Prompt-Based Learning for Thread Structure Prediction in Cybersecurity Forums

Kazuaki Kashihara, Kuntal Kumar Pal, Chitta Baral, Robert P. Trevino

Abstract

In the domain of cybersecurity, dark web hacker forums serve as critical repositories of threat intelligence. However, these platforms often lack explicit metadata to define thread structures, making it difficult to map social interactions or identify influential actors. This paper introduces Next Paragraph Prediction with Instructional Prompting (NPP-IP), a method that leverages large language models (LLMs) to reconstruct "who-replied-to-whom" relationships. By prepending structured natural language instructions and in-context examples to forum posts, NPP-IP significantly outperforms traditional heuristics and standard deep learning approaches. Our evaluation across Reddit and expert-annotated hacker forum datasets demonstrates that instructional prompting effectively bridges the gap between general-purpose language models and the specialized jargon of the cybersecurity community.

Introduction

Understanding the social dynamics of hacker forums is essential for predicting future cyberattacks and identifying emerging malware threats. Unlike mainstream social media platforms like Reddit or Twitter, many dark web forums are "unstructured," meaning they do not provide clear indicators of which post is a reply to which. Without this structural context, building accurate social networks or tracking the flow of information becomes nearly impossible.

Traditional methods for thread reconstruction rely on simple heuristics, such as assuming a user is replying to the thread creator or the most recent poster. These methods are frequently inaccurate. While recent deep learning models like Next Paragraph Prediction (NPP) have improved performance, they often struggle with the nuanced, jargon-heavy language characteristic of the cybersecurity domain. This research addresses these challenges by introducing instructional prompting to guide models through the complexities of forum discourse.

Methodology

The core of this research is the Next Paragraph Prediction with Instructional Prompting (NPP-IP) framework. Rather than modifying the underlying neural architecture of models like BERT or RoBERTa, the researchers focused on optimizing the input representation through structured prompting.

Instructional Prompting

In the NPP-IP approach, the model is not merely asked to determine if "Post B" follows "Post A." Instead, the input is prepended with a structured prompt containing:

  1. Task Description: A natural language explanation of the goal (e.g., identifying reply relationships).
  2. In-Context Examples: Specific instances of correct (positive) and incorrect (negative) reply pairs to provide the model with immediate guidance.

Framing Techniques

To optimize these prompts, the authors utilized five specific framing techniques:

  • Low-Level Patterns: Utilizing simple descriptors to avoid overly complex jargon.
  • Itemized Instructions: Presenting tasks in bulleted lists for better model parsing.
  • Break It Down: Decomposing the main task into simpler sub-tasks.
  • Enforce Constraints: Explicitly defining the expected output format (e.g., True/False).
  • Specialize Instructions: Tailoring the prompt language specifically for the cybersecurity context.

Datasets

The performance of NPP-IP was evaluated using two distinct datasets:

  • Reddit Dataset: A curated collection of 105 threads (1,648 posts) from cybersecurity-related subreddits (e.g., r/netsec, r/malware). This dataset provided a controlled environment for initial training and evaluation.
  • Hacker Forums Dataset: A newly developed, expert-annotated dataset comprising 20 threads from three real-world English-language hacker forums. This served as a benchmark for testing the model's ability to generalize to the messy, unstructured environments of the dark web.

Results and Key Insights

The experimental results indicate that NPP-IP provides a substantial performance boost over existing techniques.

Quantitative Performance

  • F1 Score Improvement: NPP-IP improved F1 scores by 2.68 to 4.70 percentage points compared to the standard NPP method.
  • Heuristic Comparison: The model vastly outperformed traditional heuristics. Methods like "Creator-oriented" or "Last Reply-oriented" networks often yielded F1 scores as low as 0.01 to 0.20, whereas NPP-IP achieved significantly higher accuracy.
  • Model Efficacy: RoBERTa-Base using NPP-IP emerged as a top performer, achieving an F1 score of 0.51 on Reddit data and up to 0.67 on real-world hacker forums.

Key Insights

  • Prompting as a Domain Bridge: Instructional prompting allows models trained on relatively clean data (Reddit) to navigate the highly specialized and often obscure language of hacker forums. The prompt acts as a contextual anchor.
  • Content vs. Temporal Logic: The study confirms that the semantic content of a post is a much stronger indicator of a reply relationship than the timestamp of the post.

Discussion and Limitations

While NPP-IP represents a significant advancement, several challenges remain. One primary issue is the "Nested Quote" problem, where users quote multiple previous posts in a single reply. This can lead the model to incorrectly attribute a reply to an earlier post in the chain rather than the immediate predecessor.

Furthermore, the current study is limited to English-language forums. Given the global nature of cybercrime, future iterations must account for multi-lingual data. There is also a persistent gap in model "understanding" of specific cybersecurity keywords; the authors suggest that future work should involve fine-tuning models on large-scale cybersecurity corpora to improve their baseline vocabulary before applying instructional prompting.

Conclusion

NPP-IP demonstrates that how we instruct a model is as important as the model's architecture itself. By providing clear, context-aware instructions, researchers can more accurately map the complex social structures of the dark web, providing a vital tool for the cybersecurity community to track and mitigate emerging threats.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{kashihara2023prompt,
  author = {Kazuaki Kashihara and Kuntal Kumar Pal and Chitta Baral and Robert P. Trevino},
  title = {{Prompt-Based Learning for Thread Structure Prediction in Cybersecurity Forums}},
  booktitle = {IntelliSys},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-031-47715-7\_51},
}
Figure