Protein Structure Refinement Guided by Atomic Packing Frustration Analysis

Mingchen Chen, Xun Chen, Shikai Jin, Wei Lu, Xingcheng Lin, Peter G. Wolynes

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for refining predicted protein structures by analyzing "packing frustration" at the atomic level. By identifying and strategically constraining "minimally frustrated" residues, their method significantly improves structural accuracy more efficiently than previous approaches, offering a powerful new tool for computational structural biology.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Predicting protein structures from their amino acid sequences has seen remarkable progress, especially with deep learning. However, these predictions, while often accurate, still contain errors. Refining these structures into highly accurate models comparable to experimental results is a significant challenge. Standard all-atom molecular dynamics simulations, even when run for extended periods, can get stuck in local energy minima, failing to correct subtle structural errors that require large-scale atomic rearrangements and side-chain repacking. This paper aims to address this by developing a more intelligent and efficient refinement strategy that guides simulations to overcome these energetic barriers.

Methods

The core of this work is the development and application of an "atomic packing frustration" index. This index quantifies how energetically unfavorable a particular atomic contact is within a protein structure.

  • Packing Frustration Calculation: They generate "decoy" structures by perturbing local residue contacts and sequences. By comparing the energy of the native contact to the distribution of energies in these decoys, they derive a frustration index for each contact.
  • Local and Global Frustration: This index is then used to assess both local (per-residue) and global (overall structure) frustration. Minimally frustrated residues are those involved in stable, native-like contacts, while highly frustrated residues indicate potential errors or areas that need adjustment.
  • Frustration-Guided Refinement: The key innovation is using this frustration analysis to guide all-atom molecular dynamics simulations. Instead of applying generic restraints, they selectively constrain the motions of minimally frustrated residues, allowing highly frustrated regions more freedom to explore and correct errors. This is achieved by applying harmonic constraints to the backbone atoms of minimally frustrated residues.
  • Replica Exchange Molecular Dynamics (REMD): To explore the free energy landscape and ensure thorough sampling, they employ REMD simulations.
  • Structural Quality Metrics: They use standard metrics like RMSD, GDT-TS, and a custom metric called Qw to evaluate the accuracy of the refined structures compared to experimental crystal structures.

Datasets

The study utilizes a dataset of 20 protein targets from the CASP12 (Critical Assessment of protein Structure Prediction) refinement competition. Both the initially predicted structures and the corresponding experimental crystal structures were used for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Frustration as a Diagnostic Tool: Packing frustration is not just a theoretical concept but a practical diagnostic tool that directly correlates with the quality of predicted protein structures.
  • Minimally Frustrated = High Quality: Residues involved in more stable, minimally frustrated interactions are generally found in more correctly predicted regions of the protein.
  • Targeted Refinement: The most significant insight is that intelligently guiding simulations by constraining stable (minimally frustrated) regions and allowing flexibility in unstable (highly frustrated) regions is far more effective than brute-force simulation or generic restraints.
  • Efficiency Gains: This targeted approach leads to significant improvements in structural accuracy with much greater efficiency compared to unguided simulations or other refinement methods.

Key Results

  • Improved Structural Accuracy: The "atomic packing frustration-guided refinement" method consistently improved the structural quality of predicted models across the CASP12 targets.
  • Outperforming Other Methods: In comparisons with other refinement strategies (Seok group, Feig group, PC-guided refinement), their method achieved better or comparable results, often with a more significant improvement in RMSD. For some targets, their method achieved improvements of up to 5 angstroms in RMSD.
  • Side Chain Accuracy: Beyond backbone accuracy, the method also significantly improved the accuracy of side-chain orientations, which is crucial for protein function.
  • Correlation with Crystal Structures: The frustration patterns of refined structures showed a stronger correlation with the native crystal structures, indicating a move towards the correct conformation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: While more efficient than unguided simulations, all-atom molecular dynamics and REMD are still computationally intensive.
  • Allostery and Multiple Conformations: The paper notes that some proteins might exhibit allostery and exist in multiple conformations in vivo, which could complicate the interpretation of frustration patterns and the identification of a single "native" state.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that this frustration-guided approach can be further developed and applied to a wider range of protein structure prediction and refinement challenges. The insights gained into the roles of different energy terms in structure discrimination could also inform the development of better force fields.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recent advances in machine learning, bioinformatics, and the understanding of the folding problem have enabled efficient predictions of protein structures with moderate accuracy, even for targets where there is little information from templates. All-atom molecular dynamics simulations provide a route to refine such predicted structures, but unguided atomistic simulations, even when lengthy in time, often fail to eliminate incorrect structural features that would prevent the structure from becoming more energetically favorable owing to the necessity of making large scale motions and to overcoming energy barriers for side chain repacking. In this study, we show that localizing packing frustration at atomic resolution by examining the statistics of the energetic changes that occur when the local environment of a site is changed allows one to identify the most likely locations of incorrect contacts. The global statistics of atomic resolution frustration in structures that have been predicted using various algorithms provide strong indicators of structural quality when tested over a database of 20 targets from previous CASP experiments. Residues that are more correctly located turn out to be more minimally frustrated than more poorly positioned sites. These observations provide a diagnosis of both global and local quality of predicted structures and thus can be used as guidance in all-atom refinement simulations of the 20 targets. Refinement simulations guided by atomic packing frustration turn out to be quite efficient and significantly improve the quality of the structures.
BibTeX
@article{chen2020protein,
  author = {Mingchen Chen and Xun Chen and Shikai Jin and Wei Lu and Xingcheng Lin and Peter G. Wolynes},
  title = {{Protein Structure Refinement Guided by Atomic Packing Frustration Analysis}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry B},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jpcb.0c06719},
}
Figure