Prioritized Goal Decomposition of Markov Decision Processes: Toward a Synthesis of Classical and Decision Theoretic Planning

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel approach to tackle complex decision-making problems by decomposing them into smaller, prioritized sub-problems. By combining techniques from classical planning and decision theory, it offers a way to generate efficient, near-optimal policies for problems with multiple competing objectives, even when traditional methods struggle.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Decision-theoretic planning (DTP) problems, often modeled as Markov Decision Processes (MDPs), are powerful for handling uncertainty and multiple goals. However, standard algorithms for solving MDPs, like dynamic programming, suffer from exponential complexity, requiring explicit enumeration of all possible states. This makes them impractical for real-world scenarios with vast state spaces. While classical planning methods are more scalable by focusing on features and structure, they typically struggle with uncertainty. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a method that leverages the strengths of both approaches: decomposing complex MDPs into manageable sub-problems and then intelligently merging their solutions.

Methods

The core of the proposed method is goal decomposition. The authors first decompose the overall objective (represented by a reward function) into several smaller, prioritized objectives. For each prioritized objective, they construct an abstract Markov Decision Process (MDP). This abstraction is achieved by identifying and focusing on the most relevant state variables that influence the achievement of that specific objective, effectively reducing the state space.

They then solve these smaller, abstract MDPs to obtain abstract policies and their corresponding value functions. The key challenge then becomes merging these abstract policies into a single, coherent policy for the original problem. Two primary merging strategies are proposed:

  1. Value Function-Based Merging: This approach uses the value functions of the abstract policies as heuristics to guide a state-space search. The search explores possible action sequences, prioritizing those that lead to states with high combined values across the prioritized objectives. This method is flexible and can handle situations where abstract policies might conflict.
  2. Least-Commitment Plan (LCP) Based Merging: This method leverages insights from classical planning. It involves extracting the essential causal structure from an abstract policy in the form of a Least-Commitment Plan (LCP). This LCP represents the core dependencies and ordering constraints of the policy. When merging a new policy, the search is constrained to actions that are consistent with the LCP of a higher-priority objective. This approach offers computational advantages by restricting the search space and allows for incremental merging.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a general framework and uses illustrative examples rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Goal Decomposition as a Bridge: Decomposing complex decision problems into prioritized sub-goals is a powerful way to bridge the gap between scalable classical planning and uncertainty-handling DTP.
  • Abstraction for Tractability: Focusing on relevant state variables for each sub-goal significantly reduces the complexity of the MDPs that need to be solved.
  • Value Functions as Heuristics: Abstract value functions can serve as effective heuristics for guiding search in the merged problem space, allowing for efficient policy merging without explicitly constructing a combined, large MDP.
  • Least-Commitment Plans for Flexibility: Extracting causal structure via LCPs from abstract policies reveals inherent flexibility, enabling more robust and efficient policy merging by respecting essential dependencies.
  • Prioritization is Key: When objectives conflict, prioritizing them allows for a principled way to make tradeoffs, approximating the behavior of an optimal policy and ensuring that more important goals are addressed.

Key Results

The paper presents a framework that, under certain assumptions (goal-oriented problems, pseudo-deterministic actions), allows for the generation of approximately optimal policies for complex MDPs by solving smaller, abstract MDPs. The proposed merging techniques, both value function-based and LCP-based, demonstrate how to combine these abstract solutions. The LCP-based merging, in particular, shows how to incorporate commitments from higher-priority objectives to guide the merging process for lower-priority ones, potentially leading to more efficient planning and policy construction. The paper illustrates these concepts with examples, showing how merging can lead to different action sequences than those dictated by individual abstract policies.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future research directions:

  • Assumptions: The current framework relies on assumptions like goal-oriented problems and pseudo-deterministic actions. Future work aims to relax these restrictions, particularly by developing more general least-commitment, causal link representations of complete policies.
  • Generalization: Extending the approach to handle more general decision-theoretic considerations, classical planning utilities, and deriving intentions from objective functions is a key area for future exploration.
  • Error Bounding: Developing methods for bounding the error associated with prioritized merging is important for understanding the quality of the generated policies.
  • Alternative Merging Strategies: Exploring other means of merging and further leveraging the LCP approach for more complex scenarios is also suggested.
  • Dynamic Prioritization: The current prioritization is static. Investigating dynamic prioritization schemes could offer more adaptability.

Summary updated

Abstract

We describe an approach to goal decomposition for a certain class of Markov decision processes (MDPs). An abstraction mechanism is used to generate abstract MDPs associated with different objectives, and several methods for merging the policies for these different objectives are considered. In one t echnique, causal (least-commitment) structures are generated for
BibTeX
@inproceedings{1997prioritized,
  title = {{Prioritized Goal Decomposition of Markov Decision Processes: Toward a Synthesis of Classical and Decision Theoretic Planning}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1997},
}
Figure