Prevalence of sustainable and unsustainable use of wild species inferred from the IUCN Red List

S. Marsh, Michael Hoffmann, Neil Burgess, Thomas M. Brooks, Daniel W. S. Challender, Patricia J. Cremona, Craig Hilton‐Taylor, Flore Lafaye de Micheaux, Gabriela Lichtenstein, Dilys Roe, Monika BöhmbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages the IUCN Red List to quantify the global prevalence of both sustainable and unsustainable use of wild species. It reveals that while a significant portion of species face extinction risk due to exploitation, a larger proportion are used sustainably, highlighting the potential for well-managed resource use to support conservation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The use of wild species is a double-edged sword: it's a critical resource for billions of people, supporting livelihoods and cultural practices, yet it's also a major driver of biodiversity loss. Historically, research has heavily focused on the negative impacts of unsustainable exploitation. However, there's been a significant knowledge gap regarding the prevalence of sustainable use and how to effectively distinguish it from unsustainable practices. This paper aims to bridge that gap by using existing data to infer the current status of both sustainable and unsustainable use across a broad range of species.

Methods

The researchers analyzed species-level data from the IUCN Red List, focusing on 13 comprehensively assessed taxonomic groups. They extracted information on:

  • Species Use: Identifying which species are documented as being used for various purposes (e.g., food, pets, medicine, materials).
  • Threats: Specifically looking for "biological resource use" as a documented threat to species.
  • Conservation Status: Utilizing Red List categories (Least Concern, Near Threatened, Threatened).
  • Population Trends: Assessing whether populations are stable, declining, or increasing.
  • Conservation Actions: Examining if management actions are in place to address use-related threats.

To determine "unsustainable use," they defined it as use that likely has an adverse impact on a species' extinction risk. They developed a decision-tree to differentiate direct, intentional use from other threat types and presented results as a range (minimum to maximum) to account for uncertainties in data. For "sustainable use," they identified species that are Least Concern and have stable or increasing population trends, or threatened/Near Threatened species not facing use as a major threat and with stable/increasing trends.

Datasets

The primary dataset used was the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species (version 2020-1). This included data for 30,923 species across 13 taxonomic groups. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Widespread Use, Not Always Unsustainable: A substantial 40% of analyzed species are documented as being used, but crucially, a majority of these (72%) are categorized as Least Concern and many have stable or improving populations. This suggests that use doesn't automatically equate to a threat.
  • Distinguishing Sustainable Use is Crucial: The study highlights that simply documenting "use" isn't enough. Understanding the impact of that use on extinction risk is key to differentiating sustainable from unsustainable practices.
  • Data Gaps Hinder Comprehensive Analysis: While the Red List is a powerful tool, the consistency of data on "use and trade" and "conservation actions" varies, particularly for non-threatened species. This limits the ability to fully assess the extent of use and the effectiveness of management.
  • Aquatic Species Face Higher Risk: Aquatic taxa appear to be disproportionately affected by unsustainable biological resource use compared to terrestrial taxa.

Key Results

  • Prevalence of Use: 40% of species (10,098 out of 25,009) across 10 data-sufficient taxonomic groups are documented as being used.
  • Unsustainable Use:
    • Intentional use is a threat to 16% of all used species (1,597-1,631 out of 10,098).
  • Over a quarter of threatened or Near Threatened species (2,752-2,848 out of 9,753) face elevated extinction risk due to intentional use.
  • Sustainable Use:
    • 72% of used species (7,291 out of 10,098) are Least Concern, with nearly half (3,469) having stable or improving populations.
  • 172 threatened or NT species with stable/improving populations are not documented as threatened by biological resource use.
  • Conservation Actions: Around a third of species with documented use as a threat do not currently receive targeted management actions. Aquatic species are more likely to lack conservation management for use-related threats (34%) compared to terrestrial species (9%).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Consistency: The study acknowledges that the recording of "use and trade" and "conservation actions" is often recommended rather than mandatory, leading to inconsistencies and potential underestimation of use and management. This is particularly true for non-threatened species.
  • Scope of Use: The analysis focuses on direct and intentional forms of biological resource use. Indirect impacts like deforestation from logging or by-catch in fisheries were only partially included.
  • Taxonomic Representation: The analysis was limited to 13 comprehensively assessed taxonomic groups, and the inclusion of certain families/orders within broader classes might inflate estimates of use for those groups.
  • Data Age: 12% of the assessed species had assessments older than 10 years, meaning their extinction risk and supporting information might be outdated.

The authors propose several recommendations to improve data quality for future analyses, including modifying the Threats Classification Scheme to better capture motivation for use, making threat documentation more consistent across all threat levels, and adding a check-box to indicate the completeness of classification scheme filling. They emphasize the need for more effort in understanding the factors determining sustainable use and the effectiveness of mitigation actions, suggesting the combination of Red List data with national and regional datasets for a more complete picture.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Unsustainable exploitation of wild species represents a serious threat to biodiversity and to the livelihoods of local communities and indigenous peoples. However, managed, sustainable use has the potential to forestall extinctions, aid recovery, and meet human needs. Research to date has focused on unsustainable biological resource use with little consideration of sustainable use; we infer the current prevalence of both. We analyzed species-level data for 30,923 species from 13 taxonomic groups on the IUCN Red List. Our results demonstrate the broad taxonomic prevalence of use, with 40% of species (10,098 of 25,009 species from 10 data-sufficient taxonomic groups) documented as being used. The main purposes of use are pets, display animals and horticulture, and human consumption. Use often has an adverse impact on species extinction risk (we define this as biologically unsustainable): intentional use is currently contributing to elevated extinction risk for over a quarter of all threatened or Near Threatened (NT) species (2,752 – 2,848 of 9,753 species). Intentional use also threatens 16% of all species used (1,597 – 1,631 of 10,098). However, 72% of species that are used (7,291 of 10,098) are Least Concern (LC), of which nearly half (3,469) also have stable or improving population trends. The remainder of used species are not documented as threatened by biological resource use, including 172 threatened or NT species with stable or improving populations. Around a third of species that have use documented as a threat do not currently receive targeted species management actions to directly address this threat. We offer suggestions for improving use-related Red List data. Our findings on the prevalence of sustainable and unsustainable use, and variation across taxa, can inform international policymaking, including the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services, the Convention on Biological Diversity, and the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species.
BibTeX
@misc{marsh2020prevalence,
  author = {S. Marsh and Michael Hoffmann and Neil Burgess and Thomas M. Brooks and Daniel W. S. Challender and Patricia J. Cremona and Craig Hilton‐Taylor and Flore Lafaye de Micheaux and Gabriela Lichtenstein and Dilys Roe and Monika Böhm},
  title = {{Prevalence of sustainable and unsustainable use of wild species inferred from the IUCN Red List}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.11.04.367763},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure