Prevalence of Deliberate Self-harm Among Chinese Patients With Heroin Dependence: A Meta-Analysis

Bao‐Liang Zhong, Yan‐Min Xu, Wuxiang Xie, Wen-Cai Chen, Jin LüFrontiers in Psychiatry 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Background: There is a paucity of data regarding the prevalence and methods of deliberate self-harm (DSH) in patients with heroin dependence in international literature. In China, studies investigating DSH in heroin-dependent patients (HDPs) have yielded widely varying rates. This meta-analysis aims to assess the prevalence of DSH among Chinese HDPs. Methods: Relevant studies were retrieved from major Chinese (CNKI, Wanfang, SinoMed) and Western databases (PubMed, EMBASE, PsycInfo). Two authors independently identified eligible studies. Quality was assessed based on representative sampling and reliable DSH ascertainment. Statistical analysis used a random-effects model. Results: Fifteen eligible studies involving 37,243 Chinese HDPs were included. The pooled prevalence of DSH was 4.4% (95% CI: 2.9, 6.2%), with significant heterogeneity ($I^2 = 98%$). High-quality studies reported a significantly higher prevalence (13.2%) compared to low-quality studies (3.4%). Swallowing foreign objects was the most common method (2.7%). Conclusion: While the reported prevalence is relatively low due to methodological limitations, the methods used are often dangerous. Restricting access to DSH methods in detoxification settings is recommended.

Introduction

Heroin remains a significant drug of abuse in China, where the standard intervention often involves compulsory detoxification. Deliberate self-harm (DSH)—defined as the intentional, direct destruction of body tissue without suicidal intent—is a known risk factor among substance users. However, existing data on Chinese heroin-dependent patients (HDPs) has been inconsistent, with reported prevalence rates ranging from as low as 1.1% to as high as 17.7%.

This meta-analysis was conducted to resolve these ambiguities, providing a comprehensive estimate of DSH prevalence and identifying the specific methods employed by this population. Understanding these patterns is essential for improving clinical management and ensuring safety within detoxification facilities.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis following PRISMA and MOOSE guidelines. The search strategy involved querying three major Chinese databases (CNKI, Wanfang, SinoMed) and three Western databases (PubMed, EMBASE, PsycInfo) for studies published through March 2018.

Figure 1: Flowchart of study inclusion process.

Studies were categorized by quality: "high quality" studies utilized representative samples (n > 100), achieved high response rates (> 70%), and employed reliable assessment tools such as clinical interviews. "Low quality" studies typically relied on retrospective medical record reviews. Due to high heterogeneity ($I^2 = 98%$), a random-effects model was used to pool prevalence rates.

Results

The final analysis synthesized data from 15 eligible studies, all published in Chinese, encompassing a total of 37,243 HDPs. Nearly all studies (14 of 15) were conducted in compulsory detoxification settings. The samples were predominantly male (approximately 75–85%) with a mean age in the early 30s.

Figure 2: Forest plot showing the pooled prevalence of DSH among Chinese HDPs.

The pooled prevalence of DSH across all studies was 4.4% (95% CI: 2.9–6.2%). However, a significant "detection gap" was observed based on study quality. Studies relying on medical records (low quality) reported a 3.4% prevalence, whereas those using clinical interviews and physical examinations (high quality) reported a much higher rate of 13.2%.

Regarding the methods of self-harm, swallowing foreign objects (such as glass, nails, keys, or lighters) was the most prevalent, with a combined prevalence of 2.7%. Other methods included cutting (0.9%), hitting oneself (0.5%), and burning (0.4%).

Discussion

The findings highlight a critical methodological underestimate in existing literature. The discrepancy between medical record data and clinical interview data suggests that official records often only capture the most severe cases requiring immediate medical intervention, missing a significant portion of DSH incidents.

The DSH profile of Chinese HDPs is unique compared to the general population. While "cutting" is typically the most common form of DSH globally, swallowing foreign objects accounts for over 61% of incidents in this cohort. This method is particularly dangerous; prognostic analysis indicates that nearly 80% of HDPs who swallowed sharp objects required surgical intervention, with some cases leading to fatal outcomes.

The use of "extreme" methods—such as cutting off fingers or jumping from heights—suggests a high level of psychological and physical distress. In compulsory settings, such acts may represent a desperate attempt to be transferred to a hospital or released for medical treatment, or a maladaptive coping mechanism for withdrawal symptoms. Additionally, the analysis revealed a temporal trend: DSH prevalence was higher in studies conducted before 2000, potentially indicating improvements in clinical management over the last two decades.

Conclusion and Limitations

While the overall prevalence of DSH among Chinese HDPs in detoxification settings appears relatively low at 4.4%, high-quality assessments suggest the true rate is likely three times higher. Furthermore, the high lethality of the methods used poses a significant challenge for facility management.

Limitations of this study include the retrospective nature of most included data, which introduces bias, and the homogeneity of the settings (mostly compulsory centers), which may limit generalizability to voluntary clinics or community settings. Future efforts should focus on implementing standardized DSH screening tools and stricter environmental controls to limit access to dangerous objects within detoxification facilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background:</b> There is paucity of data regarding the prevalence and methods of deliberate self-harm (DSH) in patients with heroin dependence in international literature. In China, there have been a few studies investigating the prevalence of DSH in heroin-dependent patients (HDPs), but their rates varied widely. We thus conducted a meta-analysis of studies assessing the prevalence of DSH among Chinese HDPs. <b>Methods:</b> Relevant studies were retrieved from major Chinese databases (China National Knowledge Infrastructure, Wanfang data, and SinoMed) and western databases (PubMed, EMBASE, and PsycInfo). Two authors independently identified eligible studies and extracted data. Studies that included a representative sample of Chinese HDPs and ascertained DSH caseness in a reliable way were considered as high quality. Statistical analysis was performed using R software. <b>Results:</b> In total, 15 eligible studies with a total of 37,243 Chinese HDPs were included. All included studies were conducted in heroin detoxification settings. Only two studies were rated as high quality. The pooled prevalence of DSH in Chinese HDPs was 4.4% (95%CI: 2.9, 6.2%), but the heterogeneity of prevalence rates across studies was significant (<i>I</i><sup>2</sup> = 98%, <i>P</i> < 0.001). Studies rated as high quality had significantly higher prevalence of DSH than those rated as low quality (13.2 vs. 3.4%, <i>P</i> < 0.001). Swallowing foreign objects was the most common method of DSH, with a combined prevalence of 2.7% (95%CI: 1.6, 4.4%). Extreme DSH methods such as cutting off fingers and jumping from height were also not uncommon in this patient population. <b>Conclusion:</b> Due to methodological problems in available studies, we find a relatively low prevalence of DSH among Chinese HDPs receiving detoxification treatment. Nevertheless, the self-harmers of Chinese HDPs are more likely to harm themselves in a dangerous or life-threatening way. Restricting the availability of DSH methods may be an effective way to prevent or reduce DSH in China's detoxification treatment settings.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhong2018prevalence,
  author = {Bao‐Liang Zhong and Yan‐Min Xu and Wuxiang Xie and Wen-Cai Chen and Jin Lü},
  title = {{Prevalence of Deliberate Self-harm Among Chinese Patients With Heroin Dependence: A Meta-Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychiatry},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyt.2018.00325},
}
Figure