Quantitative Long-Term Monitoring of the Circulating Gases in the KATRIN Experiment Using Raman Spectroscopy
Max Aker, Konrad Altenmüller, Armen Beglarian, Jan Behrens, Anatoly Berlev, Uwe Besserer, Benedikt Bieringer, Klaus Blaum, Fabian Block, Beate Bornschein, Lutz Bornschein, Matthias Böttcher, Tim Brunst, Thomas C. Caldwell, Suren Chilingaryan, Wonqook Choi, Deseada D. Díaz Barrero, Karol Debowski, Marco Deffert, Martin Descher, Peter J. Doe, Otokar Dragoun, Guido Drexlin, Stephan Dyba, Frank Edzards, Klaus Eitel, Enrico Ellinger, Ralph Engel, Sanshiro Enomoto, Mariia Fedkevych, Arne Felden, Joseph F. Formaggio, Florian Fränkle, Gregg B. Franklin, Fabian Friedel, Alexander Fulst, Kevin Gauda, Woosik Gil, Ferenc Glück, Robin Größle, Rainer Gumbsheimer, Volker Hannen, Norman Haußmann, Klaus Helbing, Stephanie Hickford, Roman Hiller, David Hillesheimer, Dominic Hinz, Thomas Höhn, Thibaut Houdy, Anton Huber, Alexander Jansen, Christian Karl, Jonas Kellerer, Luke Kippenbrock, Manuel Klein, Christoph Köhler, Leonard Köllenberger, Andreas Kopmann, Marc Korzeczek, Alojz Kovalík, Bennet Krasch, Holger Krause, Luisa La Cascio, Thierry Lasserre, Thanh-Long Le, Ondrej Lebeda, Bjoern Lehnert, Alexey Lokhov, Moritz Machatschek, Emma Malcherek, Alexander Marsteller, Eric L. Martin, Matthias Meier, Christin Melzer, Susanne Mertens, Klaus Müller, Simon Niemes, Patrick Oelpmann, Alexander Osipowicz, Diana S. Parno, Alan W. P. Poon, Jose M. Lopez Poyato, Florian Priester, Oliver Rest, Marco Röllig, Carsten Röttele, R. G. Hamish Robertson, Caroline Rodenbeck, Milos Rysavy, Rudolf Sack, Alejandro Saenz, Peter Schäfer, Anna Schaller née Pollithy, Lutz Schimpf, Klaus Schlösser, Magnus Schlösser, Lisa Schlüter, Michael Schrank, Bruno Schulz, Michal Sefcík, Hendrik Seitz-Moskaliuk, Valérian Sibille, Daniel Siegmann, Martin Slezák, Felix Spanier, Markus Steidl, Michael Sturm, Menglei Sun, Helmut H. Telle, Larisa A. Thorne, Thomas Thümmler, Nikita Titov, Igor Tkachev, Drahos Vénos, Kathrin Valerius, Ana P. Vizcaya Hernández, Marc Weber, Christian Weinheimer, Christiane Weiss, Stefan Welte, Jürgen Wendel, John F. Wilkerson, Joachim Wolf, Sascha Wüstling, Weiran Xu, Yung-Ruey Yen, Sergey Zadoroghny, Genrich Zeller
The KATRIN experiment, aiming to measure the electron neutrino mass, relies on precise monitoring of its tritium gas composition. This paper details the successful implementation and performance of a laser Raman spectroscopy system (LARA) that provides continuous, high-precision measurements of these gases, meeting and exceeding KATRIN's stringent requirements.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The KATRIN experiment's primary goal is to determine the effective electron neutrino mass with unprecedented sensitivity. A critical aspect of this experiment is the precise knowledge of the gas composition within its windowless gaseous tritium source (WGTS). The gas is not pure tritium but a mixture of hydrogen isotopologues (T₂, DT, HT, etc.). Variations in the concentration of these isotopologues, particularly tritium-substituted ones, can significantly impact the measured electron energy spectrum and thus introduce systematic errors in the neutrino mass determination. Therefore, a reliable, in-line method for continuously monitoring these gas compositions with high accuracy is essential.
Methods
The core of the monitoring system is laser Raman spectroscopy (LARA). This technique uses a laser to excite molecules in the gas, causing them to scatter light at specific wavelengths (Raman shifts) that are characteristic of their molecular identity. The intensity of these scattered signals is proportional to the concentration of the respective molecules.
