Probing environmental and tectonic changes underneath Mexico City with the urban seismic field

Laura Ermert, Enrique Cabral‐Cano, Estelle Chaussard, Darío Solano-Rojas, Luis Quintanar, Diana Morales Padilla, Enrique Fernández-Torres, Marine DenolleSolid 2023 · DOI

Abstract

The sediments underneath Mexico City have unique mechanical properties that give rise to strong site effects. We investigated temporal changes in the seismic velocity at strong-motion and broadband seismic stations throughout Mexico City, including sites with different geologic characteristics ranging from city center locations situated on lacustrine clay to hillside locations on volcanic bedrock. We used autocorrelations of urban seismic noise, enhanced by waveform clustering, to extract subtle seismic velocity changes by coda wave interferometry. We observed and modeled seasonal, co- and post-seismic changes, as well as a long-term linear trend in seismic velocity. Seasonal variations can be explained by self-consistent models of thermoelastic and poroelastic changes in the subsurface shear wave velocity. Overall, sites on lacustrine clay-rich sediments appear to be more sensitive to seasonal surface temperature changes, whereas sites on alluvial and volcaniclastic sediments and on bedrock are sensitive to precipitation. The 2017 Mw 7.1 Puebla and 2020 Mw 7.4 Oaxaca earthquakes both caused a clear drop in seismic velocity, followed by a time-logarithmic recovery that may still be ongoing for the 2017 event at several sites or that may remain incomplete. The slope of the linear trend in seismic velocity is correlated with the downward vertical displacement of the ground measured by interferometric synthetic aperture radar, suggesting a causative relationship and supporting earlier studies on changes in the resonance frequency of sites in the Mexico City basin due to groundwater extraction. Our findings show how sensitively shallow seismic velocity and, in consequence, site effects react to environmental, tectonic and anthropogenic processes. They also demonstrate that urban strong-motion stations provide useful data for coda wave monitoring given sufficiently high-amplitude urban seismic noise.

Introduction

Mexico City is a geological outlier. Built on a high-altitude basin filled with soft, water-saturated lacustrine clays (an old lakebed), the city suffers from extreme "site effects" that amplify earthquake shaking. However, these subsurface properties are not static. Traditional seismic imaging often provides only a "snapshot" in time, but understanding seismic hazard requires knowledge of how the soil responds dynamically to environmental stressors, tectonic events, and human activity.

Map of Mexico City showing the distribution of seismic stations across different geotechnical zones, including the soft Lake zone and the firmer Transition zone.

This study investigates whether existing urban "strong-motion" sensor networks—typically reserved for measuring major earthquakes—can be repurposed for continuous, long-term monitoring of these subtle subsurface shifts.

Methodology

The research team employed Coda Wave Interferometry (CWI) on the autocorrelations of urban seismic noise. Unlike traditional methods that compare signals between distant stations, autocorrelation analyzes a single station's noise signal against itself over time, highlighting structural changes directly beneath the sensor.

To manage the chaotic nature of urban noise, the authors applied a novel processing strategy using Gaussian Mixture Models (GMM) and Principal Component Analysis (PCA) to cluster noise into "day" and "night" patterns. By selectively stacking coherent daytime clusters, they significantly improved the signal-to-noise ratio. These observations were then modeled using thermoelastic (temperature-driven) and poroelastic (pressure-driven by rain) diffusion equations, optimized via Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) inversions.

Key Insights and Results

Geology and Environmental Sensitivity

A primary finding is that local geology dictates environmental sensitivity. Sites situated on thick clay layers are primarily sensitive to surface temperature changes (thermoelastic stress). Conversely, sites on volcanic hillsides or alluvial fans respond more strongly to rainfall, which alters pore pressure (poroelastic changes). Natural seasonal variations in velocity typically fluctuate by approximately 1% peak-to-peak.

Tectonic Impacts

Major tectonic events leave a lasting mark on the subsurface. The 2017 $M_w$ 7.1 Puebla earthquake caused a massive 10% drop in seismic velocity at certain sites. The subsequent recovery follows a logarithmic curve and, in several areas, remained incomplete years after the event.

Relative velocity changes (dv/v) recorded at the G.UNM station over time, highlighting the immediate drops caused by the Puebla and Oaxaca earthquakes.

Anthropogenic Subsidence

The study identified a long-term linear increase in seismic velocity (up to 0.75% per year) that correlates with ground subsidence measured by InSAR satellites ($R^2 = 0.29$). As groundwater is extracted, the clay layers compact and "stiffen," which increases the speed of seismic waves over time. This confirms that human activity is actively altering the city's seismic response.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that urban strong-motion accelerometers are a viable, research-grade tool for monitoring the shallow crust (top 100 meters). While the current models assume a linear superposition of effects, future work integrating real-time groundwater data could further refine these models. This "noise-clustering" technique offers a scalable way for cities worldwide to monitor infrastructure health and evolving seismic risks in real-time.

Summary updated

Abstract

The sediments underneath Mexico City have unique mechanical properties that give rise to strong site effects. We investigated temporal changes in the seismic velocity at strong-motion and broadband seismic stations throughout Mexico City, including sites with different geologic characteristics ranging from city center locations situated on lacustrine clay to hillside locations on volcanic bedrock. We used autocorrelations of urban seismic noise, enhanced by waveform clustering, to extract subtle seismic velocity changes by coda wave interferometry. We observed and modeled seasonal, co- and post-seismic changes, as well as a long-term linear trend in seismic velocity. Seasonal variations can be explained by self-consistent models of thermoelastic and poroelastic changes in the subsurface shear wave velocity. Overall, sites on lacustrine clay-rich sediments appear to be more sensitive to seasonal surface temperature changes, whereas sites on alluvial and volcaniclastic sediments and on bedrock are sensitive to precipitation. The 2017 Mw 7.1 Puebla and 2020 Mw 7.4 Oaxaca earthquakes both caused a clear drop in seismic velocity, followed by a time-logarithmic recovery that may still be ongoing for the 2017 event at several sites or that may remain incomplete. The slope of the linear trend in seismic velocity is correlated with the downward vertical displacement of the ground measured by interferometric synthetic aperture radar, suggesting a causative relationship and supporting earlier studies on changes in the resonance frequency of sites in the Mexico City basin due to groundwater extraction. Our findings show how sensitively shallow seismic velocity and, in consequence, site effects react to environmental, tectonic and anthropogenic processes. They also demonstrate that urban strong-motion stations provide useful data for coda wave monitoring given sufficiently high-amplitude urban seismic noise.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ermert2023probing,
  author = {Laura Ermert and Enrique Cabral‐Cano and Estelle Chaussard and Darío Solano-Rojas and Luis Quintanar and Diana Morales Padilla and Enrique Fernández-Torres and Marine Denolle},
  title = {{Probing environmental and tectonic changes underneath Mexico City with the urban seismic field}},
  booktitle = {Solid},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.5194/se-14-529-2023},
}
Figure