Rapid reduction of nurse-rated suicidality among psychiatric patients shortly following hospitalization

Yarong Ma, Xiaomin Liang, Bin Sun, Jie Zhang, Robert A. Rosenheck, Hongbo HeResearch Square 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that psychiatric hospitalization leads to a significant, rapid reduction in nurse-rated suicidality within just the first three days of admission. The findings suggest that the immediate transition to a safe, secure environment provides substantial clinical benefit even before long-term interventions, like medication or intensive psychotherapy, have time to take full effect.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Suicidality is the primary driver for psychiatric hospitalization, yet research typically focuses on long-term outcomes or the high-risk period immediately following discharge. There is a surprising lack of empirical evidence regarding the "acute" effect of the hospitalization itself—specifically what happens in those first few days.

The challenge in studying this is ethical: researchers cannot conduct a randomized controlled trial where suicidal patients are denied admission to a hospital. To bypass this, the authors examined the "pre-therapeutic window"—the first 72 hours—where the primary clinical change is likely driven by the shift in environment and safety rather than the physiological effects of new medications.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective analysis of medical records from 2016 at the Affiliated Brain Hospital of Guangzhou Medical University, the largest psychiatric facility in southern China.

  • Participants: 562 inpatients clinically judged to have elevated suicide risk upon admission.
  • Assessment Tool: The Nurses' Global Assessment of Suicide Risk (NGASR), a 15-item weighted scale.
  • The "NGASR-5": To measure rapid change, the authors focused on five specific items sensitive to short-term shifts: hopelessness, depression/loss of interest, withdrawal, suicidal intent, and suicide plans. They excluded "static" items like family history or recent stressful life events.
  • Statistical Analysis: The team compared scores from Day 1 (admission) to Day 3 using McNemar’s $\chi^2$ tests and T-tests. They also used logistic regression to identify which sociodemographic factors predicted a patient remaining at "high risk" by the third day.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of archived inpatient medical records ($n=562$) from a single large medical center. The sample was diverse in diagnosis:

  • Major Depressive Disorder (28.3%)
  • Schizophrenia spectrum disorders (26.3%)
  • Bipolar disorders (19.6%)
  • Manic episodes (11.4%)

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Safe Haven" Effect: The most significant finding is that suicidality scores dropped sharply before most psychotropic medications would have reached therapeutic levels. This points to the "non-specific" benefits of hospitalization: continuous observation, removal of access to lethal means, and the immediate reduction of social isolation.
  • Employment as a Protective Factor: Patients who were currently employed were significantly more likely to show a reduction in suicide risk by Day 3 (OR = 0.566). The authors speculate that employment may serve as a proxy for higher social functioning or provide a "reason for living" that facilitates quicker stabilization.
  • Hopelessness and Depression are Malleable: The items showing the most significant decline were "presence of hopelessness" and "evidence of depression." This suggests that simply being in a supportive, professional environment can rapidly alter a patient's immediate outlook.
  • Diagnosis Neutrality: Interestingly, a diagnosis of schizophrenia was not associated with a more severe or "stubborn" short-term suicide risk compared to other disorders in this sample, despite the common association between psychosis and prolonged risk.

Key Results

  • Quantitative Drop: The NGASR-5 scores declined from $6.3 \pm 2.8$ at admission to $4.6 \pm 3.0$ by Day 3 ($p < .001$).
  • Risk Category Shift: At admission, 66% of the sample was classified as "high risk." By the third day, this proportion dropped to 39.7%.
  • Effect Size: The change represented a Cohen’s $d$ of 0.578, which is considered a moderately large clinical effect.
  • Predictors: Baseline suicide risk was the strongest predictor of Day 3 risk (OR = 85.275), but being employed significantly reduced the likelihood of remaining high-risk (95% CI [0.361, 0.886]).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several important caveats:

  • Lack of a Control Group: Without a non-hospitalized comparison group, it is impossible to definitively prove that the hospital caused the drop, though the ethical barriers to such a group remain.
  • Regression to the Mean: Some of the reduction could be attributed to the natural fluctuation of acute distress.
  • Medication Data: The study lacked detailed data on medications initiated immediately prior to or during the first 48 hours, which could have influenced the results.
  • Generalizability: As a retrospective study from a single center in China, the results may not perfectly translate to different healthcare systems or cultural contexts.

Future research could benefit from prospective designs that include more granular data on the specific "milieu" factors (e.g., interaction with peers vs. staff) that contribute most to this rapid stabilization.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Background Suicidality is a major reason for psychiatric hospitalization but there have been no studies of the short-term changes in suicidality following psychiatric admission. To assess the short-term changes in suicidality during the first three days after psychiatric admission, when medications and other specific therapies are not likely to have taken effect and the primary benefit is likely to be from hospitalization. Methods A retrospective study of inpatients at risk for suicide was based on nurse-rated suicide assessments documented in medical records at a large psychiatric hospital in southern China. Suicidality was assessed with the Nurses' Global Assessment of Suicide Risk (NGASR) every day (1–3) following admission. Reduction of suicidality from first- to third-day were compared by using McNemar’s Chi-square tests and T-tests, followed by logistic regression to identify correlates of having high risk on day 3 following admission. Results The sample (n = 562) showed a relatively high level of average suicidality (NGASR = 9.2 ± 3.3) at admission with 33.8% reporting a prior suicide attempt. Significant reductions in suicidality were apparent by the third hospital day compared to baseline with NGASR-5 change items score declining from 6.3 ± 2.8 to 4.6 ± 3.0 (p &lt; .001, Cohen’s d = .578), indicating a moderately large change. Compared with those unemployed, being currently employed was associated with greater reduction in likelihood of being at high-risk on day 3 (OR = .568, 95%CI [.361, .895], p = .015). Conclusion This study demonstrates short-term substantial reduction in suicidality after only three days of hospitalization suggesting significant benefit from admission to a safe secure environment.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2024rapid,
  author = {Yarong Ma and Xiaomin Liang and Bin Sun and Jie Zhang and Robert A. Rosenheck and Hongbo He},
  title = {{Rapid reduction of nurse-rated suicidality among psychiatric patients shortly following hospitalization}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-4740209/v1},
}
Figure