Radio Antenna Design for Sky-Averaged 21cm Cosmology Experiments: The REACH Case

John Cumner, Eloy de Lera Acedo, Dirk I. L. de Villiers, Dominic Anstey, C. I. Kolitsidas, B. Gurdon, Nicolas Fagnoni, Paul Alexander, G. Bernardi, H. T. J. Bevins, S. Carey, Jean Cavillot, Riccardo Chiello, Christophe Craeye, W. Croukamp, J. A. Ely, Anastasia Fialkov, Thomas Gessey-Jones, Quentin Gueuning, Will Handley, R. E. Hills, Alec Josaitis, Girish Kulkarni, Alessio Magro, R. Maiolino, P. Daniel Meerburg, Shikhar Mittal, Jonathan R. Pritchard, Ewald Puchwein, N. Razavi‐Ghods, I. L. V. Roque, Anchal Saxena, K. H. Scheutwinkel, Emma Shen, Peter Sims, O. Smirnov, Marta Spinelli, Kristian Zarb Adami

TL;DR

This paper details the rigorous design process for the REACH radio antenna, crucial for detecting the faint 21cm signal from the early universe. By developing a quantitative figure-of-merit framework and employing detailed simulations, the authors successfully designed a dipole antenna with a 2.5:1 frequency bandwidth, balancing spectral smoothness and impedance matching for accurate cosmological measurements.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The detection of the 21cm hydrogen signal from the Cosmic Dawn and Epoch of Reionization is a key goal in cosmology, offering insights into the universe's earliest stages. However, this signal is incredibly faint, buried under orders of magnitude stronger foregrounds from our own galaxy and extragalactic sources. Experiments like EDGES have reported detections, but verifying these results and understanding potential systematic errors requires highly sensitive instruments and sophisticated data analysis. Specifically, designing antennas that can accurately capture this faint signal while minimizing instrumental biases and allowing for robust calibration is a significant challenge. This paper focuses on the design of the REACH (Radio Experiment for the Analysis of Cosmic Hydrogen) experiment's antenna, aiming to address these challenges by developing a systematic, figure-of-merit-driven design process.

Methods

The authors employed a quantitative, figure-of-merit-based antenna design methodology. This involved:

  • Developing Figures of Merit (FoMs): A comprehensive set of FoMs was defined, encompassing both generic antenna properties (like impedance matching, represented by |S11|) and those specific to global 21cm cosmology experiments (such as beam chromaticity, represented by $\sigma$, and calibratable bandwidth, $\beta$).
  • Numerical Modeling and Simulation: The CST Microwave Studio software was used for detailed electromagnetic simulations of various antenna designs. This included modeling antenna blades, balun structures, and ground planes.
  • Iterative Refinement: A recursive design process was implemented, starting with a broad selection of antenna styles (dipoles, monopoles, log-spirals, horns). Promising designs were then optimized using the defined FoMs and further evaluated using a mock detection pipeline.
  • Mock Detection Pipeline: This crucial step involved injecting simulated 21cm signals into realistic sky models and testing the antenna's ability to detect them. This provided a more stringent assessment of antenna performance under realistic observational conditions.
  • Parameter Space Exploration: Initial designs were explored using Latin hypercube sampling, followed by functional minimization of polynomial fits to the FoMs to identify optimal parameter sets.

Datasets

  • Sky Models: Two primary sky models were used:
  • The unfiltered NF version of the Haslam map with a constant spectral index $\beta = 2.5$.
  • The DSDS (destriped desourced) updated Haslam map, with a pixel-by-pixel spectral index derived from observational data.
  • CMB Data: Planck data was used for CMB contributions.
  • Simulated Data: The entire design and evaluation process relied heavily on simulated data generated through CST simulations and the mock detection pipeline.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Figure of Merit Driven Design is Crucial: A systematic approach using quantitative figures of merit is essential for designing antennas for challenging experiments like REACH, where subtle instrumental effects can mimic or mask the faint cosmological signal.
  • Beam Chromaticity is a Major Challenge: The frequency-dependent nature of antenna beams (chromaticity) significantly impacts foreground calibration and signal detection. Minimizing this chromaticity is a key design goal.
  • Trade-offs are Inevitable: Designing an antenna involves balancing competing requirements. For instance, a reduced antenna height might favor chromaticity but be unfavorable for impedance matching.
  • Mock Detection Pipeline is a Powerful Tool: This pipeline provides a realistic assessment of an antenna's ability to detect the target signal, going beyond simple FoM evaluation.
  • Dipole Antennas Remain a Viable Choice: Despite the complexity of other designs, the dipole antenna, with its geometric simplicity and established use in similar experiments, was chosen as the initial design for REACH due to its balance of performance and manufacturability.

