Prony systems via decimation and homotopy continuation

Dmitry Batenkov

TL;DR

This paper introduces "decimated homotopy," a novel algorithm for accurately solving Prony systems, especially when their parameters are "near-colliding." This method offers a significant improvement in accuracy and robustness compared to existing techniques, particularly in challenging scenarios with closely spaced signal components.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the "confluent Prony problem," a class of polynomial systems that arise in various fields like signal processing and spectral analysis. A key challenge is accurately solving these systems when the underlying signal components (represented by "nodes") are very close to each other, a situation termed "near-colliding." Traditional methods struggle with numerical instability and poor accuracy in these scenarios, even with small amounts of noise. The authors aim to provide a robust and accurate solution for these difficult cases.

Methods

The core contribution is the "decimated homotopy" algorithm. This approach combines several key ideas:

  • Decimation: This technique involves selecting a subset of the available measurements (e.g., every p-th measurement) to form a smaller, square system. This is a form of regularization that helps to stabilize the problem, especially in near-colliding situations.
  • Hankel-type System Transformation: The original Prony system is transformed into a Hankel-type polynomial system. This transformation is crucial for applying algebraic techniques.
  • Homotopy Continuation: This is a standard numerical technique for solving polynomial systems. It involves deforming a simple, solvable system into the target system, tracing the solutions along the way. The paper uses this to solve the constructed Hankel-type system.
  • Pruning Strategies: After solving the system, multiple candidate solutions might arise. The paper proposes several strategies (exhaustive search, filtering, and using an initial approximation) to identify the correct solution corresponding to the original Prony problem.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and numerical experiments using synthetic data generated according to the Prony system model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decimation as Regularization: The paper highlights that decimation acts as a powerful regularization technique for otherwise ill-conditioned multiple roots in Prony systems. It effectively transforms a problem with poorly conditioned roots into one with well-conditioned roots.
  • Near-Optimality in Near-Colliding Regimes: The proposed "decimated homotopy" algorithm is shown to achieve near-optimal accuracy in the challenging near-colliding regime, outperforming existing methods like ESPRIT.
  • Bridging Theory and Practice: The work aims to bridge the gap between theoretical accuracy bounds for decimation and practical algorithms that can achieve this accuracy.

Key Results

  • The proposed "decimated homotopy" algorithm provides accurate solutions for Prony systems, even in near-colliding situations.
  • Numerical experiments demonstrate that the algorithm achieves accuracy several orders of magnitude better than the standard ESPRIT algorithm in these challenging scenarios.
  • The exhaustive search pruning strategy is accurate but computationally expensive. A filtering strategy (combining pre-filtering and an initial approximation) is shown to be both accurate and much faster.
  • The algorithm's accuracy is shown to be optimal up to a constant factor, as predicted by theoretical bounds.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small Noise Assumption: The analysis and algorithm primarily assume a sufficiently small noise level. Robustness to larger noise levels is a limitation.
  • Known Multiplicity: The algorithm assumes the multiplicity structure (D) of the nodes is known. Determining this structure from data is an open problem.
  • Single Cluster: The current work focuses on the case of a single cluster of near-colliding nodes. Extending the method to handle multiple clusters is an ongoing research direction.
  • Robust Detection of Near-Singular Situations: Developing methods to reliably detect these near-singular situations (i.e., correctly identifying the collision pattern D) is highlighted as an important future research question.
  • Theoretical Analysis of Pruning: Further theoretical analysis of the pruning strategies, particularly regarding spurious solutions on the torus, is suggested.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{batenkov2014prony,
  author = {Dmitry Batenkov},
  title = {{Prony systems via decimation and homotopy continuation}},
  booktitle = {SNC},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1145/2631948.2631961},
}
Figure