Rats spontaneously perceive global motion direction of drifting plaids

Giulio Matteucci, Benedetta Zattera, Rosilari Bellacosa Marotti, Davide Zoccolan

TL;DR

Rats can spontaneously perceive the global motion direction of complex visual patterns, similar to how primates do. This ability is linked to a "pattern-cell" based representation of motion, suggesting that rodents possess a sophisticated visual processing system for motion integration, even if the underlying neural circuitry is still being uncovered.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how our brains combine local visual cues into a coherent perception of global motion is a fundamental question in neuroscience. In primates, this is thought to be mediated by "pattern cells" in higher visual areas that integrate signals from "component cells" (which detect local motion). While component cells are abundant in rodents, the existence and role of pattern cells in their visual system, particularly for complex stimuli like drifting plaids, has been unclear. This paper investigates whether rats can spontaneously perceive the global motion of plaids, and if so, whether this perception relies on a pattern-cell-like representation, analogous to what's seen in primates.

Methods

The researchers employed a visual priming paradigm to assess rats' spontaneous perception of global motion. Rats were trained to discriminate the direction of either simple drifting gratings (G group) or complex drifting plaids (P group). After training, a brief "prime" stimulus (either a grating or a plaid) was presented before the target stimulus. The extent to which the prime influenced the rat's response to the target indicated the perceived similarity between the prime and target.

To interpret the behavioral results, the authors developed computational models simulating populations of either component cells or pattern cells. These models were used to predict how a decision neuron would interpret motion signals under different assumptions about neural representation and training history. They specifically tested two hypotheses:

  1. Training-dependent decoding pool: Whether training on gratings or plaids biases the selection of neurons (component vs. pattern cells) that a decision neuron reads out.
  2. Pattern cell dominance: Whether decision neurons primarily access pattern cells, and how cross-orientation suppression might influence this.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on behavioral data collected from rats and simulated neural data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Rats are not just detecting local motion: The P group (trained on plaids) showed that gratings and plaids equally biased their perception of plaid direction. This suggests they are processing the global motion of the plaid, not just its individual components.
  • Training matters: The G group (trained on gratings) was largely insensitive to plaid primes, indicating that their visual system, trained on simpler stimuli, didn't spontaneously integrate plaid motion. This highlights a training-dependent specialization in motion perception.
  • Pattern cells are key: Computational models strongly supported a "pattern-cell" based representation for rats perceiving plaid motion. This aligns with primate visual processing and suggests rodents have similar mechanisms for global motion integration.
  • Cross-orientation suppression plays a role: The models suggest that stronger suppression of component cells by competing orientations could explain why pattern cells might be preferentially recruited for plaid perception, especially after training on plaids.

Key Results

  • Rats trained on plaids (P group) showed significant priming effects for both grating and plaid primes when judging plaid direction, indicating they perceived the global motion of the plaids.
  • Rats trained on gratings (G group) showed strong priming for grating primes but were largely unaffected by plaid primes when judging grating direction. This suggests a lack of spontaneous global motion integration for plaids in this group.
  • Computational simulations demonstrated that a pattern-cell based representation best explained the observed priming curves for the P group, while a component-cell based representation failed to do so.
  • The models also provided plausible explanations for the differential priming effects between the G and P groups, involving factors like the relative abundance of cell types and cross-orientation suppression.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Speculative explanations: The authors acknowledge that their explanations for the differential priming effects are speculative and based on assumptions about neural mechanisms (e.g., differential cross-orientation suppression).
  • Future neurophysiology: They emphasize the need for future neurophysiological experiments to directly test these hypotheses by measuring the responses of component and pattern cells in rodents to gratings and plaids.
  • Hierarchy of visual areas: The exact anatomical hierarchy of motion processing in rodents is still unclear, and future work could clarify how different visual areas contribute to global motion perception.
  • Generalizability of training: While the study shows training-dependent effects, further research could explore how other types of training or experience might influence motion integration abilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Computing global motion direction of extended visual objects is a hallmark of primate high-level vision. Although neurons selective for global motion have also been found in mouse visual cortex, it remains unknown whether rodents can combine multiple motion signals into global, integrated percepts. To address this question, we trained two groups of rats to discriminate either gratings (G group) or plaids (i.e., superpositions of gratings with different orientations; P group) drifting horizontally along opposite directions. After the animals learned the task, we applied a visual priming paradigm, where presentation of the target stimulus was preceded by the brief presentation of either a grating or a plaid. The extent to which rat responses to the targets were biased by such prime stimuli provided a measure of the spontaneous, perceived similarity between primes and targets. We found that gratings and plaids, when uses as primes, were equally effective at biasing the perception of plaid direction for the rats of the P group. Conversely, for G group, only the gratings acted as effective prime stimuli, while the plaids failed to alter the perception of grating direction. To interpret these observations, we simulated a decision neuron reading out the representations of gratings and plaids, as conveyed by populations of either component or pattern cells (i.e., local or global motion detectors). We concluded that the findings for the P group are highly consistent with the existence of a population of pattern cells, playing a functional role similar to that demonstrated in primates. We also explored different scenarios that could explain the failure of the plaid stimuli to elicit a sizable priming magnitude for the G group. These simulations yielded testable predictions about the properties of motion representations in rodent visual cortex at the single-cell and circuitry level, thus paving the way to future neurophysiology experiments.
BibTeX
@article{matteucci2021rats,
  author = {Giulio Matteucci and Benedetta Zattera and Rosilari Bellacosa Marotti and Davide Zoccolan},
  title = {{Rats spontaneously perceive global motion direction of drifting plaids}},
  journal = {PLOS Computational Biology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pcbi.1009415},
}

Loading related content...

Figure