Quantitative scenarios for cascading risks in AI, climate, synthetic bio, and financial markets by 2075

Trond Arne Undheim, Taimur AhmadFrontiers in Complex Systems 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Humanity faces a myriad of existential technology, geopolitical, and ecological risks. This paper analyzes the possibility that negative shocks superimpose and multiply their effects, leading to catastrophic macro-dynamics. Methodologically, this paper presents a rare, quantitative scenario model superimposed upon narrative scenarios where the cascading economic effects of 19 quantitative indicators of growth or decline are projected into 2075. These indicators map onto five narrative scenarios and are subsequently re-combined to study effects of plausible cascading risk events coming to pass in the 50-year period between 2025 and 2075. Results indicate that even in the case of deeply catastrophic singular events, the world would eventually recover within 25 years, as has historically been the case. The exception is that in the event of several catastrophic events in short order around the midpoint of the 50-year scenario timeline, the cascading risk escalation would create formidable negative cascades. The possibility of a protracted depression and no visible recovery within 25 years is the result. However, if we assume a modest interaction effect, even with just 3-5 co-occurring catastrophes, the result becomes a path towards humanity’s extinction based on economic decline alone.

Introduction: Beyond Siloed Risk Assessment

Traditional risk assessment often operates in silos, focusing on single "X-risks" (existential risks) like pandemics or nuclear standoffs. However, in a hyper-connected global society, risks are rarely isolated. A climate-driven drought might trigger a financial crisis, which in turn destabilizes the governance needed to regulate runaway AI or contain a lab leak. This paper addresses the "methodological chaos" in foresight studies by bridging the gap between qualitative narrative scenarios and quantitative economic modeling, specifically investigating how many co-occurring hazards would be required to put the world on an irreversible path toward extinction.

Methodology

The research employs a two-tier approach combining narrative storylines with longitudinal data projections for the period 2025–2075. The researchers developed five distinct narrative scenarios: Growth and Collapse, Climate Cataclysm, Runaway AI, Synthetic Bio Unleashed, and World War III.

To quantify these narratives, 19 indicators were identified across six critical dimensions: Sci-Tech, Social Dynamics, Ecology, Health, Economics, and Governance. These indicators, sourced from institutions like the World Bank, UNDP, and Our World In Data, serve as the basis for Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) projections.

Figure 1: List of quantitative indicators categorized by dimension.

To model cascades, the authors applied a multiplicative effect rather than simple addition. In the "Monster Scenario"—where all negative conditions apply—a 30% additional weight was added to downward impacts to simulate the systemic friction and negative macro-dynamics that occur when multiple global systems fail simultaneously.

Key Insights: Recovery Rules and Midpoint Vulnerability

A central finding of the study is the 25-Year Recovery Rule. Historically, global systems have recovered from singular "deeply catastrophic" events (such as the Great Depression or World Wars) within approximately 25 years. The model confirms that even a simulated World War III or a Runaway AI shock allows for eventual recovery if it occurs in isolation.

However, the model identifies a Midpoint Vulnerability. Shocks occurring around the 2050 midpoint are particularly dangerous. If multiple catastrophes hit in short order during this window, the cascading risk escalation prevents the typical recovery cycle. Furthermore, the model suggests that global trade is significantly more fragile than raw GDP; trade recovery is hampered by the likely emergence of discretionary trade barriers and "fortress" mentalities during crises.

Scenario Analysis and Results

The quantitative projections reveal a stark threshold for global stability. While singular shocks like a Climate Cataclysm show a clear recovery curve by 2075, the "Monster" threshold—where 3–5 catastrophes co-occur—leads to a path toward humanity’s extinction. In this scenario, the interaction effect is so severe that there is no visible recovery within the 50-year timeline.

Figure 2: Comparison of growth rates across five narrative scenarios for 2075.

Specific findings include:

  • World War III: This scenario models an 80% reduction in 2025-level GDP by 2070 due to nuclear winter and governance collapse, followed by stagnant recovery.
  • AI/SynBio Synergy: The combination of Runaway AI and Synthetic Biology creates a staggering initial growth burst followed by a catastrophic nosedive as unaligned AI and lab leaks interact with a deteriorating environment.
  • Economic Extinction: The paper posits that humanity could face extinction through a terminal economic decline where the material basis of the economy becomes too broken to sustain life.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While these projections carry a degree of uncertainty due to model assumptions, the implications are clear: humanity must either avoid significant cascading effects at all costs or identify novel ways to recover compared to previous depressions. Future work should expand the indicator set and include explicit mortality modeling to better capture the human cost beyond economic proxies like GDP and CAGR.

Summary updated

Abstract

Humanity faces a myriad of existential technology, geopolitical, and ecological risks. The paper analyzes the possibility that negative shocks superimpose and multiply their effects, leading to catastrophic macro-dynamics. Methodologically, this paper presents a rare, quantitative scenario model superimposed upon narrative scenarios where the cascading economic effects of 19 quantitative indicators of growth or decline are projected into 2075. These indicators map onto five narrative scenarios, and are subsequently re-combined to study effects of plausible cascading risk events coming to pass in the 50 years period between 2025 and 2075. Results indicate that even in the case of deeply catastrophic singular events, the world would eventually recover within 25 years, as has historically been the case. The exception is that in the event of several catastrophic events in short order around the midpoint of the 50-year scenario timeline, the cascading risk escalation would create formidable negative cascades. The possibility of a protracted depression and no visible recovery within 25 years is the result. However, if we assume a modest interaction effect, even with just 3-5 co-occurring catastrophes, the result becomes a path towards humanity’s extinction based on economic decline alone. The implications are that humanity either needs to avoid significant cascading effects at all costs or needs to identify novel ways to recover compared to previous depressions. Given the amount of model assumptions they rely upon, these projections carry a degree of uncertainty. Further study should therefore be conducted with a larger set of indicators and impacts, including mortality modeling, to assess how much worse plausible real-world outcomes might be compared to the simplified economic model deployed here.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{undheim2024quantitative,
  author = {Trond Arne Undheim and Taimur Ahmad},
  title = {{Quantitative scenarios for cascading risks in AI, climate, synthetic bio, and financial markets by 2075}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Complex Systems},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fcpxs.2024.1323321},
}
Figure