Privacy-preserving transactive energy systems: Key topics and open research challenges

Daniel Gerbi Duguma, Juliana Jia Yu Zhang, Meysam Aboutalebi, Shiliang Zhang, Catherine Banet, Cato Bjørkli, Chinmayi Prabhu Baramashetru, Frank Eliassen, Hui Zhang, Jonathan Muringani, Josef Noll, Knut Inge Fostervold, Lars Böcker, Lee Andrew Bygrave, Matin Bagherpour, Maunya Doroudi Moghadam, Olaf Owe, Poushali Sengupta, Roman Vitenberg, Sabita Maharjan, Thiago Garrett, Yushuai Li, Zhengyu ShanarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

The global transition toward renewable energy is fundamentally reshaping the power grid. Centralized models are increasingly giving way to decentralized Transactive Energy Systems (TES), where "prosumers"—households that both generate and consume electricity—can trade energy directly with their neighbors. This shift toward peer-to-peer (P2P) trading promises greater efficiency and local resilience. However, as highlighted in the synthesis of the 2023 PriTEM workshop, realizing this vision requires overcoming significant hurdles at the intersection of technology, law, and human behavior.

The Privacy-Transparency Dilemma

One of the primary technical vehicles for P2P energy markets is blockchain technology. Its decentralized nature and immutable ledger offer a transparent way to record transactions without a central authority. Yet, this transparency creates a profound conflict with privacy. High-resolution energy data can inadvertently reveal sensitive personal habits, such as when residents are home or what appliances they use.

Furthermore, the immutability of blockchain directly clashes with legal frameworks like the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), specifically the "right to be forgotten." If personal data is etched permanently into a ledger, compliance becomes nearly impossible. The paper suggests that bridging this gap requires advanced cryptographic solutions like zero-knowledge proofs or off-chain storage, though these introduce their own complexities regarding security and data persistence.

The Human Element: Understanding Prosumer Motivations

A critical insight from the research is that the "prosumer" is not a monolith driven solely by financial profit. While cost savings and ROI are important, they are often insufficient to sustain long-term engagement in local energy communities.

The literature synthesis identifies a broad spectrum of non-monetary motivators. Factors such as a desire for greater autonomy, concern for climate change, and the strengthening of social cohesion play pivotal roles. Understanding these diverse incentives is essential for designing systems that people actually want to use.

Table 1: Monetary and non-monetary factors influencing participation in P2P energy markets.

As shown in the table above, research across different regions—from the Netherlands to South Korea—highlights that "Community Identity" and "Self-sufficiency" are often as influential as "Selling prices" or "Cost savings."

Technical and Policy Bottlenecks

Beyond privacy and psychology, the paper identifies several systemic barriers:

  • The Blockchain Trilemma: Current public blockchains struggle to balance security, scalability, and decentralization. High-density urban microgrids require transaction throughputs that current decentralized ledgers cannot yet support without significant trade-offs.
  • Interoperability: The fragmentation of smart contract languages and data formats prevents different local energy markets from communicating, creating isolated "islands" of energy trading.
  • Policy Gaps: There is a notable lack of structured policy frameworks for local energy communities. For instance, even in countries with high renewable adoption like Norway, the regulatory landscape for P2P trading remains underdeveloped.

Furthermore, the paper notes a significant disconnect between top-down assessments and local realities, identifying a 2.8% gap in primary energy consumption relative to the EU’s 2030 targets. This suggests that current models may be failing to account for the complexities of local energy interactions.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The path forward for Privacy-Preserving Transactive Energy Systems is inherently transdisciplinary. It is not enough to solve the engineering challenges of scalability or the cryptographic challenges of privacy in isolation. Success depends on a "common language" between engineers, lawyers, and social scientists. Future research must prioritize localized knowledge, particularly in less developed regions, and focus on building human-centric systems that respect privacy while fostering community-driven energy transitions.

Summary updated

Abstract

This manuscript aims to formalize and conclude the discussions initiated during the PriTEM workshop 22-23 March 2023. We present important ideas and discussion topics in the context of transactive energy systems. Moreover, the conclusions from the discussions articulate potential aspects to be explored in future studies on transactive energy management. Particularly, these conclusions cover research topics in energy technology and energy informatics, energy law, data law, energy market and socio-psychology that are relevant to the seamless integration of renewable energy resources and the transactive energy systems-in smart microgrids-focusing on distributed frameworks such as peer-to-peer (P2P) energy trading. We clarify issues, identify barriers, and suggest possible solutions to open questions in diversified topics, such as block-chain interoperability, consumer privacy and data sharing, and participation incentivization. Furthermore, we also elaborate challenges associated with cross-disciplinary collaboration and coordination for transactive energy systems, and enumerate the lessons learned from our work so far.
BibTeX
@misc{duguma2023privacy,
  author = {Daniel Gerbi Duguma and Juliana Jia Yu Zhang and Meysam Aboutalebi and Shiliang Zhang and Catherine Banet and Cato Bjørkli and Chinmayi Prabhu Baramashetru and Frank Eliassen and Hui Zhang and Jonathan Muringani and Josef Noll and Knut Inge Fostervold and Lars Böcker and Lee Andrew Bygrave and Matin Bagherpour and Maunya Doroudi Moghadam and Olaf Owe and Poushali Sengupta and Roman Vitenberg and Sabita Maharjan and Thiago Garrett and Yushuai Li and Zhengyu Shan},
  title = {{Privacy-preserving transactive energy systems: Key topics and open research challenges}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2312.11564},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11564},
}
Figure