Rate-dependent bifurcation dodging in a thermoacoustic system driven by colored noise

Xiaoyu Zhang, Yong Xu, Qi Liu, Jürgen Kurths, Celso Grebogi

Abstract: Tipping in multistable systems occurs usually by varying the input slightly, resulting in the output switching to an often unsatisfactory state. This phenomenon is manifested in thermoacoustic systems. This thermoacoustic instability may lead to the disintegration of rocket engines, gas turbines and aeroengines, so it is necessary to design control measures for its suppression. It was speculated that such unwanted instability states may be dodged by changing quickly enough the bifurcation parameters. Thus, in this work, based on a fundamental mathematical model of thermoacoustic systems driven by colored noise, the corresponding Fokker-Planck-Kolmogorov equation of the amplitude is derived by using a stochastic averaging method. A transient dynamical behavior is identified through a probability density analysis. We find that the rate of change of parameters and the correlation time of the noise are helpful to dodge thermoacoustic instability, while a relatively large noise intensity is a disadvantageous factor. In addition, power-law relationships between the maximum amplitude and the noise parameters are explored, and the probability of successfully dodging a thermoacoustic instability is calculated. These results serve as a guide to the design of engines and to propose an effective control strategy, which is of great significance to aerospace-related fields.

Introduction: The Challenge of Thermoacoustic Instability

In aerospace engineering, thermoacoustic instability represents a catastrophic failure mode. It occurs when heat release fluctuations and acoustic pressure waves in a combustion chamber reinforce each other, leading to high-amplitude pressure oscillations. These vibrations can cause structural disintegration in rocket engines, gas turbines, and aeroengines.

Mathematically, this transition is a "tipping point" or bifurcation where a system switches from a stable, low-amplitude state to a dangerous, high-amplitude one. Traditional control strategies focus on maintaining steady-state stability, but real-world engines are non-autonomous; parameters like fuel flow or air intake change dynamically over time.

Modeling the "Dodge"

This research explores rate-dependent bifurcation dodging: the hypothesis that rapidly changing a parameter through a "danger zone" can prevent the system from ever reaching the unstable state. To study this, the researchers developed a reduced mathematical model based on the Helmholtz equation, simplified into a nonlinear oscillator. This model captures the "double-well" potential nature of the system, where the system can reside in either a safe "low" state or a dangerous "high" state.

Conceptual model of thermoacoustic instability showing (a) intermittent time-series and (b) the corresponding double-well amplitude effective potential.

The study specifically incorporates colored noise—randomness with a correlation time—to better simulate the turbulent environment of a real combustor compared to idealized white noise. By applying stochastic averaging, the team derived a Fokker-Planck-Kolmogorov (FPK) equation to track the evolution of the probability density of vibration amplitudes over time.

Key Insights: Ramp Rates and Noise Correlation

The analysis, solved numerically using the Crank-Nicolson difference method, revealed several critical factors for successfully "dodging" instability:

  • The Tipping Delay: Systems do not tip instantly. If the ramp rate ($R$) of a parameter change is sufficiently high, the system passes through the unstable region before the vibration amplitude can grow to dangerous levels. Increasing $R$ from 10 to 75 showed a dramatic "flattening" of the amplitude peak in probability maps.
  • The Benefit of Colored Noise: Surprisingly, noise correlation time ($ au$) aids stability. A longer correlation time (the "memory" of the noise) helps suppress the jump to high-amplitude oscillations, making the "dodge" more effective than in a white-noise environment ($ au=0$).
  • Power-Law Scaling: The researchers identified quantitative rules of thumb, finding that the maximum amplitude reached during a transition follows power-law relationships with noise parameters: $A_{max} \sim \tau^{-p}$ and $A_{max} \sim D^q$.
  • Noise Intensity Limits: While fast ramping is effective, high background noise intensity ($D$) remains a significant hurdle. If $D$ is too large, the system will tip regardless of the ramp rate.

Conclusion and Engineering Significance

The study demonstrates that the probability of successfully dodging a thermoacoustic instability can be maintained at 70% or higher with sufficiently fast parameter ramping. These findings provide a theoretical foundation for designing engine control strategies that exploit transient dynamics. By understanding the interplay between ramp rates and noise characteristics, engineers can develop more resilient propulsion systems for aerospace applications.

Reference: Zhang, X., Xu, Y., Liu, Q., Kurths, J., & Grebogi, C. (2020). Rate-dependent bifurcation dodging in a thermoacoustic system driven by colored noise. arXiv:2009.13126v1.

Summary updated

Abstract

Tipping in multistable systems occurs usually by varying the input slightly, resulting in the output switching to an often unsatisfactory state. This phenomenon is manifested in thermoacoustic systems. This thermoacoustic instability may lead to the disintegration of rocket engines, gas turbines and aeroengines, so it is necessary to design control measures for its suppression. It was speculated that such unwanted instability states may be dodged by changing quickly enough the bifurcation parameters. Thus, in this work, based on a fundamental mathematical model of thermoacoustic systems driven by colored noise, the corresponding Fokker-Planck-Kolmogorov equation of the amplitude is derived by using a stochastic averaging method. A transient dynamical behavior is identified through a probability density analysis. We find that the rate of change of parameters and the correlation time of the noise are helpful to dodge thermoacoustic instability, while a relatively large noise intensity is a disadvantageous factor. In addition, power-law relationships between the maximum amplitude and the noise parameters are explored, and the probability of successfully dodging a thermoacoustic instability is calculated. These results serve as a guide to the design of engines and to propose an effective control strategy, which is of great significance to aerospace-related fields.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2021rate,
  author = {Xiaoyu Zhang and Yong Xu and Qi Liu and Jürgen Kurths and Celso Grebogi},
  title = {{Rate-dependent bifurcation dodging in a thermoacoustic system driven by colored noise}},
  booktitle = {Nonlinear},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1007/s11071-021-06368-5},
}
Figure