Quantify Resilience Enhancement of UTS through Exploiting Connected Community and Internet of Everything Emerging Technologies

Emanuele Bellini, Paolo Ceravolo, Paolo Nesi

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method to quantify the resilience of Urban Transport Systems (UTS) by leveraging the Internet of Everything (IoE) and Connected Communities (CC). By extending the Functional Resonance Analysis Method (FRAM) and introducing a "Variability Rate" (VR) metric, the authors demonstrate how these emerging technologies can significantly enhance a UTS's ability to absorb and dampen disruptions, leading to improved resilience.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Current approaches to managing the safety and security of complex socio-technical systems, like Urban Transport Systems (UTS), often struggle with "unknown unknowns" and the increasing complexity and unpredictability of modern environments. Traditional methods are limited in their ability to account for the vast number of human, social, organizational, and technical factors that interact dynamically. This paper addresses the challenge of quantifying how emerging technologies, specifically the Internet of Everything (IoE) and Connected Communities (CC), can enhance the resilience of UTS by improving their capacity to manage variability and adapt to unexpected events. The authors highlight the need for a scientific method to precisely predict the long-term evolution and impact of critical events on infrastructure, which current approaches lack.

Methods

The core of the paper's methodology lies in extending the Functional Resonance Analysis Method (FRAM). FRAM is a system modeling tool that focuses on interdependencies and emergent behaviors. The authors propose:

  • Conceptual Extension of FRAM: Adapting FRAM to model UTS complexity, with a specific focus on human and community-related functions.
  • Network Science Approach: Applying network analysis techniques to the FRAM model to identify critical community-related functions.
  • Variability Rate (VR) Definition: Introducing a new metric, Variability Rate (VR), defined as the amount of output variability from an upstream function that a downstream function can tolerate or absorb without significantly increasing its own output variability.
  • Fuzzy Logic for Quantification: Developing a fuzzy-based quantification of VR, particularly useful when quantitative data is unavailable, relying on expert judgment. This involves using fuzzy sets to represent linguistic variables and a fuzzy majority notion to derive representative values from expert opinions.
  • Quantitative Analysis of Dependencies: Employing graph metrics, specifically Degree Prestige (DP), to analyze the centrality and importance of functions within the FRAM model.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The authors mention using data derived from the 1st RESOLUTE stakeholder workshops held in Florence in December 2015, which analyzed various scenarios including flash flooding. This data was used for expert judgment collection to quantify VR.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • IoE and CC as Resilience Enablers: The paper strongly suggests that IoE and CC are not just technological advancements but crucial enablers for enhancing UTS resilience by improving the human and social aspects of system management.
  • Variability Rate (VR) as a Key Metric: The VR metric provides a novel and quantifiable way to assess how well a system can absorb disruptions, moving beyond qualitative assessments of resilience.
  • Criticality of Human/Community Functions: The network analysis reveals that functions related to community behavior and awareness (e.g., F16: Manage awareness and user behavior) are among the most critical for UTS resilience.
  • Fuzzy Logic for Subjective Data: The integration of fuzzy logic is a practical approach to incorporate expert judgment and subjective observations into quantitative resilience analysis, bridging the gap where hard data is scarce.
  • Benefits of IoE/CC are Multi-fold: The study indicates that the benefits of introducing IoE and CC can be substantial, potentially yielding 6 to 8 times the VR increment compared to standard scenarios.

Key Results

The study applied the developed methodology to a flash flooding scenario in Florence. The key results include:

  • Significant VR Enhancement: In the case study, the VR for relationships involving community-related functions was significantly higher when IoE and CC were deployed compared to a standard scenario. For example, for the relationship F13:User Behavior:F14:input, the VR increased from 11.5% in the standard scenario to 80% in the CC scenario.
  • Identification of Critical Functions: Network analysis using Degree Prestige identified functions like F2 (Coordinate service delivery), F16 (Manage awareness and user behavior), and F1 (Delivery service) as highly critical.
  • Quantified Impact of IoE/CC: The analysis demonstrated that the introduction of IoE and CC technologies leads to a substantial increase in the variability dampening capacity of UTS functions, preventing or mitigating the propagation of variability and thus reducing the risk of functional resonance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Reliance on Expert Judgment: While fuzzy logic helps, the quantification of VR still relies on expert judgment, which can introduce subjectivity. The paper acknowledges that the "margin of regular operation" significantly influences VR results.
  • Formalization of FDC: The paper notes that the precise contribution of function buffer capacities (FBC), flexibility (FF), margin (FM), and tolerance (FT) to the Function Dampening Capacity (FDC) requires further analysis.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest several future research directions:
  • Investigating alternative formalizations of FDC.
  • Quantifying the effects of mechanisms to simulate variability propagation.
  • Developing a decision support system to predict and recommend optimal resource allocation and technology upgrades for critical interdependencies.
  • Exploring alternative methods for quantitative analysis of FRAM.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{bellini2017quantify,
  author = {Emanuele Bellini and Paolo Ceravolo and Paolo Nesi},
  title = {{Quantify Resilience Enhancement of UTS through Exploiting Connected Community and Internet of Everything Emerging Technologies}},
  journal = {ACM Trans. Internet Techn},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1145/3137572},
}
Figure