Primary User Localization and Its Error Analysis in 5G Cognitive Radio Networks

Nasir Saeed, Haewoon Nam, Tareq Y. Al-Naffouri, Mohamed-Slim Alouini

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for locating primary users (PUs) in cognitive radio networks (CRNs) by leveraging the directional capabilities of secondary user (SU) antennas. By analyzing received signal strength (RSS) across different antenna sectors and employing a scoring strategy, the proposed method significantly improves localization accuracy compared to traditional centroid localization, especially in dynamic CRN environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cognitive radio networks (CRNs) aim to efficiently utilize the radio spectrum by allowing secondary users (SUs) to access licensed spectrum when primary users (PUs) are inactive. To avoid interfering with PUs, SUs need to accurately sense and, crucially, locate PUs. However, PUs do not cooperate with SUs, making localization challenging. Existing methods like Centroid Localization (CL) and Multidimensional Scaling (MDS) often assume omnidirectional communication, which is becoming less relevant with the advent of technologies like 5G that utilize directional antennas. This paper addresses the gap in PU localization techniques that can effectively utilize the directional antenna capabilities of SUs in CRNs.

Methods

The proposed method enhances PU localization by incorporating directional antennas at the SUs. Instead of treating received signals as coming from any direction, each SU uses its M-sector antennas to measure the received signal strength (RSS) within specific angular sectors. The core of the method involves:

  1. Sectorized RSS Measurement: SUs measure RSS across their directional antenna sectors.
  2. Grid-Based Scoring: The deployment area is divided into a grid. For each grid point, SUs assign a score based on the RSS received in sectors that could potentially detect the PU. Two different scoring functions are proposed to weigh these measurements.
  3. Aggregation and Estimation: The scores from multiple SUs are aggregated, and grid points with the highest scores are identified.
  4. Grid-Based Centroid Localization: A final localization estimate is derived using a weighted centroid approach on the selected high-scoring grid points.

The paper also provides a theoretical analysis of the localization error using the moment generating function (MGF) and derives an expression for the mean square error (MSE).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation is based on extensive simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Directional Antennas are Key: The paper strongly advocates for the utilization of directional antennas in SUs for improved PU localization. This moves beyond the traditional assumption of omnidirectional communication.
  • Sector-Based Scoring is Effective: Analyzing RSS across specific sectors, rather than an aggregate omnidirectional measurement, allows for more precise localization by focusing on the most relevant signal paths.
  • Robustness to Scenarios: The proposed method demonstrates robustness to variations in PU location, path-loss exponents, and shadowing effects, outperforming conventional CL, which is particularly sensitive to PU location (e.g., edge vs. center).
  • Trade-off between Accuracy and Complexity: While smaller grid sizes and narrower sector beamwidths improve accuracy, they also increase computational complexity, highlighting a practical design consideration.

Key Results

  • Significant Accuracy Improvement: The proposed method shows a substantial improvement in localization accuracy (measured by RMSE) compared to conventional Centroid Localization (CL).
  • Impact of SU Count: Increasing the number of SUs generally improves localization accuracy up to a point, as more measurements become available.
  • Sector Beamwidth Matters: Reducing the sector beamwidth of SU antennas leads to better localization accuracy. Conversely, wider beamwidths degrade performance.
  • Robustness to PU Location: The proposed method is less affected by the PU's position within the network compared to CL, which suffers significantly when the PU is at the edge.
  • Shadowing and Path-Loss: The proposed method is more robust to shadowing effects than CL. The impact of path-loss exponent is also analyzed, showing higher RMSE for CL with smaller exponents.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While not explicitly detailed as a limitation, the paper notes that reducing grid size to improve accuracy can significantly increase network complexity.
  • Scoring Functions: Two scoring functions are proposed, but further exploration of optimal scoring strategies could be a future direction.
  • Real-world Validation: The study is based on simulations. Future work could involve experimental validation in real-world CRN testbeds.
  • Dynamic Environments: While shown to be robust to some variations, further investigation into localization in highly dynamic or rapidly changing CRN environments could be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

It is crucial to estimate the location of primary users (PUs) for the development of cognitive radio networks (CRNs). Great efforts have been made in the past to develop localization algorithms with better accuracy but low computation. In CRNs, PUs do not cooperate with secondary users (SUs), which makes the localization task challenging. Due to this feature, received signal strength (RSS)-based PU localization techniques, such as centroid localization (CL) and multidimensional scaling (MDS), are the best candidates. However, most of the CL- and MDS-based PU localization methods consider omnidirectional wireless communication. Therefore, in this paper we propose a PU localization method which uses the RSS values at different sectors of the SU antenna, where a scoring strategy is applied to all the sectors to estimate the PU location. Two different scoring functions are proposed. Numerical results show that the proposed localization method is robust to PU locations and channel conditions. The proposed method is validated in terms of various network parameters, such as the number of SUs, beamwidth of the SU sectors, size of the grid, and placement of the PUs. Results show that increasing the number of SUs improve the localization accuracy due to an increased number of measurements. However, the localization accuracy degrades with an increase in the beamwidth of the SU sector because the faraway grid points also participate in the localization. The results are also compared with the conventional CL for PU localization. Compared with conventional CL, it offers a significant improvement in the performance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{saeed2019primary,
  author = {Nasir Saeed and Haewoon Nam and Tareq Y. Al-Naffouri and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Primary User Localization and Its Error Analysis in 5G Cognitive Radio Networks}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=BTABES48Gj},
}
Figure