Key aspects of the LARA system and its application include:
Laser Excitation: A 532 nm DPSS Nd:YVO₄ laser is used for excitation.
Double-Pass Configuration: To maximize the Raman signal, the laser beam is reflected back through the gas cell, effectively doubling the excitation intensity.
High-Resolution Spectrometer: A spectrometer with a CCD detector is used to resolve the spectral signatures of the six hydrogen isotopologues.
Calibration: Rigorous calibration procedures are employed, including:
Wavelength Calibration: Using atomic emission line sources.
Intensity Calibration: Using a fluorescence standard (NIST SRM2242) placed at the Raman excitation location to account for the entire optical detection system's response.
Quantitative Linking: Developing methods to relate measured Raman signals to particle densities, utilizing theoretical calculations of Raman transition probabilities and experimental measurements.
Spectral Deconvolution: Advanced techniques are used to separate overlapping spectral features from different isotopologues, particularly the S₁(J″=2) line of T₂ and the Q₁(J″) branch of DT.
Automated Data Processing: A bespoke LabVIEW software suite (LARAsoft) handles data acquisition, processing, and real-time analysis, transferring results to the KATRIN database.
Datasets
The paper presents data from three distinct measurement campaigns:
LOOPINO: Loop test measurements without the WGTS and permeator, using an initially "pure" high-T₂ gas mixture. This dataset helps understand chemical processes in a closed loop.
FT (First Tritium): Data from the initial KATRIN operation with tritium, characterized by a low tritium content (<1%).
KNM1 (KATRIN Neutrino Mass): Data from the first full KATRIN neutrino mass run, with high-T₂ content (>95%). This represents the operational scenario for neutrino mass measurements.
The data consists of Raman spectra recorded over various durations, allowing for the analysis of temporal evolution of gas composition and system stability.
Key Insights and Ideas
Raman Spectroscopy as a Robust Tool: The study demonstrates that Raman spectroscopy is a highly effective and reliable method for real-time, quantitative monitoring of complex gas mixtures in a challenging experimental environment like KATRIN.
Importance of Gas Purity: The paper underscores the critical need for precise knowledge of gas composition, especially tritium purity (ɛт), for accurate neutrino mass measurements. Even small deviations can introduce significant systematic errors.
Chemical Reactions in the Loop: The measurements revealed insights into various chemical and radio-chemical reactions occurring within the loop, such as the generation of HT and methane from interactions with steel walls and tritium decay. Understanding these processes is crucial for interpreting the data.
Exceeding Requirements: The LARA system not only met but often surpassed the stringent precision and trueness requirements set by KATRIN for monitoring gas composition.
Temporal Dynamics: The data provided valuable information on the temporal evolution of gas concentrations, revealing characteristic time constants and the system's response to changes in operating conditions.
Key Results
High Precision and Trueness: The LARA system achieved precision for tritium purity (ɛт) of approximately 2.8 × 10⁻⁴ and trueness of 1.6 × 10⁻³, significantly better than the KATRIN requirements of 1 × 10⁻³ and 3 × 10⁻², respectively.
Isotopologue Concentration Monitoring: Concentrations of individual isotopologues (T₂, DT, HT) were monitored with high precision, with achieved values for DT and HT being well within KATRIN's requirements.
Successful Deconvolution: The spectral deconvolution techniques effectively separated overlapping spectral features, enabling accurate determination of DT concentrations.
Stability: The system demonstrated good stability over long-term operation, with statistical uncertainties remaining within limits even during disruptive events like gas batch changes.
Limitations and Future Work
Theoretical Modeling: The authors note that while the observed reaction-dynamic phenomena are not surprising, they "still lack full theoretical modeling." Developing a comprehensive model that incorporates all system segments is an ongoing effort.
Methane Identification: The spectral identification of tritiated methanes was challenging due to their low concentration. Further spectroscopy experiments with pure CT₄ are planned to clarify potential discrepancies and improve understanding.
Broader Applications: The KATRIN LARA system's capabilities suggest its potential as an analytical tool for other circulating gas mixture applications, including rapid process control, with a demonstrated detection limit of approximately 0.18 mbar for a single spectrum.
