS antennas.

System capacity vs. number of RIS elements, showing saturation and the tight fit between theoretical and simulated results.

To determine the practical size of an RIS, the authors analyzed the capacity ratio $\epsilon$. As illustrated in Figure 5, achieving 75% of the maximum system capacity ($\eta = 0.75$) with an antenna-to-user ratio of $\mu=20$ requires roughly $8 \times 10^6$ elements. For the parameters used (0.02m elements), this translates to an RIS with a side length of about 56.7 meters. Notably, when the number of BS antennas equals the number of users ($\mu=1$), the system fails to effectively leverage the RIS, confirming that the BS must have more antennas than users for optimal performance.

Ratio of sum-rate to system capacity ($\epsilon$) vs. number of reflective elements for different antenna-to-user ratios ($\mu$).

Limitations and Future Work

While providing a foundational framework, the study assumes perfect Channel State Information (CSI), which is difficult to obtain for millions of elements. Future research should address the overhead of channel estimation, the impact of user mobility, and scenarios where direct Line-of-Sight (LoS) links between the BS and users are not blocked.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zhang2021reconfigurable,
  author = {Hongliang Zhang and Boya Di and Zhu Han and H. Vincent Poor and Lingyang Song},
  title = {{Reconfigurable Intelligent Surface assisted Multi-user Communications: How Many Reflective Elements Do We Need?}},
  journal = {IEEE Wireless Communications Letters},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1109/lwc.2021.3058637},
}
Figure