Reasoning, Metareasoning, and Mathematical Truth: Studies of Theorem Proving under Limited Resources

Eric Horvitz, Adrian C. Klein

Introduction

In classical logic, a mathematical claim is treated as a binary certainty: it is either proven or unproven. However, in real-world scenarios, agents—whether human or artificial—operate under strict resource constraints. A robot navigating a complex environment or a system managing a critical infrastructure cannot always afford to wait for a definitive proof from a theorem prover. This paper explores the intersection of decision theory and formal logic, proposing a framework to treat theorem proving as a resource-allocation problem under uncertainty.

The authors address the gap between logical certainty and plausible reasoning. They argue that the progress of an automated search provides valuable information even before a proof is completed. By formalizing this "belief" into a rigorous Bayesian model, they enable agents to make rational, decision-theoretic choices about whether to continue deliberating or to take immediate action based on the current probability of truth.

The researchers focus on the matrix method of propositional theorem proving. In this context, the task is structured as a search for an "open path"—a truth assignment that satisfies the negation of the theorem. If no such path exists, the theorem is logically true.

The core insight is that the absence of a counterexample in a partially explored search space is itself a piece of probabilistic evidence. Using Bayesian updating, the system calculates the probability of truth $p(w)$ given that a portion of the search space $S$ has been explored. This allows the agent to update its confidence about a theorem's validity in real-time.

Probability of finding an open path (counterexample) as a function of the portion of the search space explored, comparing unsorted search to a preordering heuristic.

Heuristics play a critical role in this process. As shown in the empirical results, a good pre-ordering heuristic does more than just find a proof faster; it acts as a "belief accelerator." For instance, after exploring only 40% of the search space, a sorted search might yield an 84% probability of truth, whereas an unsorted search provides significantly less confidence.

Metareasoning and the Value of Computation

To bridge the gap between belief and action, the authors introduce a metareasoning framework based on the Expected Value of Computation (EVC). This involves calculating the "cost" of delayed action (the time spent searching) against the "benefit" of increased certainty.

The decision to stop searching is governed by a threshold probability ($p^*$). This threshold is derived by combining the current probability of truth with the utilities of different outcomes, such as the cost of a false positive versus a false negative. When the prover’s confidence exceeds this threshold, the Net Expected Value of Computation (NEVC) becomes negative, signaling that the agent should stop thinking and start acting.

Evolution of belief bounds over time and the corresponding utility analysis used to identify the optimal threshold for action.

Empirical Validation and Limitations

The framework was validated using a synthetic dataset of 750 randomly generated propositional matrices. Each matrix consisted of 20 clauses with 3 literals each, drawn from a 4-symbol alphabet. This controlled environment allowed the researchers to establish a prior probability of truth (0.3) and observe how different search profiles shifted that probability.

Despite its success in propositional logic, the approach faces challenges when scaling to First-Order Logic (FOL). In FOL, search spaces can be infinite or unstable, making it difficult to define a "percentage of search space explored." Furthermore, the Bayesian model assumes a degree of independence between search paths that may not hold in highly structured, real-world mathematical problems.

Conclusion

This work demonstrates that mathematical truth can be treated as a probabilistic hypothesis during the search process. By quantifying the information gained from partial searches, the authors provide a formal path toward "anytime" theorem proving, where systems can provide useful, albeit non-certain, answers under time pressure. Extending these "theorem-proving profiles" to more complex logical systems remains a promising frontier for future research in artificial intelligence.

Summary updated

Abstract

In earlier work, we introduced flexible inference and decision-theoretic metareasoning to address the intractability of normative inference. Here, rather than pursuing the task of computing beliefs and actions with decision models composed of distinctions about uncertain events, we examine methods for inferring beliefs about mathematical truth before an automated theorem prover completes a proof. We employ a Bayesian analysis to update belief in truth, given theorem-proving progress, and show how decision-theoretic methods can be used to determine the value of continuing to deliberate versus taking immediate action in time-critical situations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{horvitz1995reasoning,
  author = {Eric Horvitz and Adrian C. Klein},
  title = {{Reasoning, Metareasoning, and Mathematical Truth: Studies of Theorem Proving under Limited Resources}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1995},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=3j58iR0Xbm3},
}
Figure