TL;DR
This paper introduces and evaluates "Accessibility Learning Labs" (ALL), a set of five experiential learning modules designed to teach computing accessibility. The study found that these labs, particularly when incorporating empathy-building materials, significantly improve student motivation and understanding of accessibility principles compared to traditional methods.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Despite the significant portion of the population with disabilities, much of today's software remains inaccessible. This is often due to a lack of developer awareness and a shortage of readily available, easy-to-integrate educational materials for teaching accessibility in computing curricula. Instructors often want to cover accessibility but lack the resources to do so effectively. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a robust, experiential learning framework and materials that can be easily adopted by educators.
Methods
The authors developed five "Accessibility Learning Labs" (ALL) that follow an experiential learning structure. Each lab is web-based, requiring only a browser, and includes:
- Background Instructional Material: Explaining the accessibility topic, including lecture slides and videos.
- Activity: Students interact with an emulated accessibility challenge, experience the problem firsthand, and then repair it using a simulated IDE.
- Empathy-Creating Supplementary Material: Videos and testimonials from individuals with disabilities to foster understanding and motivation.
- Quiz: For instructor assessment.
To evaluate the effectiveness of these labs, a study was conducted with 276 students in introductory computing courses. Students were divided into three groups:
- Group A (Control): Used existing accessibility materials (Mozilla's resources).
- Group B: Used the ALL labs without the empathy-creating material.
- Group C: Used the ALL labs with the empathy-creating material.
Pre- and post-lab surveys measured student motivation and importance placed on accessibility, while quizzes assessed knowledge retention.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study used student participants from introductory computing courses at the authors' institution.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Experiential Learning is Key: The study strongly suggests that hands-on, experiential learning is more effective than traditional methods for teaching accessibility.
- Empathy is a Powerful Motivator: Incorporating "empathy-creating" materials (like student testimonials) significantly boosts student motivation and their perceived importance of accessibility.
- Accessibility Education is Under-Resourced: The paper highlights a critical need for accessible, ready-to-use teaching materials for computing instructors.
- Beyond Technical Skills: The research emphasizes that understanding why accessibility matters (through empathy) is as crucial as learning the technical solutions.
- Targeted Impact: Group C (with empathy materials) showed a unique ability to improve motivation for students starting with low interest, while Group A (control) risked decreasing motivation for highly interested students.
Key Results
- Motivation: Group C (ALL with empathy) showed a significantly greater positive impact on student motivation regarding accessibility compared to Group A (control). Group B (ALL without empathy) did not show a statistically significant impact.
- Informing Students: Both Group B and C were more effective than Group A in informing students about foundational accessibility principles, as measured by quiz scores. Group C showed a more universally positive effect than Group B.
- Empathy's Impact: The inclusion of empathy-creating materials (Group C vs. Group B) led to a statistically significant increase in students' perceived importance of creating accessible software.
- Student Background: The vast majority of students (91%) were first-year students, and 67% reported having no prior experience with software accessibility.
Limitations and Future Work
- Emulation Limitations: The authors acknowledge that while they worked with individuals with disabilities to ensure accurate emulation, no software can perfectly replicate the experience of a disability.
- Scope of Labs: The labs cover a "very small portion of possible accessibility issues" due to the vastness of the topic.
- Student Experience: The study primarily involved first-year students; future work should explore the impact on students with different experience levels and across K-12, undergraduate, and graduate levels.
- Comparison Group: The control group used only one set of existing materials; future work should compare against a wider range of resources.
- Group B's Lack of Impact: The reason why Group B (ALL without empathy) did not show a statistically significant impact on motivation warrants further investigation.
- Future Development: The authors plan to develop and evaluate additional labs for other accessibility topics and implement them in more courses and institutions.
Summary updated