Summary updated
Abstract
The Karlsruhe Tritium Neutrino (KATRIN) experiment aims at measuring the effective electron neutrino mass with a sensitivity of 0.2 eV/c2, i.e., improving on previous measurements by an order of magnitude. Neutrino mass data taking with KATRIN commenced in early 2019, and after only a few weeks of data recording, analysis of these data showed the success of KATRIN, improving on the known neutrino mass limit by a factor of about two. This success very much could be ascribed to the fact that most of the system components met, or even surpassed, the required specifications during long-term operation. Here, we report on the performance of the laser Raman (LARA) monitoring system which provides continuous high-precision information on the gas composition injected into the experiment’s windowless gaseous tritium source (WGTS), specifically on its isotopic purity of tritium—one of the key parameters required in the derivation of the electron neutrino mass. The concentrations cx for all six hydrogen isotopologues were monitored simultaneously, with a measurement precision for individual components of the order 10−3 or better throughout the complete KATRIN data taking campaigns to date. From these, the tritium purity, εT, is derived with precision of <10−3 and trueness of <3 × 10−3, being within and surpassing the actual requirements for KATRIN, respectively.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{aker2020quantitative,
author = {Max Aker and Konrad Altenmüller and Armen Beglarian and Jan Behrens and Anatoly Berlev and Uwe Besserer and Benedikt Bieringer and Klaus Blaum and Fabian Block and Beate Bornschein and Lutz Bornschein and Matthias Böttcher and Tim Brunst and Thomas C. Caldwell and Suren Chilingaryan and Wonqook Choi and Deseada D. Díaz Barrero and Karol Debowski and Marco Deffert and Martin Descher and Peter J. Doe and Otokar Dragoun and Guido Drexlin and Stephan Dyba and Frank Edzards and Klaus Eitel and Enrico Ellinger and Ralph Engel and Sanshiro Enomoto and Mariia Fedkevych and Arne Felden and Joseph F. Formaggio and Florian Fränkle and Gregg B. Franklin and Fabian Friedel and Alexander Fulst and Kevin Gauda and Woosik Gil and Ferenc Glück and Robin Größle and Rainer Gumbsheimer and Volker Hannen and Norman Haußmann and Klaus Helbing and Stephanie Hickford and Roman Hiller and David Hillesheimer and Dominic Hinz and Thomas Höhn and Thibaut Houdy and Anton Huber and Alexander Jansen and Christian Karl and Jonas Kellerer and Luke Kippenbrock and Manuel Klein and Christoph Köhler and Leonard Köllenberger and Andreas Kopmann and Marc Korzeczek and Alojz Kovalík and Bennet Krasch and Holger Krause and Luisa La Cascio and Thierry Lasserre and Thanh-Long Le and Ondrej Lebeda and Bjoern Lehnert and Alexey Lokhov and Moritz Machatschek and Emma Malcherek and Alexander Marsteller and Eric L. Martin and Matthias Meier and Christin Melzer and Susanne Mertens and Klaus Müller and Simon Niemes and Patrick Oelpmann and Alexander Osipowicz and Diana S. Parno and Alan W. P. Poon and Jose M. Lopez Poyato and Florian Priester and Oliver Rest and Marco Röllig and Carsten Röttele and R. G. Hamish Robertson and Caroline Rodenbeck and Milos Rysavy and Rudolf Sack and Alejandro Saenz and Peter Schäfer and Anna Schaller née Pollithy and Lutz Schimpf and Klaus Schlösser and Magnus Schlösser and Lisa Schlüter and Michael Schrank and Bruno Schulz and Michal Sefcík and Hendrik Seitz-Moskaliuk and Valérian Sibille and Daniel Siegmann and Martin Slezák and Felix Spanier and Markus Steidl and Michael Sturm and Menglei Sun and Helmut H. Telle and Larisa A. Thorne and Thomas Thümmler and Nikita Titov and Igor Tkachev and Drahos Vénos and Kathrin Valerius and Ana P. Vizcaya Hernández and Marc Weber and Christian Weinheimer and Christiane Weiss and Stefan Welte and Jürgen Wendel and John F. Wilkerson and Joachim Wolf and Sascha Wüstling and Weiran Xu and Yung-Ruey Yen and Sergey Zadoroghny and Genrich Zeller},
title = {{Quantitative Long-Term Monitoring of the Circulating Gases in the KATRIN Experiment Using Raman Spectroscopy}},
booktitle = {Sensors},
year = {2020},
url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=qOZmidvwZp},
}