Progress on high-temperature protective coatings for aero-engines

Lei Guo, Wenting He, Wenbo Chen, Zhaolu Xue, Jian He, Yiqian Guo, Yang Wu, Lihua Gao, Dongqing Li, Zhao Zhang, Liangliang Wei, Yuyi Gao, Tiehao Zhang, Qiao Jiao, Qianhui Li, Hongbo GuoSurface 2023 · DOI

This review paper provides a comprehensive look at the evolution of high-temperature protective coatings—Thermal Barrier Coatings (TBCs), Environmental Barrier Coatings (EBCs), stealth, and corrosion-resistant layers—essential for pushing aero-engine efficiency to new limits. It highlights the transition toward ceramic-matrix composites (CMCs) and the critical role of first-principles modeling in overcoming environmental threats like CMAS (sand/dust) attack.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern aero-engines are caught in a thermal "bottleneck." To increase thrust and fuel efficiency, engines must operate at higher gas-inlet temperatures, often exceeding 1700°C. However, traditional nickel-based superalloys lose structural integrity well below these temperatures.

While Thermal Barrier Coatings (TBCs) like yttria-stabilized zirconia (YSZ) have provided a shield for decades, they face three major hurdles at next-gen temperatures:

  1. Phase Instability: YSZ undergoes a volume-expanding phase transformation above 1250°C that leads to cracking.
  2. CMAS Attack: Ingested sand, dust, and volcanic ash (calcia-magnesia-aluminosilicates) melt into a glass that penetrates and dissolves the coating.
  3. The CMC Shift: As engines move toward Ceramic-Matrix Composites (CMCs) to save weight, they require Environmental Barrier Coatings (EBCs) to prevent water vapor from "recessing" (vaporizing) the ceramic substrate.

Furthermore, higher operating temperatures make aircraft easier to detect via infrared, necessitating the integration of stealth technologies into these protective layers.

Methods

As a comprehensive review, the paper synthesizes decades of experimental data and fabrication techniques. It categorizes progress across:

  • Fabrication Technologies: Comparing standard methods like Atmospheric Plasma Spraying (APS) and Electron Beam Physical Vapor Deposition (EB-PVD) with emerging techniques like Plasma Spray-Physical Vapor Deposition (PS-PVD), which allows for non-line-of-sight coating of complex geometries.
  • Material Design: Evaluating new candidates such as rare earth zirconates ($RE_2Zr_2O_7$), hexaaluminates, and rare earth silicates.
  • Computational Modeling: Highlighting the use of First-Principles (Density Functional Theory - DFT) calculations to predict atomic-level interface bonding strength and the reaction enthalpies between coatings and corrosive melts.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. (As a review article, it draws upon hundreds of cited experimental studies and material property databases rather than a single training or evaluation dataset).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CMAS is a Chemical Solvent, Not Just Debris: The paper emphasizes that CMAS doesn't just sit on the surface; it acts as a solvent that leaches stabilizers (like Yttria) out of the coating, triggering premature failure.
  • The "Sacrificial" Strategy: One of the most promising ways to fight CMAS is to design coatings that react with the melt to form a dense, crystalline "sealant" layer (like apatite) that blocks further penetration.
  • Synergistic Co-doping: In corrosion-resistant coatings, the authors note that doping with two reactive elements (e.g., Hf + Zr) creates a "pinning" effect on grain boundaries that is significantly more effective at slowing oxidation than either element alone.
  • Stealth-Thermal Integration: Stealth is no longer a separate layer. Researchers are developing "bi-stealth" coatings that use metamaterials and frequency-selective surfaces (FSS) to manage both radar and infrared signatures while providing thermal insulation.

Key Results

  • Thermal Performance: Rare earth zirconates like $Gd_2Zr_2O_7$ show significantly lower thermal conductivity than YSZ and remain stable above 1300°C, though they require a "double-layer" architecture to manage thermal expansion mismatch with the metal.
  • Stealth Efficiency: New microwave-absorbing coatings using MAX phase materials or perovskites can achieve reflection losses of -38 dB, while infrared coatings can drop emissivity to as low as 0.13.
  • EBC Durability: Rare earth monosilicates ($RE_2SiO_5$) were found to have lower volatility in water vapor compared to disilicates, making them superior candidates for protecting CMCs in the harsh, steam-rich environment of a combustion chamber.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several gaps that remain:

  • The "Sea Salt" Complication: Most research focuses on CMAS alone, but in marine environments, the coupling of CMAS with sea salt significantly lowers the melting point of the debris, making it even more aggressive. This "coupling corrosion" is a relatively new and understudied field.
  • Lab vs. Reality: Most testing is done in static furnaces. There is a dire need for more "burner rig" testing that simulates the high-pressure, high-velocity, and extreme thermal gradients of a real engine.
  • Smart Coatings: The next frontier is "intelligent" coatings that can sense damage or autonomously react to environmental changes to prevent failure.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Aero-engine is a key part of aircraft, the operating temperature of which is being pushed to unprecedented levels for higher engine efficiency and performance. To accomplish higher gas-inlet temperature of aero-engines, applying thermal barrier coatings (TBCs) on hot-section metallic components, or even replacing some of the metallic components in aero-engines with ceramic-matrix composites (CMCs) and applying environmental-barrier coatings (EBCs) on them, are effective methods and have been widely accepted. On the other hand, increasing aero-engines operating temperature causes the aircraft more easily be detected, thus stealth coatings are necessary for engines. Except the hottest part in aero-engines, other parts may not need TBCs or EBCs due to the relatively low operating temperature, but they still need protection from oxidation and corrosion. Hence, corrosion-resistant coatings are essential. In this paper, the latest progress of the above high-temperature protective coatings, i.e., TBCs, EBCs, stealth coatings and corrosion-resistant coatings is reviewed, mainly including their materials, fabrication technologies and performance. In addition, due to the harsh operating environment, these protective coatings face many threats such as calcia-magnesia-aluminosilicates (CMAS) attack, causing premature failure of the coatings, which is also concerned in this paper. The work would provide a comprehensive understanding on the high-temperature protective coatings in aero-engines and guidance for developing advanced protective coatings for next-generation aero-engines.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guo2023progress,
  author = {Lei Guo and Wenting He and Wenbo Chen and Zhaolu Xue and Jian He and Yiqian Guo and Yang Wu and Lihua Gao and Dongqing Li and Zhao Zhang and Liangliang Wei and Yuyi Gao and Tiehao Zhang and Qiao Jiao and Qianhui Li and Hongbo Guo},
  title = {{Progress on high-temperature protective coatings for aero-engines}},
  booktitle = {Surface},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1007/s44251-023-00005-6},
}
Figure