Primary Open Angle Glaucoma Is Associated With Functional Brain Network Reorganization

Silvia Minosse, Francesco Garaci, Alessio Martucci, S. Lanzafame, Francesca Di Giuliano, Eliseo Picchi, Massimo Cesareo, Raffaele Mancino, Maria Guerrisi, Chiara Adriana Pistolese, Roberto Floris, Carlo Nucci, Nicola ToschiFrontiers in Neurology 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Background: Resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (rs-fMRI) is commonly employed to study changes in functional brain connectivity. The recent hypothesis of a brain involvement in primary open angle Glaucoma has sprung interest for neuroimaging studies in this classically ophthalmological pathology. Object: We explored a putative reorganization of functional brain networks in Glaucomatous patients, and evaluated the potential of functional network disruption indices as biomarkers of disease severity in terms of their relationship to clinical variables as well as select retinal layer thicknesses. Methods: Nineteen Glaucoma patients and 16 healthy control subjects (age: 50-76, mean 61.0 ± 8.2 years) underwent rs-fMRI examination at 3T. After preprocessing, rs-fMRI time series were parcellated into 116 regions using the Automated Anatomical Labeling atlas and adjacency matrices were computed based on partial correlations. Graph-theoretical measures of integration, segregation and centrality as well as group-wise and subject-wise disruption index estimates were then generated for all subjects. All subjects also underwent Optical Coherence Tomography (OCT) and visual field index (VFI) quantification. We then examined associations between brain network measures and VFI, as well as thickness of retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) and macular ganglion cell layer (MaculaGCL). Results: In Glaucoma, group-wise disruption indices were negative for all graph theoretical metrics. Also, we found statistically significant group-wise differences in subject-wise disruption indexes in all local metrics. Two brain regions serving as hubs in healthy controls were not present in the Glaucoma group. Instead, three hub regions were present in Glaucoma patients but not in controls. We found significant associations between all disruption indices and VFI, RNFL as well as MaculaGCL. The disruption index based on the clustering coefficient yielded the best discriminative power for differentiating Glaucoma patients from healthy controls [Area Under the ROC curve (AUC) 0.91, sensitivity, 100%; specificity, 78.95%]. Conclusions: Our findings support a possible relationship between functional brain changes and disease severity in Glaucoma, as well as alternative explanations for motor and cognitive symptoms in Glaucoma, possibly pointing toward an inclusion of this pathology in the heterogeneous group of disconnection syndromes.

Introduction

Primary Open Angle Glaucoma (POAG) is a leading cause of irreversible blindness worldwide. Traditionally, it has been viewed as an ophthalmological condition characterized by the progressive death of retinal ganglion cells and subsequent optic nerve degeneration. However, a growing body of evidence suggests that POAG may be a complex neurodegenerative disease involving the central nervous system, sharing features with conditions like Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s diseases.

While structural changes such as gray matter atrophy have been documented in glaucoma patients, the functional implications—specifically how the brain's "connectome" reorganizes—remain poorly understood. This study aims to quantify these functional network changes using graph theory and explore their potential as biomarkers for disease severity, correlating brain metrics with established clinical markers of vision loss.

Methods and Materials

The study involved 19 POAG patients and 16 age-matched healthy controls who underwent resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (rs-fMRI) at 3T. The analytical pipeline followed several key steps to transform raw imaging data into quantifiable network metrics.

Methodological pipeline for brain network analysis in glaucoma patients.

The brain was parcellated into 116 regions using the Automated Anatomical Labeling (AAL) atlas. Functional connectivity between these regions was estimated using partial correlations of the BOLD signal time series, resulting in an adjacency matrix for each subject. From these matrices, graph-theoretical metrics were calculated, including integration (global efficiency), segregation (clustering coefficient, transitivity), and centrality (degree, betweenness).

A novel "Disruption Index" ($k$) was employed to quantify how an individual's network topology deviates from a healthy reference group. A negative $k$ value indicates a "flattening" of the network hierarchy, where highly connected regions lose connectivity and less-connected regions gain it. Finally, these brain metrics were compared against clinical data, including the Visual Field Index (VFI) and retinal layer thicknesses measured via Optical Coherence Tomography (OCT).

Results

The analysis revealed profound whole-brain functional reorganization in glaucoma patients. Group-wise disruption indices were significantly negative across all graph-theoretical metrics ($p < 0.001$), indicating a consistent pattern of network decay and reorganization far beyond the visual pathways.

