Preterm birth alters the development of cortical microstructure and morphology at term-equivalent age

Ralica Dimitrova, Maximilian Pietsch, Judit Ciarrusta, Sean P. Fitzgibbon, Logan Z. J. Williams, Daan Christiaens, Lucilio Cordero‐Grande, Dafnis Batallé, Antonios Makropoulos, Andreas Schuh, Anthony N. Price, Jana Hutter, Rui Pedro A. G. Teixeira, Emer Hughes, Andrew Chew, Shona Falconer, Olivia Carney, Alexia Egloff, Jacques‐Donald Tournier, Gráinne McAlonan, Mary Rutherford, Serena J. Counsell, Emma C. Robinson, Joseph V. Hajnal, Daniel Rueckert, A. David Edwards, Jonathan O’Muircheartaigh

TL;DR

Preterm birth significantly alters the developing brain's cortical structure and microstructure by term-equivalent age, leading to a more "immature" state compared to full-term infants. While these deviations are widespread, they are highly variable across individual preterm infants and are associated with gestational age at birth, but not with later neurodevelopmental outcomes at 18 months.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The period of late gestation and early infancy is a critical window for rapid brain development, making the developing cortex particularly vulnerable to disruptions. Preterm birth, an abrupt interruption to this process, is a known risk factor for adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes. While white matter injury has been a focus, the impact of preterm birth on cortical development (both its structure and the microscopic organization of its tissue) is increasingly recognized as a significant contributor to cognitive deficits. However, a comprehensive understanding of how preterm birth alters typical cortical maturation, especially in comparison to a large normative dataset, and the extent of individual variability, has been lacking. This paper aims to fill this gap by characterizing the typical development of cortical microstructure and morphology in term-born infants and then detailing how preterm birth impacts these trajectories at term-equivalent age.

Methods

The study employed advanced neuroimaging techniques, specifically in vivo structural and diffusion Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), to capture detailed information about the developing brain.

  • Normative Modeling: A large cohort of term-born infants (n=259) was scanned to establish normative trajectories of cortical development. A Gaussian Process Regression (GPR) model was trained on this data to predict various cortical features (like fractional anisotropy, mean diffusivity, neurite density, cortical thickness, surface area, curvature, and sulcation) based on postmenstrual age (PMA) at scan and sex. This GPR model not only provides a prediction but also quantifies the uncertainty around that prediction, allowing for the calculation of Z-scores for individual infants relative to the normative curve.
  • Preterm Infant Analysis: A separate group of preterm infants (n=76) was scanned at term-equivalent age (TEA). Their MRI data was then analyzed using the established GPR model to assess deviations from the normative development. Extreme deviations were defined as Z-scores exceeding |3.1|.
  • Statistical Analysis: Group-level differences between preterm and term infants were assessed. The study also examined the spatial overlap of extreme deviations across individuals and investigated the association between these deviations, gestational age at birth, and neurodevelopmental outcomes at 18 months using statistical methods like Permutation Analysis of Linear Models (PALM) and Kendall's tau correlation.

Datasets

  • Developing Human Connectome Project (dHCP) Neonatal Dataset: This study utilized data from the dHCP, a large-scale project that collected MRI data from healthy term-born infants. The term-born sample in this study consisted of 259 infants.
  • Preterm Infant Cohort: A cohort of 76 preterm infants was recruited and scanned at term-equivalent age.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Preterm Brain is "Immature" at Term-Equivalent Age: The study provides strong evidence that preterm infants, on average, exhibit a more immature cortical development at term-equivalent age compared to their full-term peers. This immaturity is characterized by increased tissue water content and reduced neurite density in posterior cortical regions, and greater cortical thickness anteriorly.
  • High Individual Variability is the Norm: A crucial finding is the significant heterogeneity in cortical development among preterm infants. While group-level analyses reveal average differences, the study highlights that extreme deviations from normative development are highly variable in their location and presentation across individuals. This suggests that simply categorizing infants as "preterm" masks a complex spectrum of developmental trajectories.
  • Gestational Age Matters, But Neurodevelopment Doesn't (at 18 months): The study found a clear association between gestational age at birth and deviations in cortical development. Infants born earlier showed more pronounced deviations. However, intriguingly, these cortical deviations at term-equivalent age did not correlate with neurodevelopmental outcomes at 18 months. This raises questions about the predictive power of early cortical microstructure for later cognitive function, or suggests that other factors (like white matter development or postnatal experiences) might play a more dominant role in determining long-term outcomes.
  • Surface Area vs. Thickness: The paper notes that while cortical thickness appears more affected by preterm birth, surface area development, which is governed by different cellular processes, showed less pronounced group-level differences. This hints at distinct developmental mechanisms being differentially impacted by prematurity.

