Properdin oligomers adopt rigid extended conformations supporting function

Dennis Pedersen, Martin Nors Pedersen, Sofia Mm Mazarakis, Yong Wang, Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen, Lise Arleth, G.r. Andersen

TL;DR

Properdin, a key immune protein, forms rigid, extended structures as it oligomerizes. This specific structural arrangement, rather than just multivalency, is crucial for its function in stabilizing immune responses and fighting infections.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The immune system relies on a cascade of protein interactions to defend against pathogens. Properdin is a critical regulator of this cascade, specifically stabilizing "convertases" that are essential for initiating immune responses. While it's known that properdin's biological activity is linked to its ability to form larger structures (oligomers), the precise shape and rigidity of these oligomers, and how that structure relates to their function, remained largely unknown. This paper aims to elucidate the structural basis of properdin's function by characterizing the conformations of its various oligomeric states.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Negative-stain Electron Microscopy (nsEM): This technique allowed them to visualize the shapes of individual properdin oligomers (dimers, trimers, tetramers) and analyze their 2D projections.
  • Small-Angle X-ray Scattering (SAXS): SAXS provided information about the overall size and shape of properdin oligomers in solution, complementing the EM data.
  • Rigid-body Modeling: Using the structural information from nsEM and SAXS, they built atomic models of the properdin oligomers.
  • Molecular Dynamics (MD) Simulations: These simulations were used to explore the flexibility and dynamic properties of the properdin monomer.
  • Cell Lysis Assay: This functional assay measured the ability of properdin and its variants to trigger the lysis of red blood cells, a proxy for complement system activity.
  • Biolayer Interferometry: This technique was used to measure the binding kinetics of properdin complexes to C3b-coated surfaces.

Datasets

The study utilized existing structural data of properdin monomers and their domains. The primary datasets generated were:

  • SAXS data: For properdin dimers (FP2), trimers (FP3), and tetramers (FP4).
  • nsEM 2D class averages: For properdin monomers, dimers, trimers, and tetramers, both with and without a specific nanobody (hFPNb1).

These datasets are available in the SASBDB database under entries SASDKA4 (FP2), SASDKB4 (FP3), SASDKC4 (FP4), and SASDB69 (FP E244K monomer).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Properdin Monomers are "Pretzel-Shaped": The individual properdin molecules have a distinct, somewhat rigid, pretzel-like structure.
  • Oligomers are Rigid and Extended: Contrary to what might be expected from flexible protein chains, properdin dimers, trimers, and tetramers adopt surprisingly rigid and extended conformations. Dimers are curved, while trimers and tetramers are largely planar.
  • Cyclic Symmetry: The oligomers exhibit apparent n-fold rotational symmetry (C2 for dimers, C3 for trimers, C4 for tetramers), suggesting a well-defined arrangement.
  • Structure Dictates Function: Simply linking multiple properdin monomers together (multivalency) with a nanobody was not sufficient to fully restore biological activity. The specific rigid, extended conformation of the oligomers is essential.
  • Implications for Immune Recognition: The extended, rigid structure with outward-pointing binding sites suggests a role for properdin not only in stabilizing convertases but also potentially in bridging immune cells and pathogens.

Key Results

  • Oligomer Dimensions: Properdin oligomers range from 230 Å (dimers) to 360 Å (tetramers) in their extended conformations.
  • Rigidity Confirmed: SAXS data showed pronounced peaks, indicative of rigid structures, and were well-fitted by single models with cyclic symmetry.
  • Functional Link: Nanobody-linked properdin monomers showed increased activity with increasing valency, but their activity was still lower than naturally occurring properdin oligomers, highlighting the importance of the inherent oligomer structure.
  • Binding Dynamics: Nanobody-linked properdin complexes showed stronger binding and slower dissociation from C3b-coated surfaces compared to monomeric properdin, supporting the role of avidity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • EM vs. Solution Structure: The SAXS models of dimers appeared more curved than the EM 2D classes, suggesting that EM sample preparation might flatten the structures. Further investigation into this discrepancy is warranted.
  • Bound vs. Unbound Structures: The study characterized the solution structures of properdin oligomers. However, the structures of properdin when bound to C3b and convertases on activated surfaces, or to NKp46 on immune cells, might differ. Cryo-electron tomography of these complexes is suggested as a future direction.
  • Non-Mammalian Properdin: While the domain structure is conserved across many species, the specific oligomerization and function in non-mammals remain to be explored.
  • Bridging Function: The potential for properdin oligomers to bridge cells (e.g., bacteria and innate lymphoid cells) is highlighted, suggesting future studies to investigate this role in vivo.
  • C3b-Independent AP Activation: The possibility of properdin acting as a C3b-independent pattern recognition molecule to initiate the AP is raised, prompting further experimental investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Properdin stabilizes convertases formed upon activation of the complement cascade within the immune system. The biological activity of properdin depends on the oligomerization state, but whether properdin oligomers are rigid and how their structure links to function remains unknown. We show by combining electron microscopy and solution scattering, that properdin oligomers adopt extended rigid and well-defined conformations which are well approximated by single models of apparent n-fold rotational symmetry with dimensions of 230-360 Å. Properdin monomers are pretzel-shaped molecules with limited flexibility. In solution, properdin dimers are curved molecules, whereas trimers and tetramers are close to being planar molecules. Structural analysis indicates that simultaneous binding through all binding sites to surface-linked convertases is unlikely for properdin trimer and tetramers. We show that multivalency alone is insufficient for full activity in a cell lysis assay. Hence, the observed rigid extended oligomer structure is an integral component of properdin function.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pedersen2021properdin,
  author = {Dennis Pedersen and Martin Nors Pedersen and Sofia MM Mazarakis and Yong Wang and Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen and Lise Arleth and G.R. Andersen},
  title = {{Properdin oligomers adopt rigid extended conformations supporting function}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.63356},
}
Figure