Price Suggestion for Online Second-hand Items with Texts and Images

Liang Han, Zhaozheng Yin, Zhurong Xia, Minqian Tang, Rong Jin

Introduction

Setting the right price for a used item is a significant hurdle for sellers in the second-hand economy. Unlike new products with fixed MSRPs, the value of pre-owned goods is highly variable, influenced by wear and tear, technical specifications, and the quality of the listing itself. Overpricing leads to unsold inventory, while underpricing results in lost revenue. To address this, researchers from Stony Brook University and Alibaba Group developed an intelligent, multi-modal system to automate price suggestions on platforms like Xianyu.

The Challenges of Second-hand Pricing

Automated pricing in this domain faces three primary obstacles:

  1. Data Quality: Listings often contain blurry photos or vague, non-standard text descriptions.
  2. Feature Modality: The importance of text versus images varies by category (e.g., specs matter for laptops, while condition/aesthetics matter for fashion).
  3. Ground Truth Ambiguity: There is no single "correct" price; sold prices represent a lower bound of acceptance, while unsold prices often represent an unrealistic upper bound.

Methodology: A Multi-modal "Gatekeeper" System

The proposed architecture integrates visual, textual, and statistical features to provide robust price estimates.

Overview of the multi-modal price suggestion system architecture.

System Architecture

The system employs a pre-trained CNN for image feature extraction and an LSTM-based model for text embeddings. A key innovation is the attention mechanism, which dynamically weighs the importance of visual vs. textual information based on the item category. Additionally, the model incorporates statistical features like category-wide price quartiles.

Joint Optimization and Filtering

Rather than predicting a price for every listing, the system includes a "gatekeeper" classification model. This component determines if a listing is "qualified" for a suggestion based on feature predictability. Two constraints were tested:

  • Percentile Constraint: Forcing the model to label the top $X$% of most predictable items as qualified.
  • Threshold Constraint: Qualifying items only if the predicted error falls below a specific limit.

Customized Loss Function

The researchers moved beyond standard Mean Squared Error (MSE) to a loss function targeting a price range. For sold items, the target is between the actual sold price and a small markup. For unsold items, the goal is to suggest a price lower than the current listing to facilitate a sale.

Key Insights and Data Processing

A critical finding was the "long-tail" distribution of second-hand prices. Most items are low-cost, with a few very expensive outliers.

Distribution of sold prices before and after logarithmic transformation.

By applying a logarithmic transformation to the prices (as seen in the figure above), the researchers converted the skewed distribution into a Gaussian-like curve, making it significantly easier for the neural network to learn and predict accurately.

Another major insight was that text often outweighs images in predictive power. Detailed specifications in text provide more concrete value indicators than photos, which can be ambiguous or low-quality.

Experimental Results

The system was trained and tested on a massive dataset of over 5 million items from Alibaba's Xianyu platform.

  • Accuracy: The joint optimization approach yielded an 8% improvement in prediction accuracy over baseline models.
  • Modality Synergy: The full multi-modal model (Image + Text + Attention) significantly outperformed single-modality versions. Removing text features caused a much larger drop in performance than removing images.
  • Filtering Effectiveness: The classifier successfully separated "signal from noise." Under a 60% percentile constraint, the error for qualified items was 0.15, compared to 0.41 for unqualified ones.

Conclusion

By combining multi-modal feature extraction with a selective "gatekeeper" strategy, this research provides a scalable solution for the second-hand market. The system not only improves price accuracy but also builds platform trust by withholding suggestions for low-quality listings. Future work may focus on integrating temporal market trends and seller reputation to further refine predictions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{han2020price,
  author = {Liang Han and Zhaozheng Yin and Zhurong Xia and Minqian Tang and Rong Jin},
  title = {{Price Suggestion for Online Second-hand Items with Texts and Images}},
  booktitle = {ACM Multimedia},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=VUGGrNLzwKN},
}
Figure