Pulse shape discrimination technique for diffuse supernova neutrino background search with JUNO

Jie Cheng, Xiaojie Luo, Gao-Song Li, Yufeng Li, Z. Li, H. Q. Lu, Liangjian Wen, M. Wurm, Yiyu Zhang

This paper, recently published by the JUNO collaboration, details a significant leap forward in our ability to detect one of the most elusive signals in astrophysics: the "faint glow" of neutrinos left over from every supernova that has ever occurred in the history of the universe.

TL;DR

Researchers have developed advanced machine learning techniques (Boosted Decision Trees and Neural Networks) to distinguish rare supernova neutrino signals from overwhelming atmospheric background noise. By analyzing the precise timing of light pulses in the JUNO detector, they achieved a 50% to 80% improvement in signal efficiency over previous methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Diffuse Supernova Neutrino Background (DSNB) is a cumulative flux of neutrinos from all past core-collapse supernovae. Detecting it would provide a unique window into the history of star formation and neutrino physics. However, finding DSNB neutrinos is a classic "needle in a haystack" problem.

In the Jiangmen Underground Neutrino Observatory (JUNO), the expected DSNB signal is a mere 2–3 events per year. Meanwhile, neutral-current (NC) interactions from atmospheric neutrinos create a background of about 60 events per year that look almost identical to the signal. To find the DSNB, scientists must be able to tell the difference between a positron (the signal) and the cocktail of neutrons, protons, and alpha particles (the background) produced by these atmospheric neutrinos.

Methods

The authors employ Pulse Shape Discrimination (PSD). This technique relies on the fact that different particles excite liquid scintillators in different ways, leading to slightly different "shapes" in the resulting light pulses. Heavier, highly ionizing particles (like the protons in the background) produce a higher fraction of "slow" light compared to lighter particles (like the positrons in the signal).

The paper moves beyond traditional "cut-and-count" methods (which might just look at the ratio of the pulse tail to the total area) and implements two machine learning approaches:

  • Boosted Decision Trees (BDT): Uses nine specific physical variables, including pulse rising/falling times, decay constants, and the event's position in the detector.
  • Neural Networks (NN): A multi-layer perceptron that takes the raw, binned timing profile of the light hits as an input, allowing the model to "learn" the discriminating features itself.

Datasets

Since JUNO is currently nearing completion, the study uses high-fidelity Monte Carlo simulations:

  • Signal/Background Samples: 1 million signal events and 1 million background events were simulated for training and testing.
  • Software Framework: The JUNO offline software, which uses Geant4 for particle tracking and GENIE/TALYS for modeling complex neutrino-nucleus interactions.
  • Detector Effects: The simulation accounts for photon propagation, PMT dark noise, and Transit Time Spread (TTS).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The $^{11}$C Mimicry: The most significant insight is the role of $^{11}$C. When an atmospheric neutrino hits a Carbon-12 nucleus, it can produce $^{11}$C and a high-energy neutron. That neutron can then knock into other nuclei, creating gamma rays. These gamma rays look very "electron-like," making these specific background events much harder to reject than others.
  • Reconstruction as a Filter: Surprisingly, the process of waveform reconstruction—which usually introduces some blurriness—actually helps sharpen the peak of the timing distribution for the signal. This is because the electronics effectively "pick" the first photon in a pile-up, enhancing the timing difference between fast and slow signals.
  • Position Matters: The authors found that including the cubic radius ($R^3$) of the event position as an input variable was crucial. This helps the models account for "Time-of-Flight" biases that occur depending on where the light is produced relative to the PMTs.

Key Results

  • Efficiency Boost: Both BDT and NN methods achieved approximately 80% signal efficiency while maintaining a background leakage of only 1%. This represents a 50–80% improvement over the baseline established in previous JUNO studies.
  • Model Comparison: The BDT and NN performed comparably well, though the Neural Network showed a slight edge in performance at lower energies (below 20 MeV).
  • Robustness: The study quantified how much each detector effect degrades performance. While "perfect" truth-level information would give 100% efficiency, the introduction of dark noise and Time-of-Flight calculations drops this to the final ~80%—a realistic and still highly impressive benchmark.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation is that this study is entirely simulation-based. Real-world performance will depend on how well the liquid scintillator's properties match the "recipe" used in the simulation.

The authors suggest that once JUNO is operational (expected late 2024), they will need to validate these PSD models using "tagged" data—real background events that can be identified by other means (like the decay of $^{11}$C) to calibrate the machine learning models. Additionally, improving the resolution of the event's starting position (vertex reconstruction) will directly translate into even better PSD performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Pulse shape discrimination (PSD) is widely used in particle and nuclear physics. Specifically in liquid scintillator detectors, PSD facilitates the classification of different particle types based on their energy deposition patterns. This technique is particularly valuable for studies of the diffuse supernova neutrino background (DSNB), nucleon decay, and dark matter searches. This paper presents a detailed investigation of the PSD technique, applied in the DSNB search performed with the Jiangmen Underground Neutrino Observatory (JUNO). Instead of using conventional cut-and-count methods, we employ methods based on boosted decision trees and neural networks and compare their capability to distinguish the DSNB signals from the atmospheric neutrino neutral-current background events. The two methods demonstrate comparable performance, resulting in a 50–80% improvement in signal efficiency compared to a previous study performed for JUNO (An et al. [JUNO] in J Phys G 43(3):030401, 2016). Moreover, we study the dependence of the PSD performance on the visible energy and final state composition of the events and find a significant dependence on the presence/absence of $$^{11}$$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"> <mml:msup> <mml:mrow/> <mml:mn>11</mml:mn> </mml:msup> </mml:math> C. Finally, we evaluate the impact of the detector effects (photon propagation, PMT dark noise, and waveform reconstruction) on the PSD performance.
BibTeX
@article{cheng2024pulse,
  author = {Jie Cheng and Xiaojie Luo and Gao-Song Li and Yufeng Li and Z. Li and H. Q. Lu and Liangjian Wen and M. Wurm and Yiyu Zhang},
  title = {{Pulse shape discrimination technique for diffuse supernova neutrino background search with JUNO}},
  journal = {The European Physical Journal C},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1140/epjc/s10052-024-12779-6},
}

Loading related content...

Figure