Key Results

  • REACH Dipole Antenna Design: The paper details the design of a dipole antenna for the REACH experiment with a 2.5:1 frequency bandwidth (55-135 MHz).
  • FoM Optimization: The design process successfully optimized the antenna based on the defined figures of merit, balancing beam smoothness, impedance matching, and bandwidth.
  • Mock Detection Performance: The prototype antenna demonstrated the ability to confidently detect injected Gaussian signals with realistic parameters, achieving a 2.5:1 odds confidence to reject a null signal.
  • Simulation Accuracy: Simulations of the prototype antenna showed good agreement with measured reflection coefficients, validating the computational models used in the design process.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Initial Goal Values: The goal values for the figures of merit were chosen based on initial exploration and preliminary results. These are expected to be updated as more is learned from the REACH experiment's deployment and data analysis.
  • Ground Plane Size: The prototype antenna used a smaller ground plane than planned for the final deployment. While simulations showed this had a negligible effect on impedance, further validation in the field is necessary.
  • Refinement in the Field: The authors acknowledge that further refinements to the antenna design will likely be required after deployment and initial observations, as complications may only become apparent in real-world conditions.
  • Conical Log-Spiral Antenna: While the dipole was chosen for initial development, the paper notes that a conical log-spiral design will be considered later, leveraging the refined methodologies.
  • Sky Model Uncertainty: The paper highlights the significant impact of sky model uncertainties on calibration and suggests that for confident detection, these effects must be thoroughly accounted for in the data analysis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Following the reported detection of an absorption profile associated with the 21[Formula: see text]cm sky-averaged signal from the Cosmic Dawn by the EDGES experiment in 2018, a number of experiments have been set up to verify this result. This paper discusses the design process used for global 21[Formula: see text]cm experiments, focusing specifically on the Radio Experiment for the Analysis of Cosmic Hydrogen (REACH). This experiment will seek to understand and compensate for systematic errors present using detailed modeling and characterization of the instrumentation. Detailed quantitative figures of merit and numerical modeling are used to assist the design process of the REACH dipole antenna (one of the two antenna designs for REACH Phase I). This design process produced a 2.5:1 frequency bandwidth dipole. The aim of this design was to balance spectral smoothness and low impedance reflections with the ability to describe and understand the antenna response to the sky signal to inform the critically important calibration during observation and data analysis.
BibTeX
@article{cumner2021radio,
  author = {John Cumner and Eloy de Lera Acedo and Dirk I. L. de Villiers and Dominic Anstey and C. I. Kolitsidas and B. Gurdon and Nicolas Fagnoni and Paul Alexander and G. Bernardi and H. T. J. Bevins and S. Carey and Jean Cavillot and Riccardo Chiello and Christophe Craeye and W. Croukamp and J. A. Ely and Anastasia Fialkov and Thomas Gessey-Jones and Quentin Gueuning and Will Handley and R. E. Hills and Alec Josaitis and Girish Kulkarni and Alessio Magro and R. Maiolino and P. Daniel Meerburg and Shikhar Mittal and Jonathan R. Pritchard and Ewald Puchwein and N. Razavi‐Ghods and I. L. V. Roque and Anchal Saxena and K. H. Scheutwinkel and Emma Shen and Peter Sims and O. Smirnov and Marta Spinelli and Kristian Zarb Adami},
  title = {{Radio Antenna Design for Sky-Averaged 21cm Cosmology Experiments: The REACH Case}},
  journal = {Journal of Astronomical Instrumentation},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1142/s2251171722500015},
}
Figure