Rare Event Kinetics from Adaptive Bias Enhanced Sampling

Dhiman Ray, Narjes Ansari, Valerio Rizzi, Michele Invernizzi, Michele Parrinello

TL;DR

This paper introduces "OPES flooding," a new enhanced sampling method for molecular dynamics simulations that accurately calculates the rates of rare events. By carefully controlling the applied bias, OPES flooding can efficiently and reliably predict transition timescales, even with suboptimal collective variables.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Simulating rare events in molecular systems, such as chemical reactions or protein folding, is a major challenge for molecular dynamics. These events are characterized by large energy barriers, meaning they occur on timescales far beyond what standard simulations can capture. While enhanced sampling methods exist, they often struggle to accurately recover the kinetics (i.e., the rates) of these processes because they can distort the system's natural dynamics. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a method that can both accelerate sampling and accurately predict the rates of these rare events.

Methods

The core of this work is the OPES flooding method, which builds upon the On-the-fly-Probability-Enhanced-Sampling (OPES) approach. OPES itself is an advancement over methods like Metadynamics, offering faster convergence and fewer parameters. OPES flooding specifically adapts OPES to calculate kinetics by:

  • Adaptive Bias: An external bias potential is added to the system's energy landscape, guided by collective variables (CVs) that represent the slow degrees of freedom involved in the rare event. This bias is updated dynamically during the simulation.
  • Flooding the Initial State: The key innovation is "flooding" the initial metastable state with bias up to a certain energy level. This encourages the system to overcome the energy barrier and transition to the final state more frequently.
  • Controlled Bias Deposition: Crucially, the method introduces parameters (ΔE and an excluded region, Xexc) to precisely control the amount and location of the bias. This ensures that the bias does not contaminate the transition state region, which is essential for accurate kinetic measurements.
  • Parameter Optimization: The paper provides guidance on how to choose optimal parameters (ΔE and Xexc) to balance accuracy and computational efficiency.

Datasets

The paper uses three systems to test the OPES flooding method:

  1. Modified Wolfe-Quapp potential: A 2D toy model to investigate the method's behavior with varying collective variables and parameters.
  2. Alanine dipeptide (gas phase): A small, well-studied system for conformational transitions, used to validate against long unbiased simulations.
  3. Chignolin miniprotein (explicit solvent): A 10-residue protein to test the method's applicability to more complex, biologically relevant systems (folding/unfolding).

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; instead, the method's performance was compared against existing results from unbiased simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bias Control is Paramount: The most critical factor for accurate kinetics is ensuring the bias is "converged" in the initial state and, most importantly, that the transition state remains "bias-free."
  • Suboptimal CVs Can Work: Surprisingly, OPES flooding can yield accurate kinetics even with CVs that don't perfectly distinguish between states, provided the bias is carefully controlled. This significantly broadens the applicability of the method.
  • Parameter Tuning is Key: The choice of the barrier parameter (ΔE) and the excluded region (Xexc) is crucial. ΔE should be less than the true activation barrier, and Xexc must effectively shield the transition state.
  • Efficiency vs. Accuracy Trade-off: Using a better CV improves simulation efficiency (higher acceleration factor) by allowing for larger ΔE values. However, even with poorer CVs, accurate kinetics can be obtained with careful parameter selection, albeit at a lower efficiency.

Key Results

  • Accurate Kinetics: OPES flooding accurately predicted transition timescales for all three tested systems, showing excellent agreement with unbiased simulations. For alanine dipeptide, the predicted τ was within a factor of 1.28 μs (compared to an unbiased 1.28 μs).
  • Parameter Sensitivity: The accuracy of the kinetics was found to be sensitive to the choice of ΔE and Xexc. Specifically, ΔE exceeding the barrier height or bias contaminating the transition state led to significant errors.
  • Acceleration Factors: The method achieved substantial speedups, with acceleration factors reaching up to 183 for chignolin unfolding and 36.3 for alanine dipeptide.
  • Machine Learning CVs: For chignolin, deep learning-based CVs (Deep-LDA, Deep-TICA) outperformed simpler CVs (HLDA) in terms of both efficiency and accuracy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • FES Calculation: For complex systems, obtaining a converged free energy surface (FES) to guide parameter selection can be difficult and expensive. The authors suggest using partial FES calculations or a "half-harmonic wall" to estimate parameters.
  • Rugged Landscapes: The applicability of OPES flooding to systems with multiple high free energy barriers or very rugged landscapes remains to be explored.
  • Kernel Width: The automatic estimation of Gaussian kernel width by the OPES module might need to be adjusted (made narrower) for optimal rate calculations to prevent tails from affecting the transition state.
  • Future Work: The authors intend to investigate OPESf in systems with multiple barriers and rugged landscapes. They also highlight the potential of deep learning-based CVs for improving efficiency and accuracy.

Summary updated

Abstract

We introduce a novel enhanced sampling approach named OPES flooding for calculating the kinetics of rare events from atomistic molecular dynamics simulation. This method is derived from the On-the-fly-Probability-Enhanced-Sampling (OPES) approach [Invernizzi and Parrinello, JPC Lett. 2020], which has been recently developed for calculating converged free energy surfaces for complex systems. In this paper, we describe the theoretical details of the OPES flooding technique and demonstrate the application on three systems of increasing complexity: barrier crossing in a two-dimensional double well potential, conformational transition in the alanine dipeptide in gas phase, and the folding and unfolding of the chignolin polypeptide in aqueous environment. From extensive tests, we show that the calculation of accurate kinetics not only requires the transition state to be bias-free, but the amount of bias deposited should also not exceed the effective barrier height measured along the chosen collective variables. In this vein, the possibility of computing rates from biasing suboptimal order parameters has also been explored. Furthermore, we describe the choice of optimum parameter combinations for obtaining accurate results from limited computational effort.
BibTeX
@article{ray2022rare,
  author = {Dhiman Ray and Narjes Ansari and Valerio Rizzi and Michele Invernizzi and Michele Parrinello},
  title = {{Rare Event Kinetics from Adaptive Bias Enhanced Sampling}},
  journal = {Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jctc.2c00806},
}
Figure