r-Local Unlabeled Sensing: Improved Algorithm and Applications

Ahmed Ali Abbasi, Abiy Tasissa, Shuchin Aeron

TL;DR

This paper tackles the "unlabeled sensing" problem, where we try to recover a signal from noisy linear measurements that have been arbitrarily permuted. They introduce a new, more challenging "r-local" permutation model and propose a novel proximal alternating minimization algorithm that provably converges and outperforms existing methods on synthetic and real-world data, including a formulation of the 1D unassigned distance geometry problem.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Imagine you're trying to reconstruct a signal, say an image or a set of coordinates, using a linear model. The standard approach assumes you know exactly which measurement corresponds to which part of your signal. However, in many real-world scenarios, this correspondence is lost – the measurements are "unlabeled." This is the core of the unlabeled sensing problem: recovering a signal $X^*$ from measurements $Y = P^*BX^* + W$, where $B$ is the known measurement matrix, $W$ is noise, and $P^*$ is an unknown permutation matrix that scrambles the measurements.

This paper focuses on a specific type of permutation: "r-local." This means the permutation matrix is structured into blocks of size $r \times r$. They argue this r-local model is actually harder to solve than previously studied "k-sparse" permutation models, especially when the measurement matrix $B$ is Gaussian. The challenge lies in efficiently and accurately recovering both the signal $X^*$ and the permutation $P^*$ simultaneously.

Methods

The authors propose a Proximal Alternating Minimization (PAM) algorithm. This is an iterative approach that alternates between updating the signal estimate ($X$) and the permutation estimate ($P$).

Here's a breakdown of the key methodological aspects:

  • Alternating Minimization: The core idea is to optimize for $X$ and $P$ one at a time, holding the other fixed. This is a common strategy for non-convex problems like this.
  • Proximal Operator: To ensure convergence, they introduce a regularization term (a "proximal" term) in each update step. This term encourages the new estimate to stay close to the previous one, which helps to overcome the non-convexity and guarantees convergence to a first-order stationary point. This is a theoretical improvement over simpler alternating minimization schemes.
  • r-Local Structure Exploitation: For the specific r-local permutation model, they show that the update for $P$ can be broken down into $n/r$ smaller, independent optimization problems, each involving an $r \times r$ permutation matrix. This makes the algorithm computationally efficient.
  • Initialization: They use a "collapsed initialization" strategy, which sums up groups of measurements to get an initial estimate of $BX$. This is a practical detail that helps the algorithm start from a reasonable point.

Datasets

The paper evaluates their algorithm on:

  • Synthetic Data: Generated according to the r-local unlabeled sensing model with varying parameters (noise levels, dimensions, block sizes).
  • YALE B Dataset: Used for the scrambled image restoration application. This dataset contains images of faces under varying lighting conditions.
  • MNIST Dataset: Also used for scrambled image restoration. This is a well-known dataset of handwritten digits.

They also formulate the 1-dimensional unassigned distance geometry problem (uDGP) as a new benchmark for unlabeled sensing with a structured measurement matrix.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • r-Local is Harder: The paper provides theoretical justification (via lower bounds on error probability) that the r-local permutation model is more challenging than k-sparse models for Gaussian matrices, especially in the large-n regime. This highlights the need for specialized algorithms.
  • PAM for Non-Convexity: The use of proximal terms in alternating minimization is a powerful technique to achieve theoretical convergence guarantees for non-convex optimization problems, which is crucial for problems involving discrete variables like permutations.
  • Block Structure Efficiency: Decomposing the r-local permutation update into smaller, independent block problems is a smart way to make the algorithm computationally feasible for large-scale problems.
  • uDGP as Unlabeled Sensing: Reformulating the 1D uDGP as an unlabeled sensing problem provides a new perspective and allows existing unlabeled sensing algorithms to be applied, while also demonstrating the practical utility of the r-local model.

Key Results

  • Improved Performance: The proposed proximal alternating minimization algorithm consistently outperforms existing methods (like Biconvex, Levensort, One-step, and RLUS) on synthetic data for recovering both the permutation $P^*$ and the signal $X^*$, especially for the r-local model.
  • Scrambled Image Restoration: The algorithm achieves better PSNR (Peak Signal-to-Noise Ratio) values compared to the RLUS algorithm on both YALE B and MNIST datasets for unscrambling images.
  • 1D uDGP: The algorithm demonstrates good performance in recovering point coordinates for the 1D uDGP even with noisy distance measurements, a problem that is generally NP-hard.
  • Convergence Guarantee: The algorithm is theoretically proven to converge to a first-order stationary point of the objective function.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: While efficient for the r-local model, the total cost of updating all local permutations can still be significant ($O(nr^2)$).
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring information-theoretic achievability limits for the r-local permutation model and uDGP, which would provide theoretical bounds on how well these problems can be solved in the best-case scenario. They also mention that their algorithm outperforms existing ones, implying that further algorithmic improvements might be possible.

Summary updated

Abstract

The unlabeled sensing problem is to solve a noisy linear system of equations under unknown permutation of the measurements. We study a particular case of the problem where the permutations are restricted to be r-local, i.e. the permutation matrix is block diagonal with r×r blocks. Assuming a Gaussian measurement matrix, we argue that the r-local permutation model is more challenging compared to a recent sparse permutation model. We propose a proximal alternating minimization algorithm for the general unlabeled sensing problem that provably converges to a first order stationary point. Applied to the r-local model, we show that the resulting algorithm is efficient. We validate the algorithm on synthetic and real datasets. We also formulate the 1-d unassigned distance geometry problem as an unlabeled sensing problem with a structured measurement matrix.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{abbasi2022r,
  author = {Ahmed Ali Abbasi and Abiy Tasissa and Shuchin Aeron},
  title = {{r-Local Unlabeled Sensing: Improved Algorithm and Applications}},
  booktitle = {IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech and Signal Processing},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=hqkZnSxSWM},
}
Figure