Real-space and reciprocal-space topology in the Eu(Ga$_{1-x}$Al$_x$)$_4$ square net system

Jaime M. Moya, Jianwei Huang, Shiming Lei, Kevin Allen, Yuxiang Gao, Yan Sun, Ming Yi, E. MorosanarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

This paper explores the fascinating intersection of two different types of "topology" within a single material system: the $\text{Eu}(\text{Ga}_{1-x}\text{Al}_x)_4$ series. By tuning the ratio of Gallium to Aluminum, researchers have found a rare platform where real-space spin textures and reciprocal-space electronic band structures coexist and interact.

TL;DR

Researchers have identified the $\text{Eu}(\text{Ga}_{1-x}\text{Al}_x)_4$ family as a rare bulk material system that hosts both real-space topology (complex spin textures) and reciprocal-space topology (Weyl nodes). This discovery provides a unique playground for tuning topological phases via chemical substitution, offering a new path toward high-efficiency spintronic devices.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the quest for next-generation electronic devices, "topological" materials are the holy grail because they can support electron transport with little to no energy loss. Physicists generally categorize topology into two "spaces":

  1. Real-space topology: This involves the physical arrangement of electron spins, such as skyrmions—tiny, particle-like magnetic swirls that can act as data bits.
  2. Reciprocal-space (momentum-space) topology: This involves the global properties of the material's electronic bands, leading to phenomena like the Anomalous Hall Effect (AHE) driven by "Berry curvature."

While both have been studied extensively, they are rarely found together in a single, tunable bulk material. Usually, researchers have to create complex "sandwiches" (heterostructures) of different materials to see both effects. This paper addresses the challenge of finding a single, stoichiometric material where both types of topology can be manipulated simultaneously.

Methods

The team synthesized single crystals of $\text{Eu}(\text{Ga}_{1-x}\text{Al}_x)_4$ using a self-flux method, varying the Al concentration ($x$) from 0.15 to 0.90. They employed a multi-pronged approach to characterize the samples:

  • Magnetotransport Measurements: They measured longitudinal and Hall resistivity at cryogenic temperatures and high magnetic fields.
  • Magnetization: They used a vibrating sample magnetometer to map out magnetic phase transitions.
  • Theoretical Modeling: Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations were used to predict the electronic band structure and identify topological features like Dirac points and Weyl nodes.
  • Hall Effect Parsing: A critical part of their work was mathematically separating the measured Hall signal into three parts: the normal Hall effect (from the Lorentz force), the Anomalous Hall Effect (AHE, from reciprocal-space topology), and the Topological Hall Effect (THE, from real-space spin textures).

Datasets

The "data" in this paper consists of original experimental measurements and computational results generated by the authors. This includes:

  • Magnetic field-temperature ($H-T$) phase diagrams for various compositions.
  • Resistivity and magnetization curves across a range of Al/Ga ratios.
  • DFT-calculated band structures for the $\text{EuGa}_2\text{Al}_2$ ($x=0.5$) composition.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Switch" for Real-Space Topology: The researchers found that real-space topology (indicated by the THE) only emerges when the Aluminum content is high ($x \geq 0.50$). At lower concentrations, the system behaves like a simpler antiferromagnet.
  • Universal Reciprocal Topology: Unlike the THE, the Anomalous Hall Effect (AHE) was observed across all compositions in the spin-polarized state. This suggests that the underlying electronic band topology is a robust feature of the entire square-net crystal structure.
  • The Dirac-to-Weyl Transition: DFT calculations revealed a Dirac point (a four-fold crossing of electronic bands) very near the Fermi level in the paramagnetic state. When a magnetic field is applied, this Dirac point is expected to split into "Weyl nodes," which act as intense sources of Berry curvature, explaining the large AHE observed experimentally.
  • Centrosymmetric Skyrmion Candidates: Most materials that host skyrmions lack inversion symmetry (they are "non-centrosymmetric"). However, this system is centrosymmetric. This implies that the spin textures are likely stabilized by the RKKY interaction (mediated by conduction electrons) rather than the more common Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction.

Key Results

  • Topological Hall Effect (THE): For $0.50 \leq x \leq 0.90$, the team observed a distinct THE, signaling the presence of non-coplanar spin textures (like skyrmions).
  • Large Anomalous Hall Effect: All samples showed a significant AHE. The calculated anomalous Hall conductivity ($\sigma_{xy}^A$) was between 600 and 1000 $(\Omega \text{ cm})^{-1}$, which is remarkably high and points to an intrinsic topological origin.
  • Phase Complexity: The $H-T$ phase diagrams for high-$x$ compositions revealed multiple intermediate magnetic phases, suggesting a highly frustrated and tunable magnetic landscape.

Limitations and Future Work

While the transport data strongly implies the existence of topological spin textures, the researchers did not directly image them. The authors note that future work using Lorentz Transmission Electron Microscopy (LTEM) or Small-Angle Neutron Scattering (SANS) will be necessary to confirm the exact geometry of these textures (e.g., whether they are a skyrmion lattice or a more exotic "meron" lattice).

Additionally, the paper highlights that the energy of the Dirac point shifts slightly as the Al/Ga ratio changes. This suggests a future opportunity to "fine-tune" the material so the Dirac point sits exactly at the Fermi level, potentially maximizing the topological transport effects.

Summary updated

Abstract

Magnetotransport measurements on the centrosymetric square-net Eu(Ga$_{1-x}$Al$_x$)$_4$ compounds reveal evidence for both reciprocal- and real-space topology. For compositions $0.50 \leq x \leq 0.90$, several intermediate field phases are found by magnetization measurements when $H \parallel c$, where a maximum in the topological Hall effect (THE) is observed, pointing to the existence of topological (real-space topology) or non-coplanar spin textures. For $0.25 \leq x \leq 0.39$, magnetization measurements reveal an intermediate field state, but no transition is visible in the Hall measurements. For $x = 0.15$, only one magnetic transition occurs below the Néel temperature $T_N$, and no intermediate field spin reorientations are observed. The Hall effect varies smoothly before the spin-polarized (SP) state. However, in the SP state, Hall measurements reveal a large anomalous Hall effect (AHE) for all compositions, a consequence of reciprocal-space topology. Density functional theory calculations in the paramagnetic state indeed reveal a Dirac point that lies very near the Fermi energy, which is expected to split into Weyl nodes in the SP state, thereby explaining the observed AHE. These results suggest the Eu(Ga$_{1-x}$Al$_x$)$_4$ family is a rare material platform where real- and reciprocal-space topology exist in a single material platform.
BibTeX
@misc{moya2023real,
  author = {Jaime M. Moya and Jianwei Huang and Shiming Lei and Kevin Allen and Yuxiang Gao and Yan Sun and Ming Yi and E. Morosan},
  title = {{Real-space and reciprocal-space topology in the Eu(Ga$\_\{1-x\}$Al$\_x$)$\_4$ square net system}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2302.03076},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03076},
}
Figure