Read-Green resonances in a $p_x+ip_y$ superfluid interacting with a bath

Pieter W. Claeys, Stijn De Baerdemacker, Dimitri Van Neck

Abstract

We study the weak-pairing phase in a finite-size two-dimensional $p_x+ip_y$ superfluid interacting with an environment. This interaction breaks particle-number symmetry and can be modelled by means of an integrable Hamiltonian. We present the exact wave function and solve the resulting Bethe ansatz equations, from which it is shown how resonances are introduced at fixed interaction strengths. These cannot be observed within mean-field theory and are argued to be caused by zero-energy excitations at topologically protected Read-Green points.

Introduction

Topological superconductors are a "holy grail" in condensed matter physics due to their potential to host Majorana zero modes—quasiparticles that could serve as building blocks for fault-tolerant quantum computers. Most theoretical models of these systems rely on mean-field theory (specifically Bogoliubov-de Gennes theory), which assumes an unfixed particle number. However, for finite-sized superconductors interacting with an environment (a "bath"), the exact number of particles and its fluctuations become critical. This paper addresses what happens to the topological phase transition in a finite system when it can exchange particles with its environment, identifying signatures that traditional mean-field theories fail to predict.

Methods

The authors move beyond standard approximations by using an integrable Hamiltonian based on Richardson-Gaudin pairing models. By mapping the complex interactions of fermions onto a quasispin formalism, they obtain exact quantum states via the Bethe ansatz. They introduce a specific term to the Hamiltonian that allows for particle-pair exchange with a bath while maintaining the system's integrability. This approach allows for a precise numerical study of a "picket-fence" model (where single-particle energy levels are equally spaced) with $L=12$ states to demonstrate finite-size and bath-coupling effects.

Key Insights and Results

The "Inhale" Effect and Quantized Jumps

In an isolated system, topological phase transitions occur at specific "Read-Green points." When coupled to a bath, the system exhibits an "inhale" effect: at each Read-Green point, the average number of Cooper pairs $\langle \hat{N} \rangle$ increases by exactly one. These discrete steps are a hallmark of the transition in finite systems.

Average particle number $\langle \hat{N} \rangle$ (top) and pairing amplitude $|\langle c_k^\dagger c_{-k}^\dagger \rangle|$ (bottom) as a function of the coupling constant $G$. Dashed vertical lines indicate Read-Green points.

Read-Green Resonances

Accompanying these jumps are "Read-Green resonances"—sharp peaks in the pairing amplitude of the lowest-energy states. These are essentially the "ghosts" of the zero-energy modes that would exist in an isolated system. As shown in Figure 1, these peaks occur precisely at the interaction strengths $G$ where the particle number jumps.

Avoided Crossings and Mean-Field Blindness

Traditional mean-field theory completely misses these resonant fluctuations in finite systems. In the exact solution, the topological phase transition—usually seen as a gapless point where energy levels meet—becomes an "avoided crossing" when the bath is introduced. The energy levels get very close but "repel" each other due to the interaction with the environment.

Energy gap $\Delta E$ as a function of $G$ for various system-bath coupling strengths $\gamma$. The resonances at Read-Green points are visible as minima that are lifted as $\gamma$ increases.

As the coupling strength $\gamma$ increases, these unique quantum fluctuations are gradually smoothed out, and the system's behavior begins to resemble the predictions of mean-field theory.

Discussion and Future Work

The discovery of Read-Green resonances provides a new way to identify topologically protected states in open quantum systems. However, several hurdles remain for experimental verification. The current study relies on an integrable model; future work must determine how non-integrable "chaos" in real-world materials might alter these resonances. Furthermore, observing these effects in a lab would require extremely low temperatures—significantly smaller than the superconducting pairing gap—to prevent thermal noise from obscuring the quantum fluctuations. Extending the model to single-particle exchanges could more directly involve the physics of Majorana fermion parity.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the weak-pairing phase in a finite-size two-dimensional $p_x+ip_y$ superfluid interacting with an environment. This interaction breaks particle-number symmetry and can be modelled by means of an integrable Hamiltonian. We present the exact wave function and solve the resulting Bethe ansatz equations, from which it is shown how resonances are introduced at fixed interaction strengths. These cannot be observed within mean-field theory and are argued to be caused by zero-energy excitations at topologically protected Read-Green points.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{claeys2016read,
  author = {Pieter W. Claeys and Stijn De Baerdemacker and Dimitri Van Neck},
  title = {{Read-Green resonances in a $p\_x+ip\_y$ superfluid interacting with a bath}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.93.220503},
}
Figure