Peer-to-peer energy systems for connected communities: A review of recent advances and emerging challenges

Wayes Tushar, Chau Yuen, Tapan Kumar Saha, Thomas Morstyn, Archie C. Chapman, M. J. E. Alam, Sarmad Hanif, H. Vincent PoorApplied Energy 2020 · DOI

Introduction

The global energy landscape is undergoing a fundamental shift. After a century of centralized stability, we are moving toward a deregulated, prosumer-centric model driven by the rapid deployment of Distributed Energy Resources (DERs), such as rooftop solar, wind turbines, and electric vehicles (EVs). While peer-to-peer (P2P) energy sharing has shown promise in small-scale pilots, a significant gap remains between research and large-scale implementation. This review provides a roadmap for this transition, categorizing technological advances and identifying critical hurdles.

Conceptual Framework: Layers and Markets

To organize the complex P2P ecosystem, the authors propose a domain-based classification. A fundamental distinction is made between the physical infrastructure and the digital marketplace.

The P2P ecosystem is divided into a Physical Layer (grid hardware) and a Virtual Layer (information and pricing systems).

The Physical Layer encompasses grid connections, smart metering, and communication infrastructure. Conversely, the Virtual Layer handles information systems, market operations, pricing mechanisms, and energy management.

Market Structures

The review identifies three primary market models for P2P energy trading:

  1. Coordinated Market: Centralized control where a coordinator manages trades.
  2. Decentralized Market: Pure P2P trading with direct interaction between prosumers.
  3. Community Market: A hybrid model where a community manager facilitates trading without absolute control.
Comparison of (a) Coordinated, (b) Decentralized, and (c) Community market structures for P2P energy trading.

The "Community Market" model is highlighted as a vital middle ground, balancing prosumer autonomy with the grid operator's need for oversight.

Key Insights and Technological Enablers

  • The "Negawatt" Concept: P2P trading is evolving beyond selling excess generation. Prosumers can now trade "negawatts"—revenue earned by strategically reducing consumption during peak periods.
  • Responsive Buildings: Buildings can participate as prosumers even without local generation by leveraging IoT to manage internal energy flexibility.
  • AI and 5G: Handling the complexity of real-time trading requires the ultra-low latency of 5G and the predictive capabilities of Reinforcement Learning to manage uncertainties in weather and behavior.

Results and Economic Viability

Evidence from global pilots, such as the Brooklyn Microgrid (USA) and Australia's RENew Nexus, demonstrates that the technology is mature. Key findings include:

  • Savings: P2P sharing, particularly when paired with battery storage, can increase household energy savings by 28% to 60% compared to traditional models.
  • Grid Efficiency: These systems reduce peak demand and improve localized network performance, such as mitigating voltage fluctuations.

Emerging Challenges

Despite technological readiness, four major challenges persist:

  1. Stakeholder Conflicts: Divergent interests between traditional retailers, network providers, and prosumers.
  2. Physical Constraints: The difficulty of accounting for physical network losses in digital contracts.
  3. Post-Settlement Uncertainty: Gaps between committed and actual energy delivery due to forecasting errors.
  4. Regulatory Barriers: The lack of legislative frameworks for taxing and structuring P2P markets.

Conclusion

The transition to P2P energy systems is technically feasible but requires a holistic approach that integrates market design with physical grid constraints and regulatory reform. Hybrid "Community" models currently offer the most practical path for scaling these systems globally.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{tushar2020peer,
  author = {Wayes Tushar and Chau Yuen and Tapan Kumar Saha and Thomas Morstyn and Archie C. Chapman and M. J. E. Alam and Sarmad Hanif and H. Vincent Poor},
  title = {{Peer-to-peer energy systems for connected communities: A review of recent advances and emerging challenges}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2011.11118},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2011.11118},
}
Figure