Quantitative and Kinetic Proteomics Reveal ApoE Isoform-dependent Proteostasis Adaptations in Mouse Brain

Nathan R. Zuniga, Noah E. Earls, Ariel E. A. Denos, Jared M. Elison, Benjamin S. Jones, Ethan G. Smith, Noah G. Moran, Katie L. Broce, Gerome M. Romero, Chad D. Hyer, Kimberly B. Wagstaff, Haifa M. Almughamsi, Mark K. Transtrum, John C. Price

Introduction

Proteostasis—the delicate balance of protein synthesis, folding, and degradation—serves as the cell's primary defense against aging and neurodegeneration. While the ApoE4 allele is well-established as a significant genetic risk factor for Alzheimer’s Disease (AD), and ApoE2 is known to be protective, the underlying mechanical pathways remain elusive.

Traditional proteomics often focuses on abundance, providing a static snapshot of the proteome. However, abundance alone cannot distinguish between a stable, long-lived protein and one undergoing rapid turnover. This study addresses this gap by utilizing kinetic proteomics to map the "flux" of the proteome, revealing how ApoE variants alter the maintenance of critical cellular machinery like mitochondria and lysosomes.

Experimental Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated in vivo labeling approach to capture protein dynamics in transgenic mice expressing human ApoE2, E3, or E4 isoforms.

Experimental workflow for in vivo kinetic proteomics, including heavy water labeling and LC-MS/MS analysis.
  • Heavy Water Labeling: Mice were provided with $D_2O$ (heavy water) in their drinking water for up to 32 days. Newly synthesized proteins incorporated deuterium, creating a detectable "time stamp."
  • LC-MS/MS: Liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry identified and quantified thousands of proteins from brain and liver tissues.
  • Kinetic Modeling: The team calculated the Turnover Rate Fold Change (ΔTurnover) and Abundance Fold Change (ΔAbundance) to categorize proteomic shifts into specific quadrants of synthesis and degradation.

Mapping the Proteostasis Landscape

A key innovation of this study is the use of 2D "Proteostasis Plots." By plotting ΔAbundance against ΔTurnover, researchers can visualize whether changes in protein levels are driven by altered production or altered clearance.

Proteostasis plot showing the relationship between ΔAbundance and ΔRate for ApoE4 vs ApoE3 functional ontologies.

Key Insights

  • Coordinated vs. Piecemeal Maintenance: In the protective ApoE2 brain, mitochondrial matrix and membrane proteins showed synchronized degradation, suggesting efficient "mitophagy" (wholesale organelle recycling). Conversely, ApoE4 brains exhibited "discordant" changes—membranes were degraded while the matrix was not—indicating a breakdown in quality control.
  • Metabolic Shifts: Due to inefficient mitochondrial maintenance, ApoE4 brains appear to shift toward carbohydrate metabolism (glycolysis) to compensate for failing oxidative phosphorylation.
  • Proteasome Paralysis: ApoE4 was linked to reduced synthesis of proteasome components and Hsp70 chaperones, weakening the cell's ability to clear toxic, misfolded proteins.
  • Tissue Specificity: These adaptations were largely absent in the liver, suggesting that the AD-related effects of ApoE are specifically amplified by the brain's unique cellular environment.

Results and Implications

The study quantified 3,532 abundance changes and approximately 1,400 turnover rate changes, providing a high-resolution map of isoform-dependent proteostasis. The findings suggest that ApoE2 confers an advantage through "streamlined" regulation of endolysosomal events, potentially preventing the accumulation of toxic aggregates. In contrast, the ApoE4 variant leads to inefficient mitochondrial maintenance and stalled endosomal maturation.

Limitations and Future Directions

While this study provides a comprehensive map of the consequences of ApoE isoforms, several questions remain. The use of bulk brain tissue may mask cell-type-specific differences (e.g., neurons vs. astrocytes). Additionally, while the study maps the consequences of these isoforms, the initial molecular trigger that initiates proteostasis failure in ApoE4 carriers remains a target for future investigation. Future work utilizing single-cell kinetic proteomics may provide the granularity needed to pinpoint these early events.

Summary updated

Abstract

Apolipoprotein E (ApoE) polymorphisms modify the risk of neurodegenerative disease with the ApoE4 isoform increasing and ApoE2 isoform decreasing risk relative to the 'wild-type control' ApoE3 isoform. To elucidate how ApoE isoforms alter the proteome, we measured relative protein abundance and turnover in transgenic mice expressing a human ApoE gene (isoform 2, 3, or 4). This data provides insight into how ApoE isoforms affect the <i>in vivo</i> synthesis and degradation of a wide variety of proteins. We identified 4849 proteins and tested for ApoE isoform-dependent changes in the homeostatic regulation of ~2700 ontologies. In the brain, we found that ApoE4 and ApoE2 both lead to modified regulation of mitochondrial membrane proteins relative to the wild-type control ApoE3. In ApoE4 mice, this regulation is not cohesive suggesting that aerobic respiration is impacted by proteasomal and autophagic dysregulation. ApoE2 mice exhibited a matching change in mitochondrial matrix proteins and the membrane which suggests coordinated maintenance of the entire organelle. In the liver, we did not observe these changes suggesting that the ApoE-effect on proteostasis is amplified in the brain relative to other tissues. Our findings underscore the utility of combining protein abundance and turnover rates to decipher proteome regulatory mechanisms and their potential role in biology.
BibTeX
@article{zuniga2024quantitative,
  author = {Nathan R. Zuniga and Noah E. Earls and Ariel E. A. Denos and Jared M. Elison and Benjamin S. Jones and Ethan G. Smith and Noah G. Moran and Katie L. Broce and Gerome M. Romero and Chad D. Hyer and Kimberly B. Wagstaff and Haifa M. Almughamsi and Mark K. Transtrum and John C. Price},
  title = {{Quantitative and Kinetic Proteomics Reveal ApoE Isoform-dependent Proteostasis Adaptations in Mouse Brain}},
  journal = {PLOS Computational Biology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pcbi.1012407},
}
Figure