Quantized crystalline-electromagnetic responses in insulators

Sachin Vaidya, André Grossi Fonseca, Mark R. Hirsbrunner, Taylor L. Hughes, Marin SoljačićarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: We introduce new classes of gapped topological phases characterized by quantized crystalline-electromagnetic responses, termed "multipolar Chern insulators". These systems are characterized by nonsymmorphic momentum-space symmetries and mirror symmetries, leading to quantization of momentum-weighted Berry curvature multipole moments. We construct lattice models for such phases and confirm their quantized responses through numerical calculations. These systems exhibit bound charge and momentum densities at lattice and magnetic defects, and currents induced by electric or time-varying strain fields. Our work extends the classification of topological matter by uncovering novel symmetry-protected topological phases with quantized responses.

Introduction

The discovery of topological phases of matter has revolutionized our understanding of condensed systems, with the "gold standard" for a robust phase being the observation of a quantized response. While the Quantum Hall effect provides a paradigm for electromagnetic responses—where the transverse current is exactly proportional to an integer Chern number—crystalline-electromagnetic responses have historically been more elusive. Crystalline responses, where electronic properties are coupled to lattice deformations like strain and dislocations, have typically lacked fundamental quantization, often depending on material-specific details.

This work introduces "multipolar Chern insulators," a new class of gapped topological phases where crystalline responses are fundamentally quantized. By leveraging nonsymmorphic symmetries that effectively twist momentum space into non-orientable manifolds, the authors demonstrate that these materials bind precise amounts of charge and momentum to crystalline defects, much like the Quantum Hall effect binds charge to magnetic flux.

Theoretical Framework and Methods

The researchers utilize an effective action approach, extending the standard Chern-Simons framework to include translational gauge fields ($e^a_\mu$) alongside electromagnetic gauge fields ($A_\mu$). This unified treatment allows for a description of how electrons respond to both magnetic flux and lattice strain on equal footing.

Hierarchy of topological actions and their corresponding static and dynamical responses.

A key innovation is the identification of nonsymmorphic momentum-space symmetries. These operations involve a reflection or rotation combined with a fractional shift in momentum, which partitions the Brillouin Zone into non-orientable manifolds, such as the Klein bottle or the Real Projective Plane ($RP^2$). These geometric constraints prevent the arbitrary redistribution of Berry curvature, effectively "pinning" its momentum-weighted moments—dipoles ($D_i$) and quadrupoles ($Q_{ij}$)—to quantized values (e.g., multiples of $\pi$ or $2\pi^2$).

Results and Numerical Validation

The study confirms these theoretical predictions through numerical simulations of two-band tight-binding models on square lattices. In the dipolar Chern insulator phase, the Berry dipole $D_y$ is quantized to multiples of $\pi$. This leads to a new version of the famous Streda formula: while the original relates charge density to magnetic fields ($\rho \propto C B_z$), this version relates charge density to lattice strain ($\rho \propto D_y B^y_z$).

Quantization in dipolar Chern insulators: from non-orientable momentum space to charge density response.

In the dipolar model, the authors demonstrated that inserting a "translation flux" (a dislocation) binds a precise, quantized amount of electronic charge to the defect site. For quadrupolar phases, the Berry quadrupole $Q_{xy}$ is quantized to $2\pi^2 n$. These systems exhibit unique dynamical responses, such as momentum currents induced by time-varying shear strain. In these currents, counter-propagating charges carry momentum in the same direction, a phenomenon previously unobserved in this quantized form. The numerical results show perfect agreement with the theoretical quantized predictions, highlighting the robustness of these phases against small perturbations.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This work extends the classification of topological matter by uncovering novel symmetry-protected phases with quantized crystalline responses. By showing that geometry and electronics are inextricably linked through nonsymmorphic symmetries, the authors open a path toward a new hierarchy of topological materials.

While the current study focuses on non-interacting 2D systems, future research will explore the effects of strong electron-electron interactions and extensions to 3D "octupolar" insulators. Potential experimental realizations include photonic crystals, acoustic metamaterials, or moiré materials like twisted bilayer graphene, where lattice geometry can be precisely engineered to observe these quantized crystalline-electromagnetic phenomena.

Summary updated

Abstract

We introduce new classes of gapped topological phases characterized by quantized crystalline-electromagnetic responses, termed "multipolar Chern insulators". These systems are characterized by nonsymmorphic momentum-space symmetries and mirror symmetries, leading to quantization of momentum-weighted Berry curvature multipole moments. We construct lattice models for such phases and confirm their quantized responses through numerical calculations. These systems exhibit bound charge and momentum densities at lattice and magnetic defects, and currents induced by electric or time-varying strain fields. Our work extends the classification of topological matter by uncovering novel symmetry-protected topological phases with quantized responses.
BibTeX
@misc{vaidya2025quantized,
  author = {Sachin Vaidya and André Grossi Fonseca and Mark R. Hirsbrunner and Taylor L. Hughes and Marin Soljačić},
  title = {{Quantized crystalline-electromagnetic responses in insulators}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2503.09970},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.09970},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure