Rate-Splitting Unifying SDMA, OMA, NOMA, and Multicasting in MISO Broadcast Channel: A Simple Two-User Rate Analysis

Bruno Clerckx, Yijie Mao, Robert Schober, H. Vincent Poor

Introduction: The Challenge of Interference Management

In 5G and beyond, transmitters must serve multiple users simultaneously. Historically, distinct "Multiple Access" strategies have been employed:

  • SDMA (Space Division Multiple Access): Treats interference as noise; optimal when users are spatially separated.
  • NOMA (Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access): Uses interference cancellation; optimal when channel strengths differ significantly.
  • OMA (Orthogonal Multiple Access): Allocates orthogonal resources; simple but often suboptimal.

Engineers typically switch between these strategies based on the environment. This research explores whether a single, unified framework can encompass all these strategies while delivering superior performance.

Methods: The Rate-Splitting Architecture

The study focuses on a two-user MISO (Multiple-Input Single-Output) Broadcast Channel using Linearly Precoded Rate-Splitting (RS).

System model of the two-user Rate-Splitting transmitter and receiver architecture.

In the RS framework, each user's message is split into:

  1. Common Part: Combined into a "common stream" ($s_c$) decoded by all users.
  2. Private Part: Kept separate ($s_1, s_2$) for individual users.

At the receiver, Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC) is employed. The common stream is decoded first and subtracted from the total signal before the private stream is decoded. The authors utilize Zero-Forcing (ZF) precoding for private streams and optimize power allocation via a splitting variable ($t$). By adjusting $t$, the system can mathematically degenerate into SDMA, NOMA, OMA, or Multicasting.

Key Insights: RS as a Generalization

RS is not merely a new technique but a generalization of existing ones. This "partial decoding" capability allows RS to manage interference more effectively than SDMA (which ignores it) or NOMA (which attempts to decode it all). It is particularly robust in "semi-orthogonal" scenarios where users are neither perfectly aligned nor perfectly separated.

Key Results and Performance Analysis

Simulations using 10,000 random channel realizations highlight the dominance of RS over traditional silos.

Analysis of the optimum power-split variable t and the resulting regions of operation for different access strategies.
  • Dominance: RS was the optimal strategy for approximately 75% of channel realizations at high SNR. SDMA was preferred for the remaining 25%, while NOMA and OMA were rarely optimal.
  • Capacity Gains: RS achieves 2 Degrees of Freedom (DoF), doubling capacity over NOMA or OMA in high-interference scenarios.
  • Robustness: Even when SDMA performs well, RS provides a constant sum-rate enhancement by using the common stream to mitigate residual interference. In overloaded regimes, gains of 10% to 70% were observed over traditional switching strategies.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the analysis provides a clear theoretical foundation using Zero-Forcing precoders and perfect Channel State Information at the Transmitter (CSIT), future work could explore:

  • Imperfect CSIT: RS is expected to show even greater benefits when channel knowledge is noisy.
  • Scaling: Extending the two-user analysis to massive MIMO scenarios with many users, where message-splitting complexity increases.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{clerckx2020rate,
  author = {Bruno Clerckx and Yijie Mao and Robert Schober and H. Vincent Poor},
  title = {{Rate-Splitting Unifying SDMA, OMA, NOMA, and Multicasting in MISO Broadcast Channel: A Simple Two-User Rate Analysis}},
  journal = {IEEE Wireless Communications Letters},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1109/lwc.2019.2954518},
}
Figure