Visualization of global and local metrics through graph theoretical analysis.

Key findings included:

  • Hub Plasticity: The brain's most highly connected regions, or "hubs," shifted significantly. Two hubs present in healthy controls (the right angular gyrus and a cerebellar lobule) were absent in patients. Conversely, three new hubs emerged in the glaucoma group, including the right inferior occipital cortex and the left cerebellar lobule IX.
  • Cerebellar Involvement: Significant changes were observed in the cerebellum, suggesting that glaucoma may impact areas involved in fine motor coordination and visual guidance, which could explain non-visual symptoms like balance issues.
  • Diagnostic Accuracy: The disruption index based on the clustering coefficient demonstrated exceptional discriminative power, identifying glaucoma patients with an AUC of 0.91 (100% sensitivity and 78.95% specificity).
  • Clinical Correlation: Strong positive associations were found between brain network disruption and clinical markers such as RNFL thickness and VFI, suggesting that brain and eye degeneration occur in tandem.

Discussion and Conclusion

The findings support the hypothesis that POAG involves significant central nervous system reorganization, potentially classifying it among "disconnection syndromes." The strong correlation between brain network metrics and retinal degeneration suggests that these functional changes are closely tied to disease progression.

However, several limitations must be considered. The sample size (n=35) is relatively small, necessitating validation in larger cohorts. Furthermore, the cross-sectional nature of the study prevents determining whether these brain changes are a primary neurodegenerative process or a secondary effect of visual deprivation. Future longitudinal studies are required to clarify these causal relationships and to explore the impact of glaucoma medications on brain dynamics. In conclusion, functional brain network metrics, particularly the disruption index, offer a promising new avenue for monitoring disease severity and understanding the systemic impact of glaucoma.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background:</b> Resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (rs-fMRI) is commonly employed to study changes in functional brain connectivity. The recent hypothesis of a brain involvement in primary open angle Glaucoma has sprung interest for neuroimaging studies in this classically ophthalmological pathology. <b>Object:</b> We explored a putative reorganization of functional brain networks in Glaucomatous patients, and evaluated the potential of functional network disruption indices as biomarkers of disease severity in terms of their relationship to clinical variables as well as select retinal layer thicknesses. <b>Methods:</b> Nineteen Glaucoma patients and 16 healthy control subjects (age: 50-76, mean 61.0 ± 8.2 years) underwent rs-fMRI examination at 3T. After preprocessing, rs-fMRI time series were parcellated into 116 regions using the Automated Anatomical Labeling atlas and adjacency matrices were computed based on partial correlations. Graph-theoretical measures of integration, segregation and centrality as well as group-wise and subject-wise disruption index estimates (which use regression of graph-theoretical metrics across subjects to quantify overall network changes) were then generated for all subjects. All subjects also underwent Optical Coherence Tomography (OCT) and visual field index (VFI) quantification. We then examined associations between brain network measures and VFI, as well as thickness of retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) and macular ganglion cell layer (MaculaGCL). <b>Results:</b> In Glaucoma, group-wise disruption indices were negative for all graph theoretical metrics. Also, we found statistically significant group-wise differences in subject-wise disruption indexes in all local metrics. Two brain regions serving as hubs in healthy controls were not present in the Glaucoma group. Instead, three hub regions were present in Glaucoma patients but not in controls. We found significant associations between all disruption indices and VFI, RNFL as well as MaculaGCL. The disruption index based on the clustering coefficient yielded the best discriminative power for differentiating Glaucoma patients from healthy controls [Area Under the ROC curve (AUC) 0.91, sensitivity, 100%; specificity, 78.95%]. <b>Conclusions:</b> Our findings support a possible relationship between functional brain changes and disease severity in Glaucoma, as well as alternative explanations for motor and cognitive symptoms in Glaucoma, possibly pointing toward an inclusion of this pathology in the heterogeneous group of disconnection syndromes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{minosse2019primary,
  author = {Silvia Minosse and Francesco Garaci and Alessio Martucci and S. Lanzafame and Francesca Di Giuliano and Eliseo Picchi and Massimo Cesareo and Raffaele Mancino and Maria Guerrisi and Chiara Adriana Pistolese and Roberto Floris and Carlo Nucci and Nicola Toschi},
  title = {{Primary Open Angle Glaucoma Is Associated With Functional Brain Network Reorganization}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neurology},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fneur.2019.01134},
}
Figure