Rate-cost tradeoffs in control. Part II: achievable scheme

Victoria Kostina, Babak Hassibi

TL;DR

This paper tackles the fundamental trade-off between communication rate and control performance in distributed systems. It demonstrates that a simple lattice quantization scheme, which quantizes only the "innovation" (the difference between predicted and actual state), can achieve near-optimal control performance, closely approaching theoretical lower bounds. This is crucial for designing efficient control systems that operate under bandwidth constraints.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many real-world control systems, the controller doesn't have direct access to the system's state. Instead, it receives information through a communication channel, which is often bandwidth-limited. This creates a fundamental challenge: how much information (measured by communication rate) must be sent to achieve a desired level of control performance (measured by a quadratic cost function, like the Linear Quadratic Regulator or LQR)? The companion paper established a theoretical lower bound on this trade-off. This paper addresses the question of whether this theoretical bound is achievable in practice, particularly with practical coding and quantization schemes. The core problem is to bridge the gap between theoretical limits and practical implementations in distributed control systems operating under communication constraints.

Methods

The paper's main contribution is proving the achievability of the rate-cost tradeoff bound. The authors propose a simple, time-invariant lattice quantization scheme. This scheme quantizes the innovation of the state estimate, which is the difference between the controller's prediction of the state and the encoder's actual estimate. This is a key simplification, as it avoids transmitting the entire state history. The proof of achievability leverages recent advancements in non-asymptotic high-resolution vector quantization, particularly results concerning the output entropy of lattice quantizers. They also employ tools from information-theoretic quantities like entropy power and mutual information to rigorously bound the performance gap. The analysis is extended to both fully and partially observed systems.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and does not present experimental results on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Quantizing the Innovation is Key: The most significant insight is that focusing quantization on the "innovation" (the error in state prediction) is sufficient to achieve near-optimal control performance. This is a much simpler approach than trying to quantize the entire state or its history.
  • Lattice Quantization's Power: The paper highlights the effectiveness of lattice quantization, particularly in higher dimensions, for approaching theoretical bounds. Lattice quantizers offer a good balance between simplicity and performance in approximating spherical cells.
  • Bridging Theory and Practice: The work provides a concrete, simple scheme that demonstrates the achievability of theoretical rate-cost bounds, moving beyond purely theoretical limits.
  • Smoothness Matters: The achievability of the bound relies on the system noise having a "smooth" probability density function. This condition is crucial for the effectiveness of the quantization scheme and the analytical tools used.
  • Dimensionality Helps: The paper suggests that increasing the dimensionality of the system can further reduce the gap between the achievable scheme and the theoretical bound, hinting at the benefits of block coding.

Key Results

The paper proves that the theoretical lower bound on the rate-cost tradeoff, established in a companion paper, can be closely approached by a simple lattice quantization scheme. Specifically:

  • Fully Observed Systems: For systems where the encoder observes the state directly, the proposed scheme achieves an entropy-cost function that is within a quantifiable gap of the theoretical lower bound. This gap is shown to decrease as the target LQR cost approaches the minimum possible cost and can be further reduced by increasing system dimensionality.
  • Partially Observed Systems: Similar results are shown for systems where the encoder only observes a noisy version of the state. The achievable scheme, again based on quantizing the innovation, closely approaches the theoretical bounds.
  • Quantifiable Performance Gap: The paper provides explicit bounds on the difference between the achievable performance and the theoretical optimum, showing that this gap is manageable, especially in the low-cost (high-rate) regime and for higher-dimensional systems.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Noise Smoothness Assumption: The achievability results rely on the assumption that the system noise has a sufficiently smooth probability density function. The performance of the scheme under highly non-smooth noise distributions is not explicitly addressed.
  • Fixed-Rate Quantization: While the paper focuses on variable-rate quantization, it notes that determining whether fixed-rate quantization schemes can approach the theoretical bounds remains an open question.
  • Non-Lattice Quantizers: The paper suggests exploring whether other types of quantizers (e.g., Elia-Mitter or Lloyd-Max) could further narrow the performance gap.
  • Joint Source-Channel Coding: The authors express interest in exploring novel ways to design optimal joint source-channel codes for control, potentially by combining variable-rate quantization with anytime channel coding.

Summary updated

Abstract

Consider a distributed control problem with a communication channel connecting the observer of a linear stochastic system to the controller. The goal of the controller is to minimize a quadratic cost function in the state variables and control signal, known as the linear quadratic regulator (LQR). We study the fundamental tradeoff between the communication rate r bits/sec and the limsup of the expected cost b. In the companion paper, which can be read independently of the current one, we show a lower bound on a certain cost function, which quantifies the minimum mutual information between the channel input and output, given the past, that is compatible with a target LQR cost. The bound applies as long as the system noise has a probability density function, and it holds for a general class of codes that can take full advantage of the memory of the data observed so far and that are not constrained to have any particular structure. In this paper, we prove that the bound can be approached by a simple variable-length lattice quantization scheme, as long as the system noise satisfies a smoothness condition. The quantization scheme only quantizes the innovation, that is, the difference between the controller's belief about the current state and the encoder's state estimate. Our proof technique leverages some recent results on nonasymptotic high resolution vector quantization.
BibTeX
@misc{kostina2016rate,
  author = {Victoria Kostina and Babak Hassibi},
  title = {{Rate-cost tradeoffs in control. Part II: achievable scheme}},
  year = {2016},
  eprint = {1612.02128},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1612.02128},
}
Figure