Quantitative measure of hysteresis for memristors through explicit dynamics

Panayiotis S. Georgiou, Sophia N. Yaliraki, E.m. Drakakis, Mauricio Barahona

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel mathematical framework to analytically describe the behavior of memristors, specifically focusing on their characteristic hysteresis. By leveraging the Bernoulli differential equation, the authors derive explicit solutions for memristor dynamics, enabling a quantitative measure of hysteresis and the identification of a key lumped parameter that governs this behavior.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, memristors have been a theoretical concept, defined as a fourth fundamental circuit element alongside resistors, capacitors, and inductors, exhibiting a resistance that depends on its past history. While experimental devices resembling memristors have been fabricated, a general analytical framework to understand and predict their behavior, particularly their hysteresis, has been lacking. Previous analyses often relied on computationally intensive numerical simulations. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a systematic mathematical approach to derive analytical solutions for memristor dynamics and hysteresis, facilitating their design and analysis.

Methods

The core of the paper's methodology lies in recognizing that the dynamics of many memristor models, when expressed in terms of specific variables, adhere to a Bernoulli differential equation. This equation is known to be reducible to a linear differential equation through a nonlinear transformation. The authors exploit this property to derive general analytical solutions for memristor input-output characteristics. They then apply this framework to the Hewlett-Packard (HP) memristor model, deriving explicit expressions for its current-voltage (i-v) characteristics under various input waveforms (sinusoidal, bipolar piecewise linear, and triangular). A key outcome of this analysis is the identification of a dimensionless lumped parameter, denoted by $\beta$, which encapsulates device-specific properties and input drive characteristics, and governs the memristive behavior and hysteresis. Finally, they define and derive a quantitative measure of hysteresis based on the work done by the driving signal, expressed in terms of this lumped parameter.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical modeling and analytical derivation rather than experimental data analysis or the introduction of new datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bernoulli Equation as a Unifying Framework: The paper demonstrates that a broad class of memristor dynamics can be elegantly described by the Bernoulli differential equation, offering a powerful analytical tool.
  • Analytical Solutions for Memristor Dynamics: By transforming the Bernoulli equation into a linear one, the authors achieve explicit, analytical solutions for memristor i-v characteristics, bypassing the need for numerical simulations.
  • The Lumped Parameter $\beta$: The introduction of $\beta$ is a crucial insight. This single dimensionless parameter elegantly combines material properties, fabrication details, and input signal characteristics, providing a unified way to understand and predict memristor behavior.
  • Quantitative Measure of Hysteresis: The paper moves beyond qualitative descriptions of hysteresis by defining a formal, quantitative measure based on the energy dissipated by the device, directly linked to the lumped parameter $\beta$.
  • Design Implications: The analytical framework and the parameter $\beta$ offer practical guidance for designing memristors with specific hysteretic responses and for characterizing fabricated devices.

Key Results

  • The paper provides a general mathematical framework for analyzing memristor dynamics using the Bernoulli differential equation, leading to analytical solutions.
  • Explicit analytical solutions for the i-v characteristics of the HP memristor model are derived for sinusoidal, bipolar piecewise linear, and triangular voltage inputs.
  • A dimensionless lumped parameter $\beta$ is identified, which governs the memristive behavior and the amount of hysteresis.
  • A quantitative measure of hysteresis is defined and derived as an explicit function of $\beta$ for the HP memristor under the studied input drives.
  • The analysis shows that hysteresis is zero when $\beta=0$ (linear resistor behavior) and increases as $\beta$ approaches its upper bound, with a finite maximum hysteresis achievable. For instance, for a sinusoidal input, the maximum hysteresis is approximately 0.4972.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplification: The authors acknowledge that the HP memristor model used is a simplified one. Limitations such as the absence of saturation or breakdown mechanisms in the model are noted, suggesting that more realistic models incorporating windowing functions would be a direction for future research.
  • Generalizability: While the framework is presented as general, its application to other memristor models and networks is mentioned as an area for further investigation.
  • Non-linear Dopant Kinetics: The paper suggests that future work could involve investigating more realistic memristor models that account for non-linear dopant kinetics.
  • Experimental Validation: Although the paper discusses design and characterization, direct experimental validation of the derived analytical expressions and the parameter $\beta$ across a wide range of devices and conditions would strengthen the findings.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We introduce a mathematical framework for the analysis of the input–output dynamics of externally driven memristors. We show that, under general assumptions, their dynamics comply with a Bernoulli differential equation and hence can be nonlinearly transformed into a formally solvable linear equation. The Bernoulli formalism, which applies to both charge- and flux-controlled memristors when either current or voltage driven, can, in some cases, lead to expressions of the output of the device as an explicit function of the input. We apply our framework to obtain analytical solutions of the i–v characteristics of the recently proposed model of the Hewlett–Packard memristor under three different drives without the need for numerical simulations. Our explicit solutions allow us to identify a dimensionless lumped parameter that combines device-specific parameters with properties of the input drive. This parameter governs the memristive behaviour of the device and, consequently, the amount of hysteresis in the i–v. We proceed further by defining formally a quantitative measure for the hysteresis of the device, for which we obtain explicit formulas in terms of the aforementioned parameter, and we discuss the applicability of the analysis for the design and analysis of memristor devices.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{georgiou2012quantitative,
  author = {Panayiotis S. Georgiou and Sophia N. Yaliraki and E.M. Drakakis and Mauricio Barahona},
  title = {{Quantitative measure of hysteresis for memristors through explicit dynamics}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1098/rspa.2011.0585},
}
Figure