Raman Signatures of Broken Inversion Symmetry and In-plane Anisotropy in Type-II Weyl Semimetal Candidate TaIrTe4

Yinan Liu, Qiangqiang Gu, Peng Yu, Shaomian Qi, Na Zhang, Zhang Yinong, Xiumei Ma, Rui Zhu, Lianming Tong, Ji Feng, Zheng Liu, Jianhao ChenarXiv 2018 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The layered ternary compound $TaIrTe_4$ is a prominent candidate for hosting the recently predicted Type-II Weyl fermions. However, establishing the necessary broken inversion symmetry—a prerequisite for the existence of Weyl fermions—has remained a challenge. This study utilizes angle-resolved polarized Raman spectroscopy and high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HR-TEM) to provide definitive evidence of broken inversion symmetry in $TaIrTe_4$. Furthermore, the research introduces a nondestructive method for determining crystallographic orientation and reveals a significant in-plane electrical anisotropy of 200% at 10K, the highest recorded for materials with comparable metal-like carrier densities.

Introduction

Weyl semimetals represent a frontier in condensed matter physics, characterized by the presence of Weyl fermions—massless quasiparticles that could enable ultra-fast, low-dissipation electronic transport. The realization of these particles requires the crystal lattice to break either time-reversal or spatial inversion symmetry.

$TaIrTe_4$, a layered ternary compound, has been theoretically predicted to be a Type-II Weyl semimetal. Despite these predictions, experimental confirmation of its non-centrosymmetric structure has been elusive. Standard X-ray diffraction struggles to distinguish between symmetric and non-symmetric possible structures because the atomic displacements involved are incredibly subtle. This research aims to provide a "smoking gun" proof of broken symmetry using optical spectroscopy.

Experimental Methodology

To resolve the symmetry ambiguity, the research team combined experimental spectroscopy with high-level theoretical modeling:

  • Angle-Resolved Polarized Raman Spectroscopy: This served as the primary diagnostic tool. By rotating the crystal sample under polarized laser light, the researchers observed how specific atomic vibrations (phonons) responded to the light's orientation.
  • First-Principles Calculations (DFT): Using the Vienna ab initio simulation package (VASP), the team calculated expected phonon modes for both centrosymmetric and non-centrosymmetric versions of the crystal to compare with experimental data.
  • High-Resolution Transmission Electron Microscopy (HR-TEM): Used to verify lattice constants and atomic arrangements, providing a ground-truth for the Raman data.
  • Electrical Transport: The team fabricated devices with 12 electrodes arranged in a circular pattern to measure conductivity at various angles and temperatures (down to 10K).

Definitive Proof of Broken Inversion Symmetry

The definitive evidence for broken inversion symmetry came from the identification of specific Raman-active modes. In a centrosymmetric crystal (one with inversion symmetry), certain vibrational modes are "forbidden" or inactive in Raman scattering.

The researchers identified eight specific Raman peaks that should not exist if the crystal were symmetric. The clear observation of these peaks—particularly "Mode D"—serves as unambiguous proof that the symmetry is broken. The experimental Raman frequencies matched theoretical predictions for the non-centrosymmetric space group $Pmn2_1$ with an uncertainty of less than 0.46 meV. This confirmation establishes $TaIrTe_4$ as a valid host for the predicted four Type-II Weyl points.

A Nondestructive Crystallographic Compass

Beyond symmetry confirmation, the study demonstrates that angle-resolved Raman spectroscopy can serve as a "compass" for $TaIrTe_4$. By correlating the intensity patterns of specific Raman modes with the $a$-axis and $b$-axis identified via HR-TEM, the researchers established a "recipe" to determine the exact orientation of a crystal flake using only a laser. This provides a fast, nondestructive alternative to electron microscopy, which is essential for the efficient fabrication of future topological devices.

Record-Breaking Electrical Anisotropy

One of the most surprising findings was the material's extreme electrical anisotropy. While "good metals" like copper or silver are typically isotropic (conducting electricity equally in all directions), $TaIrTe_4$ exhibits a massive directional bias.

  • Anisotropy Ratio: The electrical anisotropy ratio ($\sigma_a/\sigma_b$) reached 2.0 (200%) at 10K and remained as high as 1.7 even at room temperature.
  • The Anisotropy Paradox: This is the strongest electrical anisotropy ever recorded for a material with such high carrier density ($\sim 1.2 \times 10^{27} m^{-3}$).

By analyzing Hall mobility, the researchers determined that this lopsidedness is not caused by impurities or scattering. Instead, it is an intrinsic property: electrons literally "feel" heavier when moving along the $b$-axis compared to the $a$-axis due to the material's unique electronic band structure.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This work provides the foundational structural evidence required to classify $TaIrTe_4$ as a Type-II Weyl semimetal. The discovery that the flakes are air-stable and possess massive electrical anisotropy suggests immediate practical applications, such as the creation of directional interconnects in integrated circuits.

While the study proves the structural prerequisite for Weyl fermions, the "chiral anomaly"—a classic transport signature of these particles—has not yet been observed in $TaIrTe_4$. This is likely because the Weyl points are predicted to lie above the Fermi level. Future work involving chemical doping or electrical gating to shift the electron levels will be necessary to directly probe these exotic particles in action.

Summary updated

Abstract

The layered ternary compound TaIrTe4 is an important candidate to host the recently predicted type-II Weyl Fermions. However, a direct and definitive proof of the absence of inversion symmetry in this material, a prerequisite for the existence of Weyl Fermions, has so far remained evasive. Herein, an unambiguous identification of the broken inversion symmetry in TaIrTe4 is established using angle-resolved polarized Raman spectroscopy. Combining with high-resolution transmission electron microscopy, we demonstrate an efficient and nondestructive recipe to determine the exact crystallographic orientation of TaIrTe4 crystals. Such technique could be extended to the fast identification and characterization of other type-II Weyl Fermions candidates. A surprisingly strong in-plane electrical anisotropy in TaIrTe4 thin flakes is also revealed, up to 200% at 10K, which is the strongest known electrical anisotropy for materials with comparable carrier density, notably in such good metals as copper and silver.
BibTeX
@misc{liu2018raman,
  author = {Yinan Liu and Qiangqiang Gu and Peng Yu and Shaomian Qi and Na Zhang and Zhang Yinong and Xiumei Ma and Rui Zhu and Lianming Tong and Ji Feng and Zheng Liu and Jianhao Chen},
  title = {{Raman Signatures of Broken Inversion Symmetry and In-plane Anisotropy in Type-II Weyl Semimetal Candidate TaIrTe4}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1804.00797},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.00797},
}
Figure