PubChain: A Decentralized Open-Access Publication Platform with Participants Incentivized by Blockchain Technology

Taotao Wang, Soung Chang Liew, Shengli Zhang

TL;DR

This paper introduces PubChain, a decentralized open-access publication platform leveraging blockchain and IPFS to address the drawbacks of traditional publishing, such as paywalls and ineffective peer review. By incentivizing authors, reviewers, and readers with cryptocurrency rewards, PubChain aims to foster a more robust and equitable ecosystem for scientific knowledge dissemination.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The current academic publishing landscape is plagued by several significant issues. Firstly, the "paywall" model, where publishers charge both authors for publication and readers for access, hinders the free exchange of knowledge and prevents researchers from easily building upon prior work. Secondly, the peer review process, crucial for maintaining quality, often suffers from a lack of incentives for reviewers, leading to shallow or ineffective reviews. This is exacerbated by the sheer volume of research being published. Finally, centralized platforms, whether commercial publishers or even some open-access initiatives, represent single points of failure and can lead to "information islands" where resources are not easily shared. The authors aim to create a system that democratizes access, incentivizes quality contributions, and ensures resilience.

Methods

PubChain is built on a foundation of two core decentralized technologies: blockchain and the InterPlanetary File System (IPFS).

  • Blockchain Layer: This layer acts as a tamper-proof distributed ledger for recording essential metadata about papers, such as ownership, IPFS addresses, and citation information. It also handles transaction commands and ensures consensus on operations. The system is designed to transition from a consortium blockchain (Proof-of-Authority) to a public blockchain (Proof-of-Work) for increased decentralization.
  • IPFS Layer: This peer-to-peer file sharing system is used for storing the actual paper content. IPFS offers content-addressing, meaning files are identified by their content rather than their location, and ensures data availability through distributed storage.
  • Incentive Mechanism: A key innovation is PubChain's elaborate incentive scheme. Authors pay a small fee (in PubCoins) to publish, with a portion going to a reviewer bonus pool and another to the authors of cited papers. Reviewers are rewarded with PubCoins based on the quality of their reviews, which are themselves reviewed by readers. Readers can also earn rewards for providing valuable feedback on reviews. This creates a self-sustaining ecosystem where participation is financially motivated.
  • Decentralized Scoring System: To combat potential score manipulation, PubChain employs a decentralized scoring system. Review scores are averaged, with the highest and lowest 10% of reader scores for reviews being excluded to mitigate the impact of outliers or malicious actors. This system is designed to be robust against attempts to artificially inflate paper scores.
  • Financial Model: PubChain uses a two-phase financial model. Phase I involves a "cold-start" where PubCoins are pegged to established cryptocurrencies (like Bitcoin or Ether) via a two-way pegging mechanism to inject real monetary value. Phase II transitions to a model where PubChain acts as a decentralized central bank, continuously issuing a fixed amount of PubCoins per block to reward participants, similar to how a currency supports an expanding economy.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the design and simulation of the PubChain platform, not on training or evaluating on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Incentivizing the "Invisible" Work: The paper highlights that while authors and readers are often motivated by visibility and access, reviewers' contributions are largely uncompensated and undervalued. PubChain directly addresses this by creating a financial incentive for high-quality peer reviews.
  • Beyond Static Publications: The platform supports continuous improvement of publications, allowing authors to submit revised versions based on feedback, treating research papers more like living documents rather than static records.
  • Decentralization as a Resilience Strategy: By distributing data across IPFS and control across a blockchain, PubChain aims to eliminate single points of failure and ensure uninterrupted access to research.
  • A "Currency" for Knowledge: The PubCoin system aims to create a tangible value for contributions to the scientific ecosystem, moving beyond purely academic prestige.
  • Robustness Against Malice: The simulations demonstrate that the decentralized scoring system is designed to resist attempts to artificially inflate paper scores, even with a significant number of malicious actors.

Key Results

The paper presents simulation results demonstrating the robustness of PubChain's decentralized scoring system against two attack strategies:

  • First Attack Strategy (Fake Reviews): When malicious nodes act as reviewers, the proposed scoring method is shown to be robust, especially when the number of honest readers (Nrs) is large. The system's computed paper score (Si) deviates less from the ground-truth score compared to a simple average of review scores.
  • Second Attack Strategy (Fake Reviewers and Readers): In this scenario, malicious nodes act as both reviewers and readers. The simulations indicate that even with this more complex attack, PubChain's scoring method remains resilient, particularly with a larger readership (Nrs).

The paper also details the implementation of a proof-of-concept prototype, showcasing smart contracts for posting papers and demonstrating the system's core functionalities.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Incentive Mechanism Implementation: The authors acknowledge that the proposed incentive mechanism, which requires extensive modifications to blockchain program codes, has not yet been fully implemented. This is identified as a crucial area for future work.
  • Scalability of Blockchain: While the paper discusses the transition to a public blockchain, the inherent scalability challenges of blockchain technology for handling a massive volume of transactions (like those in a global publication platform) are implicitly present.
  • Real-World Adoption: The success of PubChain hinges on recruiting a critical mass of authors, reviewers, and readers who believe in its tenet of free dissemination. The authors explicitly invite volunteers to join and advocate for the platform.
  • Complexity of Review Scoring: While a decentralized scoring system is proposed, the paper notes that evaluating review comments and scores objectively is a complex task.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to focus on implementing the full incentive mechanism, further refining the decentralized scoring system, and exploring the integration with other decentralized technologies. They also emphasize the need for community participation to drive the project's success.

Summary updated

Abstract

We design and implement Publication Chain (PubChain), a decentralized open-access publication platform built on decentralized and distributed technologies of blockchain and IPFS peer-to-peer file sharing systems. The existing publication platforms have some severe drawbacks. First, instead of promoting widespread knowledge sharing, access to publications on the platforms owned by publishers is often on a fee basis. This drawback of pay wall prevents researchers from "standing on the shoulders of giants". Moreover, the peer review process on most all existing publication platforms (including both openaccess and publisher platforms) is prone to be ineffective, since there is no proper incentive to reviewers for performing high-qualified reviews. PubChain is an alternative platform to the existing publication venues aiming to address their drawbacks. No central third-party owns the contents (i.e., papers and reviews) of PubChain. Exploiting blockchain technology, we devise an elaborate incentive scheme on PubChain to incentivize key stakeholders (i.e., authors, readers and reviewers) to participate publication activities on PubChain in a substantive manner by earning credits and rewards through self-motivated interactions. We have performed simulations to investigate the robustness of our proposed incentive scheme against fraudulent publications and reviews. We also have implemented a prototype of PubChain to demonstrate its key concepts.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2020pubchain,
  author = {Taotao Wang and Soung Chang Liew and Shengli Zhang},
  title = {{PubChain: A Decentralized Open-Access Publication Platform with Participants Incentivized by Blockchain Technology}},
  booktitle = {ISNCC},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=B1NCaaE05t},
}
Figure