Privacy constraints in regularized convex optimization

Kamalika Chaudhuri, Anand D. Sarwate

TL;DR

This paper introduces a general framework for creating privacy-preserving versions of convex optimization problems by adding noise to the objective function. This approach allows for the computation of solutions that protect individual data privacy, with applications in machine learning, density estimation, and resource allocation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As more personal data moves online, preserving the privacy of individuals becomes increasingly critical. While algorithms can efficiently process and analyze this data, there's a growing need to ensure that the insights derived do not inadvertently reveal sensitive information about the individuals who contributed to the dataset. This paper tackles the challenge of computing and releasing functions of data in a way that guarantees privacy, specifically focusing on convex optimization problems, which are fundamental to many machine learning and statistical tasks. The goal is to find a solution to an optimization problem that is useful but makes it difficult for an adversary to infer individual data points from the output.

Methods

The core contribution of this paper is a general method for privatizing convex optimization problems. Instead of adding noise to the final solution (the "sensitivity method"), they propose adding noise directly to the objective function before optimization. Specifically, for an objective function $J(f; D) = L(f; D) + N(f)$, where $L$ is a data-dependent loss function and $N$ is a regularizer, they propose minimizing a perturbed objective $J_{priv}(f) = J(f; D) + b^T f$. The noise vector $b$ is drawn from a distribution that depends on the privacy parameter $\epsilon$.

This approach relies on the $\epsilon$-differential privacy model, a strong notion of privacy where the output of an algorithm is nearly indistinguishable whether or not any single individual's data is included. The authors establish conditions under which this perturbed optimization yields an $\epsilon$-differentially private solution. These conditions include the differentiability of the loss function, convexity of the regularizer, and strict convexity of the overall objective function. They also show that if the objective function is $\lambda$-strongly convex, the utility loss (deviation from the optimal non-private solution) can be bounded.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a general framework and theoretical analysis, using synthetic or conceptual datasets for illustrative examples within specific applications.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Perturbing the Objective is Key: Adding noise to the objective function, rather than the final solution, is a more effective way to achieve differential privacy for convex optimization problems. This is because it "smooths out" the landscape of the optimization problem, making it harder to pinpoint the exact contribution of any single data point.
  • Differential Privacy as a General Framework: The paper demonstrates that the $\epsilon$-differential privacy model, originally developed for general algorithms, can be effectively applied to a broad class of convex optimization problems.
  • Regularization and Privacy Synergy: The authors note an interesting parallel between regularization (used to prevent overfitting) and privacy mechanisms (used to mask individual data). Both aim to "smooth" the output of an optimization process, albeit for different reasons.
  • Differentiability Matters: The proof of privacy guarantees relies on the differentiability of the loss function. Non-differentiable loss functions (like the hinge loss in SVMs) require approximations (e.g., Huber loss) to fit the framework, as demonstrated in the analysis.
  • Strict Convexity is Crucial: The strict convexity of the objective function ensures a unique solution, which is essential for differential privacy. If multiple solutions exist, selecting one arbitrarily could reveal information about the data.

Key Results

  • The paper provides a general algorithm (Algorithm 1) for privacy-preserving convex optimization by perturbing the objective function.
  • Theorem 1 establishes that under certain conditions (differentiable loss, convex regularizer, strictly convex objective), the proposed algorithm achieves $\epsilon$-differential privacy.
  • Theorem 2 shows that if the objective function is $\lambda$-strongly convex, the privacy-preserving solution's objective value is not significantly worse than the optimal non-private solution, with bounded utility loss.
  • The paper illustrates the applicability of the framework to classification (logistic regression, SVMs), density estimation (regularized maximum entropy), and resource allocation problems.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Differentiability Requirement: The core algorithm and its privacy guarantees rely on the differentiability of the loss function. While approximations like the Huber loss can be used for non-differentiable losses, this adds complexity and might impact performance. The paper acknowledges that the proof does not hold for non-differentiable loss functions without such approximations.
  • Strict Convexity Requirement: The strict convexity of the objective function is necessary to ensure a unique solution, which is vital for privacy. If the objective is not strictly convex, additional mechanisms might be needed to ensure privacy.
  • Utility Trade-off: While the paper bounds the utility loss for strongly convex objectives, the inherent trade-off between privacy ($\epsilon$) and utility remains a key consideration.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring decentralized auction mechanisms for resource allocation that preserve privacy and developing new techniques for privatizing algorithms used in practice. They also hint at the need for further analysis for non-differentiable loss functions and objectives.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper is withdrawn due to some errors, which are corrected in arXiv:0912.0071v4 [cs.LG].
BibTeX
@misc{chaudhuri2009privacy,
  author = {Kamalika Chaudhuri and Anand D. Sarwate},
  title = {{Privacy constraints in regularized convex optimization}},
  year = {2009},
  eprint = {0907.1413},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/0907.1413},
}
Figure