Quadruped Capturability and Push Recovery via a Switched-Systems Characterization of Dynamic Balance

Hua Chen, Zejun Hong, Shunpeng Yang, Patrick M. Wensing, Wei Zhang

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new framework for quadruped robots to recover from pushes by characterizing "dynamic balance" and using this to plan footstep adjustments. This approach significantly improves disturbance rejection compared to existing methods, allowing robots to handle larger impacts and adapt to different gaits and push timings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Quadruped robots are excellent for navigating challenging terrain, but they are also prone to falling when pushed. Existing methods for push recovery, largely developed for bipeds, often rely on achieving static or quasi-static balance, which is too restrictive for dynamic quadrupedal locomotion. Quadrupedal robots have unique features like multiple swinging legs and point contacts, and their balance is inherently time-varying due to their gaits. This paper addresses the challenge of developing robust push recovery strategies that account for these quadruped-specific dynamics, the time-varying nature of balance, and the influence of gait and impact timing.

Methods

The authors propose a novel approach based on switched systems modeling to capture the dynamics of quadruped locomotion. They extend the concept of capturability by introducing dynamic balance, which allows for controlled movement during recovery rather than requiring an immediate stop. This dynamic balance is formalized as a tube of dynamically balanced states.

To analyze this, they employ Explicit Model Predictive Control (EMPC) to compute these "balanced" and "capturable" tubes. This offline analysis provides a detailed understanding of how gait patterns and disturbance timings affect the robot's ability to recover. Based on this, they develop an online CoM and footstep planning scheme. This scheme iteratively plans the robot's center of mass (CoM) trajectory and footstep locations to ensure the robot lands in a capturable state, using quadratic programming for efficient real-time execution.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The authors use simulations and hardware experiments on a Mini Cheetah robot.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dynamic Balance is Crucial: Static balance is insufficient for dynamic quadrupedal locomotion. The paper formalizes "dynamic balance" as a controlled evolution of the robot's state within a time-varying tube, allowing for more flexible recovery.
  • Gait and Timing Matter: The ability to recover from a push is highly dependent on the robot's current gait and the timing of the impact. The proposed framework explicitly accounts for these factors, leading to more robust performance.
  • Capturability as a Tube: Instead of a single point, capturability is characterized by a "tube" of states that can lead to dynamic balance, providing a richer understanding of recovery capabilities.
  • EMPC for Analysis: EMPC is used effectively to analyze the complex dynamics and derive the necessary sets for capturability analysis, providing valuable offline insights.
  • Online Planning for Real-time Recovery: The framework translates offline analysis into an efficient online planning strategy that adjusts footstep placement and CoM trajectories to achieve recovery.

Key Results

  • Significant Improvement: The proposed approach demonstrates an improvement of up to 100% in rejecting external pushes compared to state-of-the-art methods (specifically, a convex MPC and whole-body impulse control approach).
  • Enhanced Disturbance Rejection: Simulations show the proposed method can reject impacts up to twice as large as the baseline, and in some directions, up to three times larger.
  • Hardware Validation: Experiments on a Mini Cheetah robot confirm the effectiveness of the proposed strategy, showing improved performance and robustness.
  • Gait and Timing Influence: The results clearly illustrate how different gaits and impact timings affect the robot's recovery capabilities, a factor often overlooked in previous methods.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulation vs. Hardware Discrepancy: While simulations show high disturbance rejection, hardware experiments exhibit a larger fluctuation in balance due to factors like state estimation noise and unmodeled dynamics.
  • State Estimation: The performance in hardware is sensitive to the accuracy of the state estimator. Better-tuned parameters or more advanced estimators could further improve performance.
  • Self-Collision and Trajectory Tracking: Issues like self-collision and imperfect swing leg trajectory tracking can lead to recovery failures in hardware, which are not modeled in simulations.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest investigating gait adjustment strategies in reaction to disturbances as a future research direction. They also highlight the need for better state estimation and addressing hardware-specific issues for practical deployment.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article studies capturability and push recovery for quadruped locomotion. Despite the rich literature on capturability analysis and push recovery for legged robots, existing tools have been developed mainly with the requirement of reaching static or quasi-static balance following a push. In practice, this requirement commonly restricts capturability analysis to cases with simple dynamics and fails to encode the time dependence of capturable states for legged locomotion with time-based gaits. To address these issues, we apply switched systems to model quadruped locomotion and extend capturability notions through a novel specification of <italic xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">dynamic balance</i> . We also provide an explicit model predictive control (EMPC) scheme to compute the dynamic balance and capturable tubes and offer a way of using the capturable tube to synthesize push recovery controllers. Such a generalization allows for a rigorous characterization of disturbance timing on the capturability of quadrupedal locomotion and opens the door of disturbance-timing-aware push recovery control strategies. Extensive simulation and hardware experiments illustrate the necessity of considering dynamic balance for quadrupedal push recovery, reveal how disturbance timing affects capturability, and demonstrate the significant improvement in disturbance rejection with the proposed strategy. Hardware experimental validations on a replica of the Mini Cheetah quadruped further verify that the proposed approach performs statistically better than the state-of-the-art baseline considered.
BibTeX
@article{chen2023quadruped,
  author = {Hua Chen and Zejun Hong and Shunpeng Yang and Patrick M. Wensing and Wei Zhang},
  title = {{Quadruped Capturability and Push Recovery via a Switched-Systems Characterization of Dynamic Balance}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Robotics},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1109/tro.2023.3240622},
}
Figure