Random finite noncommutative geometries and topological recursion

Shahab Azarfar, Masoud Khalkhali

Abstract

This paper investigates a model for quantum gravity on finite noncommutative spaces using the theory of blobbed topological recursion. The model is based on a particular class of random finite real spectral triples $(\mathcal{A}, \mathcal{H}, D, \gamma, J)$, specifically random matrix geometries of type (1,0), with a fixed fermion space and a distribution of the form $e^{-\mathcal{S}(D)} dD$ over the moduli space of Dirac operators. The action functional $\mathcal{S}(D)$ is defined as a sum of multi-trace terms, reflecting the spectral action principle. By deriving Schwinger–Dyson equations through a differential geometric approach, the authors demonstrate that the large $N$ expansion of connected correlators enumerates "stuffed maps"—discrete surfaces with complex internal topologies. Furthermore, the spectral curve of the model is analyzed, providing an explicit expression for the fundamental symmetric bidifferential $\omega_{0,2}$ in terms of the model's formal parameters.

Introduction

A fundamental challenge in theoretical physics is the formulation of a consistent theory of quantum gravity. Noncommutative Geometry (NCG) provides a unique framework for this by describing spacetime through spectral triples $(\mathcal{A}, \mathcal{H}, D, \gamma, J)$, where the metric information is encoded within the Dirac operator $D$. To quantize such a theory, one must perform a path integral over the moduli space of possible geometries—effectively integrating over the space of Dirac operators.

While previous research has utilized numerical simulations to explore these finite noncommutative spaces, an analytical framework for calculating correlators was largely absent. This paper bridges that gap by treating these geometries as random matrix models and applying the machinery of blobbed topological recursion to solve them analytically.

The Random Matrix Model of Type (1,0)

The authors focus on random matrix geometries of type (1,0), where the Dirac operator $D$ can be represented as a Hermitian matrix. The core of the model is the action functional $\mathcal{S}(D)$. Unlike standard matrix models that typically employ single-trace actions (e.g., $\text{Tr}(D^k)$), NCG requires a "multi-trace" action:

$$\mathcal{S}(D) = \sum_{i=1}^s \prod \text{Tr}(D^{n_i})$$

This multi-trace structure is essential for consistency with the spectral action principle in NCG, but it introduces significant mathematical complexity, as it implies non-local interactions between the eigenvalues of the Dirac operator.

Methodology: Differential Geometry and Recursion

To solve the model, the authors employ a multi-step analytical approach:

  1. Schwinger–Dyson Equations (SDEs): Instead of using traditional combinatorial loop equations, the authors derive the SDEs—the equations of motion for the correlators—using a differential geometric method. By leveraging the invariance of the action under unitary transformations, they apply Cartan’s magic formula and Stokes’s theorem to derive robust equations applicable to a wide class of models.
  2. Blobbed Topological Recursion: Standard topological recursion is insufficient for multi-trace actions. The authors utilize "blobbed" topological recursion, a generalized framework designed to handle the "blobs" (non-local interactions) introduced by the multi-trace terms in the action.
  3. Spectral Curve Analysis: The "spectral curve" $(\Sigma, \omega_{0,1}, \omega_{0,2})$ serves as the initial data for the recursion. The authors characterize this curve in detail, focusing on the "one-cut" regime where eigenvalues cluster into a single interval.

Key Insights: Stuffed Maps and Geometric Symmetry

A primary conceptual breakthrough of this work is the identification of the combinatorial objects enumerated by the large $N$ expansion. The authors show that the correlators $W_{g,n}$ are generating functions for stuffed maps.

In standard matrix models, correlators count "maps" (graphs embedded on surfaces). In this NCG-inspired model, the surfaces are "stuffed," meaning the building blocks of the discrete surface can possess their own internal topologies (genus $g > 0$). This provides a precise geometric interpretation of how multi-trace spectral actions correspond to more complex topological structures in Euclidean quantum gravity.

Results

The paper yields several significant results for the study of noncommutative quantum gravity:

  • Topological Expansion: It is rigorously proven that the connected $n$-point correlators $W_n$ possess a large $N$ expansion of topological type, where each term corresponds to a specific genus $g$.
  • Explicit Bidifferential: The authors derive an explicit expression for the fundamental symmetric bidifferential $\omega_{0,2}$. This bidifferential is the "engine" of the recursion; having an explicit form allows for the systematic calculation of all higher-order terms ($W_{g,n}$).
  • Recursive Solution: The study proves that all stable coefficients in the large $N$ expansion can be computed recursively using the blobbed topological recursion formula, effectively providing a complete analytical solution for this class of quantum gravity models.

Limitations and Future Directions

While this work establishes a powerful analytical framework, it is currently restricted to type (1,0) geometries and the one-cut regime. Future research is required to extend these results to other KO-dimensions to capture more physically realistic scenarios. Additionally, while the paper treats the matrix integrals as formal power series, investigating the actual convergence of these integrals for specific physical coupling constants remains an important open challenge for the physics community.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we investigate a model for quantum gravity on finite noncommutative spaces using the theory of blobbed topological recursion. The model is based on a particular class of random finite real spectral triples {(\mathcal{A}, \mathcal{H}, D, \gamma, J)} , called random matrix geometries of type {(1,0)} , with a fixed fermion space {(\mathcal{A}, \mathcal{H}, \gamma, J)} and a distribution of the form {e^{- \mathcal{S} (D)}\, {\mathrm{d}} D} over the moduli space of Dirac operators. The action functional {\mathcal{S} (D)} is considered to be a sum of terms of the form {\prod_{i=1}^s \mathrm{Tr} ({D^{n_i}})} for arbitrary {s \geqslant 1} . The Schwinger–Dyson equations satisfied by the connected correlators {W_n} of the corresponding multi-trace formal 1-Hermitian matrix model are derived by a differential geometric approach. It is shown that the coefficients {W_{g,n}} of the large N expansion of {W_n} ’s enumerate discrete surfaces, called stuffed maps, whose building blocks are of particular topologies. The spectral curve {( {\Sigma, \omega_{0,1}, \omega_{0,2}} )} of the model is investigated in detail. In particular, we derive an explicit expression for the fundamental symmetric bidifferential {\omega_{0,2}} in terms of the formal parameters of the model.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{azarfar2024random,
  author = {Shahab Azarfar and Masoud Khalkhali},
  title = {{Random finite noncommutative geometries and topological recursion}},
  booktitle = {Annales},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.4171/aihpd/188},
}
Figure