Quantum process tomography of excitonic dimers from two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy. I. General theory and application to homodimers

Joel Yuen-Zhou, Alán Aspuru‐GuzikThe Journal of Chemical Physics 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method to perform quantum process tomography (QPT) on molecular dimers using two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy (2D-ES). By analyzing the spectral features obtained from carefully controlled laser pulses, researchers can reconstruct the dynamics of the dimer's excitonic states, effectively "characterizing the quantum black box" of the molecular system. This approach offers a powerful new way to understand complex molecular dynamics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the intricate dynamics of excited states in complex molecular systems, especially those with multiple interacting chromophores (like molecular dimers), is a significant challenge in chemistry and physics. Traditional spectroscopic methods often struggle to disentangle the various pathways and processes occurring. The authors aim to bridge this gap by proposing a method to fully characterize the quantum dynamics of these systems. They frame this as a "quantum process tomography" problem, analogous to characterizing quantum gates in quantum information processing, but applied to condensed-phase molecular systems. The core question is: can we infer the time-evolving quantum state of a multichromophoric system from a sequence of 2D-ES measurements?

Methods

The paper adapts the framework of Quantum Process Tomography (QPT) to analyze data from two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy (2D-ES). The key idea is to treat the molecular dimer as a "quantum black box" and use 2D-ES experiments to probe its internal dynamics.

  • Quantum Process Matrix (X(T)): The central object is the process matrix, $\chi(T)$, which describes the linear evolution of the system's density matrix over time. Reconstructing $\chi(T)$ provides a complete characterization of the system's dynamics.
  • 2D-ES as a QPT Tool: The authors show how peaks in the 2D-ES spectrum, obtained from specific laser pulse sequences (coherence, waiting, and echo times), directly relate to elements of the process matrix $\chi(T)$.
  • Polarization Control: By systematically varying the polarization of the laser pulses used in the 2D-ES experiments, different elements of $\chi(T)$ can be selectively probed.
  • Homodimer Simplification: For homodimers (where the two chromophores are identical), isotropic averaging of the signals leads to a simplification. Coherence-to-population transfer signals vanish, allowing for a partial QPT with just two polarization-controlled experiments.
  • Angle Extraction: Crucially, the analysis of the 2D-ES data for homodimers allows for the self-consistent determination of the angle between the transition dipole moments of the two sites. This provides simultaneous structural and dynamical information.
  • Numerical Modeling: The theory is validated using a secular Redfield approach to model the system's dynamics, including bath interactions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and numerical simulations using model systems.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • 2D-ES as a Quantum Tomography Tool: The most significant insight is demonstrating that 2D-ES, a powerful spectroscopic technique, can be directly mapped onto the framework of QPT. This opens up new avenues for understanding molecular dynamics from a quantum information perspective.
  • Complete Characterization of Excitonic Dynamics: By reconstructing the process matrix $\chi(T)$, researchers can achieve a complete characterization of the single-exciton manifold dynamics, including population transfer, coherence evolution, and their interplay.
  • Homodimer Simplification: The vanishing of coherence-to-population transfer signals in homodimers under isotropic averaging is a key simplification. It means that a full characterization of the observable dynamics can be achieved with fewer experiments than initially thought.
  • Simultaneous Structural and Dynamical Information: The ability to extract the angle between transition dipole moments from the 2D-ES data alongside the dynamical information ($\chi(T)$) is a powerful synergy. This provides a more holistic understanding of the molecular system.
  • Bridging Spectroscopy and QIP: The paper explicitly bridges the gap between traditional spectroscopic studies of excitation energy transfer and the rigorous tools of quantum information processing (QIP).

Key Results

  • A theoretical framework is established for performing QPT of molecular dimers using 2D-ES.
  • For homodimers, a partial QPT is shown to be achievable with only two polarization-controlled 2D-ES experiments, simplifying experimental requirements.
  • The angle between the site transition dipoles can be self-consistently determined from the 2D-ES data.
  • Numerical simulations for a model homodimer validate the theoretical framework, showing the reconstruction of extractable elements of $\chi(T)$ and the determination of the dipole angle.
  • The study demonstrates that the dynamics of populations and coherences can be independently analyzed, leading to multiexponential integrated dynamics.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Partial QPT for Homodimers: While the method is powerful, for homodimers, only a partial QPT is possible due to the vanishing of certain coherence-to-population transfer terms under isotropic averaging.
  • Experimental Implementation: The paper acknowledges that aspects like static disorder and resolving vibronic structure would add complexity to experimental implementation and require further theoretical development (e.g., compressed sensing approaches).
  • Heterodimers: A detailed analysis for heterodimers is deferred to a companion paper.
  • Non-Markovian Effects: While the current model uses secular Redfield theory (implying Markovian dynamics), the authors anticipate that deviations from this assumption (non-Markovian behavior) might occur for short coherence times and would require further investigation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest future studies will address:
  • Implementation of QPT for heterodimers.
  • The role of static disorder and its impact on signal averaging.
  • Resolving vibronic structure and incorporating nuclear wavepacket dynamics.
  • Exploring alternative spectroscopic techniques for more robust QPT.
  • Investigating non-Markovian dynamics and non-secular processes.
  • Probing quantum entanglement in excitonic states.

Summary updated

Abstract

Is it possible to infer the time evolving quantum state of a multichromophoric system from a sequence of two-dimensional electronic spectra (2D-ES) as a function of waiting time? Here we provide a positive answer for a tractable model system: a coupled dimer. After exhaustively enumerating the Liouville pathways associated to each peak in the 2D-ES, we argue that by judiciously combining the information from a series of experiments varying the polarization and frequency components of the pulses, detailed information at the amplitude level about the input and output quantum states at the waiting time can be obtained. This possibility yields a quantum process tomography (QPT) of the single-exciton manifold, which completely characterizes the open quantum system dynamics through the reconstruction of the process matrix. In this manuscript, we present the general theory as well as specific and numerical results for a homodimer, for which we prove that signals stemming from coherence to population transfer and vice versa vanish upon isotropic averaging, therefore, only allowing for a partial QPT in such case. However, this fact simplifies the spectra, and it follows that only two polarization controlled experiments (and no pulse-shaping requirements) suffice to yield the elements of the process matrix, which survive under isotropic averaging. Redundancies in the 2D-ES amplitudes allow for the angle between the two site transition dipole moments to be self-consistently obtained, hence simultaneously yielding structural and dynamical information of the dimer. Model calculations are presented, as well as an error analysis in terms of the angle between the dipoles and peak amplitude extraction. In the second article accompanying this study, we numerically exemplify the theory for heterodimers and carry out a detailed error analysis for such case. This investigation reveals an exciting quantum information processing (QIP) approach to spectroscopic experiments of excitonic systems, and hence, bridges an important gap between theoretical studies on excitation energy transfer from the QIP standpoint and experimental methods to study such systems in the chemical physics community.
BibTeX
@article{yuenzhou2011quantum,
  author = {Joel Yuen-Zhou and Alán Aspuru‐Guzik},
  title = {{Quantum process tomography of excitonic dimers from two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy. I. General theory and application to homodimers}},
  journal = {The Journal of Chemical Physics},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1063/1.3569694},
}
Figure