Dyadic risk mechanisms–a nomenclature for 36 proto-cascading effects determining humanity’s future

Trond Arne UndheimEuropean 2024 · DOI

In an era defined by "polycrises"—where climate change, AI-driven disruption, and economic instability collide—modeling global chaos has become a matter of existential importance. A recent study by Trond Arne Undheim, published in the European Journal of Futures Research, argues that our current approach to systemic risk often overlooks the fundamental building blocks of catastrophe. To understand how humanity’s future might collapse or be saved, we must first master the "dyads": the fundamental, two-way interactions between disruptive forces.

The Problem: Systems Theory Without Mechanics

Current risk literature frequently jumps directly to "cascading risks" or "existential risks" (x-risks) using a broad systems-theory lens. While valuable for high-level overviews, this approach often skips the granular mechanics of how these cascades actually begin.

A significant barrier to progress is the lack of a precise, cross-disciplinary vocabulary. While "NaTech" (Natural disasters triggering Technological accidents) is a well-established term, there are no equivalent shorthands for how governance failures impact biodiversity (GovNat) or how AI might spark the next pandemic (TechHealth). Without a standardized nomenclature, it remains difficult for policymakers and researchers across disparate fields to communicate effectively or build accurate predictive models.

Methodology: Distilling Millions of Data Points

The author employed a systematic literature review following a modified PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) process to ground the new nomenclature in existing evidence.

  1. Framework Design: Six core disruptive forces were identified: Science and Technology (Sci-tech), Governance, Economics, Social Dynamics, Ecological Impact, and Health Adversity.
  2. Matrix Construction: Crossing these six forces generated a 6x6 matrix of 36 potential dyadic interactions.
  3. Literature Search: An initial search of Google Scholar and Web of Science yielded over 8 million hits. This was narrowed through strict exclusion criteria to identify specific case studies and theoretical support for each of the 36 dyads.
  4. Nomenclature Development: The "NaTech" naming convention was generalized across the entire matrix (e.g., EconSoc for economic impacts on social dynamics).
The PRISMA review process used to filter millions of search results into the final dyadic framework.

The final qualitative synthesis relied on 45 high-impact, peer-reviewed articles spanning Science, Engineering, Social Science, and Management journals, with an average impact factor of 9.1.

The 36-Dyad Framework

The primary contribution of the research is the Nomenclature Matrix. It provides a definition and a historical data point for every possible interaction between the six identified forces.

The 36 basic dyadic risk mechanisms mapped across the six disruptive forces.

Key Insights

  • Simplicity as a Prerequisite for Complexity: The author posits that one cannot truly understand a "tetradic" (four-way) risk cascade without first understanding the dyadic relationships that compose it. Dyads are the "proto-cascading" effects.
  • Co-Causality and Feedback Loops: In many instances, the direction of risk is reciprocal. For example, does technology disrupt governance (TechGov), or does governance failure create technological risk (GovTech)? The study identifies 22 "co-causal" dyads where the interaction is essentially a feedback loop.
  • The "Big Six": Six mechanisms are highlighted as particularly dire: $T^2$ (tech-on-tech), NaEcon (nature-on-economy), GovNat (governance-on-nature), $G^2$ (intra-government rivalry), NaHealth (nature-on-health), and TechGov (tech-on-governance).

Limitations and Future Directions

While the 36-dyad framework provides a manageable starting point, the complexity of global risk grows exponentially. Triadic relationships (three-way) would result in 216 combinations ($6^3$). The author suggests that moving beyond dyads will eventually require AI-assisted factor analysis and potentially quantum computing to model higher-order cascades.

Furthermore, while the paper provides a nomenclature, establishing definitive causality remains a challenge. Future research must move from identifying correlations to proving the causal links within these dyads to better inform global risk management strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Re-reading the risk literature, I sketch a novel nomenclature for 36 dyadic risk interactions that constitute the prototypes of what eventually become cascading effects. This analysis demonstrates where cascading risk effects originate and also hints at how they get their enormous power. Risk dyads derive from basic first-order interactions across six disruptive forces: sci-tech, governance, economics, social dynamics, ecological impact, and health adversity. I give brief examples of each and provide a short case description of six of the most prominent dyads. Very few of these dyads have an existing shorthand. The exception is NaTech, which denotes natural disasters being amplified by, or amplifying industrial risk, or now more broadly, sci-tech-derived risk. By generalizing the NaTech-style nomenclature across domains, I aim to provide the basic building blocks for a precise understanding of contemporary risk mechanics. This step is often skipped by avid complexity scholars intent on first describing system-wide features. Yet, dyadic analysis is an important prerequisite for systemic understanding of complex cascading effects that depend on triadic or tetradic risk relationships. In reality, even if systemic, and existential risks, as they emerge in the twenty-first century, depend on a myriad of cascading effects, they cannot be fully understood simply by looking at the whole system and attempting to analytically ignore its constituent parts claiming to gain a better overview.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{undheim2024dyadic,
  author = {Trond Arne Undheim},
  title = {{Dyadic risk mechanisms–a nomenclature for 36 proto-cascading effects determining humanity’s future}},
  booktitle = {European},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1186/s40309-024-00228-2},
}
Figure