Reaction rates for reaction-diffusion kinetics on unstructured meshes

Stefan Hellander, Linda Petzold

Abstract

The reaction-diffusion master equation (RDME) is a stochastic model often utilized in the study of biochemical reaction networks in living cells. It is applied when the spatial distribution of molecules is important to the dynamics of the system. A viable approach to resolve the complex geometry of cells accurately is to discretize space with an unstructured mesh. Diffusion is modeled as discrete jumps between nodes on the mesh, and the diffusion jump rates can be obtained through a discretization of the diffusion equation on the mesh. Reactions can occur when molecules occupy the same voxel. In this paper, we develop a method for computing accurate reaction rates between molecules occupying the same voxel in an unstructured mesh. For large voxels, these rates are known to be well approximated by the reaction rates derived by Collins and Kimball, but as the mesh is refined, no analytical expression for the rates exists. We reduce the problem of computing accurate reaction rates to a pure preprocessing step, depending only on the mesh and not on the model parameters, and we devise an efficient numerical scheme to estimate them to high accuracy. We show in several numerical examples that as we refine the mesh, the results obtained with the reaction-diffusion master equation approach those of a more fine-grained Smoluchowski particle-tracking model.

Introduction

In systems biology, the spatial organization of molecules is often as critical as their concentrations. To model these systems, researchers frequently turn to the Reaction-Diffusion Master Equation (RDME), a stochastic framework that discretizes space into small volumes called voxels. While Cartesian grids are computationally simple, they struggle to represent the complex, curved geometries of biological cells. Unstructured meshes, composed of triangles or tetrahedra, offer a more flexible alternative. However, a significant hurdle remains: determining the correct mesoscopic reaction rates ($k_a^{meso}$) to ensure the model remains physically accurate as the mesh is refined.

The Problem: The Breakdown of Volume Scaling

In a traditional RDME approach, molecules are assumed to be well-mixed within each voxel. For bimolecular reactions, the mesoscopic rate is typically derived by scaling the macroscopic rate by the voxel volume. While this approximation holds for relatively large voxels, it fails significantly as the mesh is refined.

As voxels become smaller, the time a molecule spends within a single voxel decreases, and the discrete nature of the mesh begins to interfere with the reaction dynamics. On simple Cartesian grids, mathematical corrections exist to account for this. On unstructured meshes, however, the irregular connectivity and varying voxel sizes mean no analytical formula is available. Without a proper correction, simulations on fine meshes diverge from the underlying physics, leading to significant errors in diffusion-limited systems.

Methodology: Bridging the Mesoscopic and Microscopic Gap

The researchers propose a novel numerical method to calculate these rates by matching the "mean binding time"—the average time required for two molecules to meet and react—between the mesoscopic RDME and the high-fidelity microscopic Smoluchowski model.

Preprocessing and Algorithm 3

To make this computationally feasible, the authors developed an efficient Monte Carlo scheme (Algorithm 3). This algorithm estimates two vital parameters for each voxel:

  1. $\tau_{diff}^{meso}$: The time it takes for a molecule to first reach a specific voxel.
  2. $t_1$: The time it takes for a molecule to return to its original voxel after wandering away.

Crucially, these parameters depend only on the mesh geometry and the diffusion coefficient, not on the specific chemical parameters of the reaction. This allows the most intensive calculations to be performed as a one-time preprocessing step.

Linear Approximation for Scalability

Modern biological simulations may involve meshes with hundreds of thousands of voxels. Computing a unique rate for every single voxel using Monte Carlo simulations would be prohibitively expensive. The authors discovered a key relationship: the inverse of the mesoscopic reaction rate is approximately linear with respect to the voxel volume:

$$(k_a^{meso})^{-1} = k_0 + k_1 V_{vox}$$

By calculating the rates for a small sample of voxels and applying linear regression, the method can efficiently assign accurate rates across the entire mesh.

Numerical Validation

The method was tested using several geometric models, including cubes, spheres, and "capsule" shapes (representing rod-shaped bacteria). These were discretized into tetrahedral meshes using the Gmsh tool. The benchmark system was a dissociation-rebinding model ($S_1 \to S_{11} + S_{12} \to S_2$), where the spatial correlation of the products is essential to the reaction outcome.

The results were compared against the "gold standard" Smoluchowski particle-tracking model using the Green’s Function Reaction Dynamics (GFRD) algorithm.

Key Results and Insights

The study yielded several significant findings:

  • Convergence: Unlike standard volume-scaling methods, which fail to converge as the mesh is refined, the new method allows the RDME to converge to the microscopic Smoluchowski results.
  • Efficiency: Algorithm 3 provided a 15x speedup in preprocessing time compared to naive approaches, making it practical for large-scale models.
  • Robustness: The linear approximation held true across various geometries, confirming that the method is scalable and consistent.

Limitations and Future Outlook

While the method represents a major step forward, the authors identified specific boundaries. If a mesh is refined beyond the physical reaction radius of the molecules, the calculated rates can theoretically become negative—a sign that the RDME's fundamental assumptions are being pushed too far. Additionally, while the method performs well in the bulk of the mesh, voxels near the cell membrane may require specialized treatment to account for boundary effects.

Future work will focus on extending this framework to 2D surfaces, which is vital for modeling signaling pathways that occur on the cell membrane. By providing a robust way to calculate reaction rates on unstructured meshes, this research enables faster, more accurate simulations of the complex spatial dynamics within living cells.

Summary updated

Abstract

The reaction-diffusion master equation is a stochastic model often utilized in the study of biochemical reaction networks in living cells. It is applied when the spatial distribution of molecules is important to the dynamics of the system. A viable approach to resolve the complex geometry of cells accurately is to discretize space with an unstructured mesh. Diffusion is modeled as discrete jumps between nodes on the mesh, and the diffusion jump rates can be obtained through a discretization of the diffusion equation on the mesh. Reactions can occur when molecules occupy the same voxel. In this paper, we develop a method for computing accurate reaction rates between molecules occupying the same voxel in an unstructured mesh. For large voxels, these rates are known to be well approximated by the reaction rates derived by Collins and Kimball, but as the mesh is refined, no analytical expression for the rates exists. We reduce the problem of computing accurate reaction rates to a pure preprocessing step, depending only on the mesh and not on the model parameters, and we devise an efficient numerical scheme to estimate them to high accuracy. We show in several numerical examples that as we refine the mesh, the results obtained with the reaction-diffusion master equation approach those of a more fine-grained Smoluchowski particle-tracking model.
BibTeX
@article{hellander2017reaction,
  author = {Stefan Hellander and Linda Petzold},
  title = {{Reaction rates for reaction-diffusion kinetics on unstructured meshes}},
  journal = {The Journal of Chemical Physics},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1063/1.4975167},
}
Figure