Key Results

  • Group-Level Differences: Preterm infants showed higher mean diffusivity (MD) and lower neurite density index (fICVF) in posterior cortical regions. They also had higher fractional anisotropy (FA) and lower orientation dispersion index (ODI) in the insula, and greater cortical thickness in frontal, insular, and anterior parietal regions compared to term-born infants.
  • Extreme Deviations: Preterm infants were more likely to exhibit extreme deviations (Z > |3.1|) from normative development. These deviations were widespread across various metrics, including MD, fICVF, thickness, and sulcation.
  • Variability: For most cortical features, fewer than 8% of preterm infants showed extreme deviations in the same parcel, underscoring the high degree of individual variability.
  • Association with GA: Lower gestational age at birth was associated with increased MD and decreased fICVF in the parietal cortex, and increased FA and lower ODI in the insula.
  • No Association with Neurodevelopment: No significant associations were found between cortical deviations (Z-scores or atypicality indices) and Bayley III neurodevelopmental scores at 18 months.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Specificity of Diffusion Metrics: The authors acknowledge that diffusion MRI metrics like FA are sensitive to multiple underlying microstructural factors (dendritic/axonal density, orientation dispersion, partial volume contamination), making it challenging to attribute changes to a single biological process. While NODDI offers better specificity, it still has limitations.
  • Model Parameter Choices: The decision to fix certain parameters in the NODDI model, while consistent with previous studies, might introduce bias. Further work is needed to validate model parameter estimation and their biological accuracy in developing brains.
  • Image Registration Challenges: The rapid changes in neonatal brain morphology and tissue contrast make image registration and segmentation particularly challenging. While the study employed advanced surface-based methods to mitigate these issues, it remains a consideration.
  • Predictive Power of Cortical Development: The lack of association between early cortical deviations and later neurodevelopmental outcomes at 18 months is a significant finding that warrants further investigation. Future research could explore longer-term follow-up, investigate the interplay between white matter and cortical development, and examine other potential biomarkers for predicting neurodevelopmental trajectories in preterm infants. The authors suggest that while cortical development is altered, WM dysmaturation might have a stronger impact on later behavior.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Introduction The dynamic nature and complexity of the cellular events that take place during the last trimester of pregnancy make the developing cortex particularly vulnerable to perturbations. Abrupt interruption to normal gestation can lead to significant deviations to many of these processes, resulting in atypical trajectory of cortical maturation in preterm birth survivors. Methods We sought to first map typical cortical micro and macrostructure development using invivo MRI in a large sample of healthy term-born infants scanned after birth (n=270). Then we offer a comprehensive characterisation of the cortical consequences of preterm birth in 78 preterm infants scanned at term-equivalent age (37-44 weeks postmenstrual age). We describe the group-average atypicality, the heterogeneity across individual preterm infants, and relate individual deviations from normative development to age at birth and neurodevelopment at 18 months. Results In the term-born neonatal brain, we observed regionally specific age-associated changes in cortical morphology and microstructure, including rapid surface expansion, cortical thickness increase, reduction in cortical anisotropy and increase in neurite orientation dispersion. By term-equivalent age, preterm infants had on average increased cortical tissue water content and reduced neurite density index in the posterior parts of the cortex, and greater cortical thickness anteriorly compared to term-born infants. While individual preterm infants were more likely to show extreme deviations (over 3.1 standard deviations) from normative cortical maturation compared to term-born infants, these extreme deviations were highly variable and showed very little spatial overlap between individuals. Measures of regional cortical development were associated with age at birth, but not with neurodevelopment at 18 months. Conclusion We showed that preterm birth alters cortical micro and macrostructural maturation near the time of fullterm birth. Deviations from normative development were highly variable between individual preterm infants.
BibTeX
@article{dimitrova2021preterm,
  author = {Ralica Dimitrova and Maximilian Pietsch and Judit Ciarrusta and Sean P. Fitzgibbon and Logan Z. J. Williams and Daan Christiaens and Lucilio Cordero‐Grande and Dafnis Batallé and Antonios Makropoulos and Andreas Schuh and Anthony N. Price and Jana Hutter and Rui Pedro A. G. Teixeira and Emer Hughes and Andrew Chew and Shona Falconer and Olivia Carney and Alexia Egloff and Jacques‐Donald Tournier and Gráinne McAlonan and Mary Rutherford and Serena J. Counsell and Emma C. Robinson and Joseph V. Hajnal and Daniel Rueckert and A. David Edwards and Jonathan O’Muircheartaigh},
  title = {{Preterm birth alters the development of cortical microstructure and morphology at term-equivalent age}},
  journal = {NeuroImage},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1016/j.neuroimage.2021.118488},
}
Figure