Preliminary Validity and Acceptability of Motion Tape for Measuring Low Back Movement: Mixed Methods Study

Audrey Lee, Elijah Wyckoff, Emilia Farcas, Job Godino, Kevin Patrick, Spencer Spiegel, Rose Yu, Arun Kumar, Kenneth J Loh, Sara GombattoJMIR Rehabilitation and Assistive Technologies 2024 · OpenReview

Introduction

Low back pain (LBP) is a pervasive public health challenge, often leading to physical disability and significant economic burdens for both individuals and society. While physical therapy is a cornerstone of LBP management, clinicians currently lack objective tools to monitor patient posture and movement outside of clinical encounters. Standard 3D optical motion capture systems are highly accurate but expensive and confined to laboratories. Portable alternatives, such as Inertial Measurement Units (IMUs), are often rigid and struggle to account for the complex skin-strain dynamics of the human spine.

To bridge this gap, researchers developed "Motion Tape" (MT), a low-profile, wearable sensor. MT is created by spray-coating piezoresistive graphene nanocomposites directly onto commercial kinesiology tape. This "skin-like" sensor moves with the body, providing a disposable and comfortable method for tracking movement. This study evaluates the concurrent validity of MT against gold-standard motion capture and assesses its acceptability among users.

Methods

The study utilized a mixed-methods approach with 10 healthy participants (5 male, 5 female; average age 22.4). Participants were fitted with a 3x2 matrix of MT sensors on their low backs, alongside retroreflective markers for a 16-camera Qualisys 3D optical motion capture system. The protocol included movements in three planes: sagittal (flexion and extension), frontal (lateral bending), and axial (rotation).

Concurrent validity was assessed using cross-correlation coefficients at zero phase shift, comparing MT strain data with kinematic angles derived from a multi-segmental spine model. Following laboratory testing, semi-structured interviews were conducted and analyzed using Rapid Qualitative Analysis (RQA) based on the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) to identify themes regarding user experience and potential clinical utility.

Results

Visual inspection and statistical analysis confirmed that MT can effectively distinguish between different movement directions based on unique strain "fingerprints" across the sensor matrix.

Concurrent Validity

The sensors demonstrated high correlation with motion capture kinematics, particularly when the tape was in tension. Median cross-correlation values were highest for lateral bending (0.87–0.94) and rotation (0.84–0.93). While flexion also showed strong correlation (0.62–0.93), it presented a 41.7% sensor failure rate because the extreme stretch of the low back during deep bending exceeded the sensor's current electrical capacity.

Technical Insights

  • Sensor Dynamics: Performance was superior during stretching (tension) compared to bunching (compression), where signals became noisier. A "rebound effect"—a momentary resistance spike when returning to neutral—was identified as a target for future signal processing improvements.
  • Muscle Engagement: Interestingly, some strain increases did not align perfectly with joint angles. Researchers hypothesize that MT may be detecting "muscle engagement" (the physical bulging of muscles under the skin), providing a physiological metric that traditional motion capture cannot detect.

User Acceptability

User feedback was overwhelmingly positive regarding the sensor's physical properties:

  • Comfort and Security: 100% of participants found the tape secure and the removal process painless.
  • Anatomical Fit: 90% agreed the sensor matrix fit well with their anatomy.
  • Future Needs: Despite the enthusiasm, 70% of users expressed concerns about the current wired data acquisition setup, highlighting the necessity for a fully wireless, integrated system for home use.

Conclusion

This preliminary validation confirms that Motion Tape is a viable, acceptable tool for distinguishing and measuring low back movements. While the current prototype requires optimization for high-strain flexion and wireless connectivity, its ability to provide objective movement data in a low-profile format marks a significant step toward remote physical therapy monitoring. Future research will focus on testing the device in "free-living" environments and with populations currently experiencing low back pain.

Originally published in JMIR Rehabilitation and Assistive Technologies (2024;11:e57953).

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: Low back pain (LBP) is a significant public health problem that can result in physical disability and financial burden for the individual and society. Physical therapy is effective for managing LBP and includes evaluation of posture and movement, interventions directed at modifying posture and movement, and prescription of exercises. However, physical therapists have limited tools for objective evaluation of low back posture and movement and monitoring of exercises, and this evaluation is limited to the time frame of a clinical encounter. There is a need for a valid tool that can be used to evaluate low back posture and movement and monitor exercises outside the clinic. To address this need, a fabric-based, wearable sensor, Motion Tape (MT), was developed and adapted for a low back use case. MT is a low-profile, disposable, self-adhesive, skin-strain sensor developed by spray coating piezoresistive graphene nanocomposites directly onto commercial kinesiology tape.Objective: The objectives of this study were to (1) validate MT for measuring low back posture and movement and (2) assess the acceptability of MT for users.Methods: A total of 10 participants without LBP were tested. A 3D optical motion capture system was used as a reference standard to measure low back kinematics. Retroreflective markers and a matrix of MTs were placed on the low back to measure kinematics (motion capture) and strain (MT) simultaneously during low back movements in the sagittal, frontal, and axial planes. Cross-correlation coefficients were calculated to evaluate the concurrent validity of MT strain in reference motion capture kinematics during each movement. The acceptability of MT was assessed using semistructured interviews conducted with each participant after laboratory testing. Interview data were analyzed using rapid qualitative analysis to identify themes and subthemes of user acceptability.Results: Visual inspection of concurrent MT strain and kinematics of the low back indicated that MT can distinguish between different movement directions. Cross-correlation coefficients between MT strain and motion capture kinematics ranged from –0.915 to 0.983, and the strength of the correlations varied across MT placements and low back movement directions. Regarding user acceptability, participants expressed enthusiasm toward MT and believed that it would be helpful for remote interventions for LBP but provided suggestions for improvement.Conclusions: MT was able to distinguish between different low back movements, and most MTs demonstrated moderate to high correlation with motion capture kinematics. This preliminary laboratory validation of MT provides a basis for future device improvements, which will also involve testing in a free-living environment. Overall, users found MT acceptable for use in physical therapy for managing LBP.JMIR Rehabil Assist Technol 2024;11:e57953doi:10.2196/57953
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lee2024preliminary,
  author = {Audrey Lee and Elijah Wyckoff and Emilia Farcas and Job Godino and Kevin Patrick and Spencer Spiegel and Rose Yu and Arun Kumar and Kenneth J Loh and Sara Gombatto},
  title = {{Preliminary Validity and Acceptability of Motion Tape for Measuring Low Back Movement: Mixed Methods Study}},
  booktitle = {JMIR Rehabilitation and Assistive Technologies},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=U8RnJKLdEW},
}
Figure