Probabilistic forecasts of wind power generation in regions with complex topography using deep learning methods: An Arctic case

Odin Foldvik Eikeland, Finn Dag Hovem, Tom Eirik Olsen, Matteo Chiesa, Filippo Maria Bianchi

TL;DR

This paper explores using deep learning to generate probabilistic wind power forecasts for a wind farm in the complex, mountainous terrain of the Norwegian Arctic. The researchers found that combining local sensor data with regional weather models allows deep learning architectures (specifically DeepAR) to "auto-correct" weather prediction biases, and that incorporating physical constraints—like the plant's maximum capacity—dramatically improves the quality of the forecast intervals.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As the world shifts toward renewable energy, power grids must manage the inherent intermittency of wind and solar. In liberalized electricity markets, producers must commit to "day-ahead" generation targets; if they produce too much or too little, they face financial penalties.

Standard "point forecasts" provide a single expected value but offer no information about uncertainty. This is a major liability in regions like the Arctic, where complex topography (mountains and fjords) creates micro-climates that "Numerical Weather Predictions" (NWPs) often fail to capture. The authors aim to move beyond point forecasts to probabilistic forecasts, which provide a Prediction Interval (PI)—essentially a range (e.g., "we are 95% sure generation will be between 10MW and 15MW") that allows grid operators to manage risk more effectively.

Methods

The authors employed DeepAR, a state-of-the-art deep learning framework designed specifically for probabilistic time series forecasting.

  • Architecture: DeepAR uses Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs)—the authors compared Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) and Gated Recurrent Unit (GRU) cells—to map historical data to the parameters of a probability distribution (in this case, a Gaussian distribution).
  • Probabilistic Output: Instead of predicting a single number, the model predicts the mean and standard deviation, allowing it to generate Monte Carlo samples of potential future outcomes.
  • Physical Post-processing: A key contribution of the paper is the "adjusted" forecast. Since a wind farm has a hard physical limit (54 MW in this case), the authors capped the upper bound of the statistical prediction intervals at this theoretical maximum, significantly refining the forecast's utility.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset from a wind farm in Northern Norway consisting of 18 turbines (54 MW total capacity).

  • Local Measurements: 1-hour resolution data of power generation, wind speed, and wind direction from nacelle-mounted instruments (Year 2020).
  • NWP Data: Forecasts from the AROME-Arctic model, which provides weather data at a 2.5 km spatial resolution.
  • Topography: Digital altitude maps were used to contextualize why certain turbines (shielded by mountains) produced significantly less energy than others.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Auto-Correction" Effect: The most important finding was that models using only weather forecasts or only local measurements performed poorly. However, when combined, the deep learning model learned to use local historical data to "correct" the systematic biases found in the coarse regional weather models.
  • Topography as a Noise Source: In the Arctic, two turbines just a few kilometers apart can experience vastly different wind speeds due to terrain shielding. This makes standard weather models particularly unreliable and highlights the need for site-specific deep learning.
  • Physics Beats Pure Statistics: Statistical models don't inherently know that a wind farm cannot produce 60 MW if its turbines are rated for 54 MW. By manually enforcing this physical "ceiling" on the prediction intervals, the researchers achieved a much "sharper" (narrower and more useful) forecast without losing accuracy.

Key Results

The DeepAR-LSTM model emerged as the superior architecture across all configurations.

  • Best Configuration: Using both measured and predicted weather (Configuration 1) yielded a Normalized Root Mean Square Error (NRMSE) of 0.16 and a Mean Scaled Interval Score (MSIS) of 2.53.
  • Impact of Physical Constraints: By capping the 95% Prediction Interval at the plant's 54 MW capacity, the MSIS (a measure of interval quality) improved from 2.53 to 1.16. A lower score indicates a "sharper" interval that still contains the true value, making it far more actionable for energy traders.
  • Failure of Single-Source Data: Models relying only on local measurements (Configuration 2) were significantly worse, with an MSIS of 10.16, proving that historical patterns alone cannot predict future wind shifts without a forward-looking weather model.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a few areas for improvement:

  • Distribution Assumptions: The model assumes a Gaussian (normal) distribution for errors. However, wind power data is often "skewed" (e.g., many hours of zero production), suggesting that other probability distributions might fit the data better.
  • Hyperparameter Automation: While a grid search was used for tuning, more advanced automated machine learning (AutoML) could potentially find even more efficient model configurations.
  • Generalizability: The study focuses on a single Arctic site. Future work should test if these "auto-correction" patterns hold true across different climates and terrains.

Summary updated

Abstract

The energy market relies on forecasting capabilities of both demand and power generation that need to be kept in dynamic balance. Nowadays, contracts and auctions of renewable energy in a liberalized electricity market heavily rely on forecasting future power generation. The highly intermittent nature of renewable energy sources increases the uncertainty about future power generation. Since point forecast does not account for such uncertainties, it is necessary to rely on probabilistic forecasts. This work first introduces probabilistic forecasts with deep learning. Then, we show how deep learning models can be used to make probabilistic forecasts of day-ahead power generation from a wind power plant located in Northern Norway. The performance, in terms of the quality of the prediction intervals, is compared to different deep learning models and sets of covariates. The findings show that the accuracy of the predictions improves by 37% when historical data on measured weather and numerical weather predictions (NWPs) were included as exogenous variables. In particular, historical data allows the model to auto-correct systematic biases in the NWPs. Finally, we observe that when using only NWPs or only measured weather as exogenous variables, worse performances are obtained. The work shows the importance of understanding which variables must be included to improve the prediction performance, which is of fundamental value for the energy market that relies on accurate forecasting capabilities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{eikeland2022probabilistic,
  author = {Odin Foldvik Eikeland and Finn Dag Hovem and Tom Eirik Olsen and Matteo Chiesa and Filippo Maria Bianchi},
  title = {{Probabilistic forecasts of wind power generation in regions with complex topography using deep learning methods: An Arctic case}},
  booktitle = {Energy},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1016/j.ecmx.2022.100239},
}
Figure